Its the risk that most of the list are either unknown quantities, or known to be off the mark to make finals.
Cripps - goes without saying Agree
C. Curnow - looks like a superstar in the making. Disagree. He's a superstar now.
L. O'Brien - looks very capable Unproven kid
P. Dow - also looks very capable Unproven kid
Weitering - he will be pretty solid once they get their act together Regressed kid who looks shaky.
H. McKay - got a bit of something and will get better with more experience. Great foil for Curnow Unproven kid
Z. Fisher - very exciting prospect. Would take him at my club tomorrow. Got a bit of spunk about him. Agree. Looks quality.
Marchbank - can play a role Role players are fine in KPD positions.
Docherty - has been a big loss for them Agree
Plowman - looks ok. Disagree. I'd be surprised if he was on a list if not for the expansion sides and dilution of talent.
SPS - bit of X factor. Unproven kid.
It is feeling like Melbourne pre-Roos/PJ resurgence.
Cripps - goes without saying Agree
C. Curnow - looks like a superstar in the making. Disagree. He's a superstar now.
L. O'Brien - looks very capable Unproven kid
P. Dow - also looks very capable Unproven kid
Weitering - he will be pretty solid once they get their act together Regressed kid who looks shaky.
H. McKay - got a bit of something and will get better with more experience. Great foil for Curnow Unproven kid
Z. Fisher - very exciting prospect. Would take him at my club tomorrow. Got a bit of spunk about him. Agree. Looks quality.
Marchbank - can play a role Role players are fine in KPD positions.
Docherty - has been a big loss for them Agree
Plowman - looks ok. Disagree. I'd be surprised if he was on a list if not for the expansion sides and dilution of talent.
SPS - bit of X factor. Unproven kid.
It is feeling like Melbourne pre-Roos/PJ resurgence.
I would much rather have the Carlton list than GC list

