That is an extremely short sighted view. Promote someone to the senior squad that is disobeying team rules and has not performed the way he should have? He wasn't even showing good form in the WAFL.
Or is it his MCG experience that we value so much? Because if it is I'm pretty sure we could get half of the Dee's squad if we traded them Fyfe. He has barely any MCG Experience.
If we went the Ziffel way and won all our round 4 games at the expense of team discipline and couldn't make or win finals I'm pretty sure we would be a bunch of pissed off supporters. You sound exactly like
E Shed 2 years ago saying that we should abandon the Walters treatment and just play him because he had X factor. It reeks of weak willed desperation imo.
The coaching staff and leadership group will have a set of KPI's that they expect every player to meet in order to play and if they don't meet them they shouldn't be playing.