The best prelim finals since 1995?

JRyan23

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 6, 2016
Posts
3,855
Likes
4,561
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Thread starter #1
As it is Prelim Finals week, what prelims do you think were the 5 best since 1995, (before 1995 isn't really my time)
For me, I would go?
5. Western Bulldogs vs Adelaide 1997
4. Pies v Cats 2007.
3. GWS v Bulldogs 2016
2. Port Adelaide v St Kilda 2004
1. Carlton v Essendon 1999

Honourable mentions: Hawks v Crows 2012, Hawks v Pies 2011, Hawks v Cats 2013, Hawks v Port 2014, Crows v Eagles 2006

What are yours?
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

JRyan23

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 6, 2016
Posts
3,855
Likes
4,561
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Thread starter #4
Port V St Kilda 2004.

G Train kicked his 100, close all game. Bit of Wanganeen brilliance at the end to get Port over the line after previous finals struggles.

Close all night and a nuts crowd. Just what you want in a pre lim.
Yeah that was very close to number one for me, but just the upset Carlton produced, as well as the closeness of the game and the Fraser Brown tackle, just tipped it above Port v Saints
 

Thomas9

ライオンに行く
Joined
Jun 3, 2014
Posts
5,686
Likes
5,791
Location
Sunshine Coast
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
#5
Geelong/Collingwood (2007) will always stand out. 98,002 fans at the MCG on a Friday night - compared to the 97,302 eight days later. The atmosphere just about as electrifying as the football.

Gary Ablett was outstanding - his performance evidence as to why he has a place amongst the all-time greats.
 
Last edited:

adammania9

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Posts
9,087
Likes
17,624
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
University
#9
Stkilda v Dogs 2009 was a fierce close game until the last min.
It's amazing to think in these close games, the loser led during points in the final quarter. Imagine if they kicked another one or two and finished it off. Would completely change history:
- Bulldogs vs St Kilda 2009 PF
- Collingwood vs Brisbane 2002 GF
- Collingwood vs Geelong 2007 PF
- Adelaide vs Hawthorn 2012 PF
- St Kilda vs Collingwood 2010 GF
- St Kilda vs Port Adelaide 2004 PF
are some examples
 

Whiskers

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Posts
5,425
Likes
3,815
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Geelong
#11
Good thread.
Shows just how many absolute classics we have had and is hard to seperate them all.
Taking out my bias, 99 prelim was huge and last year was simply awesome.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Sep 14, 2016
Posts
225
Likes
560
AFL Club
Geelong
#12
As it is Prelim Finals week, what prelims do you think were the 5 best since 1995, (before 1995 isn't really my time)
For me, I would go?
5. Western Bulldogs vs Adelaide 1997
4. Pies v Cats 2007.
3. GWS v Bulldogs 2016
2. Port Adelaide v St Kilda 2004
1. Carlton v Essendon 1999

Honourable mentions: Hawks v Crows 2012, Hawks v Pies 2011, Hawks v Cats 2013, Hawks v Port 2014, Crows v Eagles 2006

What are yours?
Biased, because I was there and I am a cats fan, but that pies v cats game in 2007 was amazing. 98,002. Close all game, good football being played and crowd was electric.

The noise in the last five minutes gave me shivers.
 

ep2018

Bigfooty Pessimist
Joined
Sep 16, 2006
Posts
24,994
Likes
19,989
AFL Club
West Coast
#17
West Coast vs Adelaide 06 was up there. No one gave WC a chance and all in Adelaide thought at half time they were through to the GF.
We went into the game as favourites iirc. We had beaten them twice that year already and they had injuries. I thought at half time we were a chance to run over them, and then it happened lol. I remember at the time the oddity of being favourite to win the PF yet Adelaide were still favourites for the flag. Winning a prelim final away from home is a great achievement and its one of my favourite footy memories.
 

demondavey

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 18, 2005
Posts
18,126
Likes
13,906
AFL Club
Melbourne
#18
I'm gonna cheat and go back to 1994.

5. Hawthorn v Geelong 2013
4. Geelong v Collingwood 2007
3. Collingwood v Hawthorn 2011
2. Essendon v Carlton 1999
1. North Melbourne v Geelong 1994
Agree. North v Geelong was huge. I think we missed out on a potentially great GF between two of the great sides of the 90's. WC v North. For me;

1. WB v Adelaide 97 - never seen a better comeback. Ever.
2. North v Geelong 94
3. Adelaide v Essendon 93
4. Sydney v Essendon 96
5. Adelaide v WC 06
6. Essendon v Carlton 99
7. Hawthorn v Geelong 13
8. Geelong v Collingwood 07
9. Hawthorn v Adelaide 12
10. Brisbane v Sydney 03

There were some stellar comebacks in some of those games, none more than the 97 Preliminary Final. What Adelaide did was unbelievable. What a side.

1993 also gets a mention, the Bombers put together an amazing resurgence to power home. Adelaide were dynamic that day but the baby Bombers were relentless - cue the GF the week later.

In 2003 I watched an amazing comeback by the Lions, again, like Adelaide, what a side. And a great victory to put them in a GF.
 
Last edited:

iluvparis

Premium Platinum
Joined
Apr 1, 2005
Posts
25,871
Likes
17,637
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Calgary Flames, Man Utd
#19
We went into the game as favourites iirc. We had beaten them twice that year already and they had injuries. I thought at half time we were a chance to run over them, and then it happened lol. I remember at the time the oddity of being favourite to win the PF yet Adelaide were still favourites for the flag. Winning a prelim final away from home is a great achievement and its one of my favourite footy memories.
Lol there is zero chance that would have been the case - think about basic probability for a minute.
 

jwint43

All Australian
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Posts
897
Likes
1,240
AFL Club
St Kilda
#20
I love prelims. You basically get 2 Grand finals the week before the big one and at least one is a classic each year. Only have memories from 2000ish onwards so for me the best ones are Coll/Hawk 2011, Coll/Geelong 07, Saints/Dogs 09, Hawks/Geelong 13, Crows/WC 06, Hawks vs Crows and Hawks Port. Now that I look at it, the Hawks had so many crazy prelims. Just shows how impressive it was they went b2b2b.

Hawks v Geelong is probably the best because of the hype leading up to it. Geelong were on that massive win streak which the hawks were desperate to break and the Hawks were seeking vengeance after losing in 2012 and knew another loss against Geelong in such a big game would have been devastating, and they looked cooked going into the last quarter. They may have never won another flag if they lost this game. Only bad thing about it was that it was so loud at the end the players couldn't hear the siren, so it was a bit awkward at the end, but that's nitpicking.

*Also special mention to Freo/Syd 2013, not the closest or highest level of skill but you will never see more relentless pressure and desire than what the Dockers showed that game. I was in shock. That was Ross Lyon's masterpiece.
 

GreatBradScott

Good Morning, Hell-A.
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Posts
7,420
Likes
15,667
Location
California
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Manchester City, Melbourne Victory
#21
It's honestly my favourite week of the season. Everything on the line and you're more likely than not to get a belter that goes very close to being a classic.

Carlton v Essendon 99, Cats v Pies 07, Hawks v Cats 13, Dogs v Giants 16.

Bring on the weekend.
 
Top Bottom