The Big 4- Who is the best

[happy_eagle]

Arguably the 4 biggest footy journo's in this country are

Caroline Wilson (The Age)
Mike Sheehan (Herald Sun)
Patrick Smith (The Austalian)
Mark Robinson (Herald Sun)


Who do we all think is the best, or in some cases the least worst

 

[aaronm46]

4 hideous, hideous human beings

 

[saj_21]

Sheehan is easily, he makes his point and does not continue to beat his drum weeks upon weeks like Caro and Smith do. Robbo is alright but i do not think his insight into the game is a good as sheehan.

 

[Hoops]

Arguably the 4 biggest footy journo's in this country are

Caroline Wilson (The Age)
Mike Sheehan (Herald Sun)
Patrick Smith (The Austalian)
Mark Robinson (Herald Sun)


Who do we all think is the best, or in some cases the least worst

Mark Robinson - Journalist? LOL

 

[goal sneak]

Mike Sheehan by so far it's not funny. It will be a shame when he retires.

 

[Papa G]

Surely Michangelo Rucci....

Nah probably Sheehan is the best of a bad bunch. Actually talks more about football than the issues surronding football.

 

[BacharHouli_43]

Mike Sheehan by default... the rest are some of the worst journo's in the business. Sheehan at least does not need to resort to gutter journalism whereas the same could not be said about the others

 

[anti.]

digby beecham?
mark duffield?
kim hagdorn?
jay clark?

damn those are some bad journo's.

 

[Il Naso De Gastev]

You can tell by the way he writes that Sheahan actually pulled on the boots and played the game.

Did Robinson ever play anywhere??

 

[Bomber32]

Mike Sheahan easily.

 

[The Teflon Dean]

Mike Sheahan easily.

By the length of the Flemington straight.

In fact this thread should be renamed "The Big 1"

 

[aaronm46]

of list makers?

 

[Strawbs]

Mark Robinson - Journalist? LOL

Exactly. Classic Herald-Sun crap artist. Sheahan at least talks some sense, Wilson breaks some exclusives as does Patrick Smith. Can't stand Robinson's articles and his radio and TV work - can listen to him for even less time than I can stand reading his stuff - and that's saying something.