The BigFooty Liverpool Army

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BlueBen

Premiership Player
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Posts
4,663
Likes
3,463
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Liverpool
And we spent £20m on Markovic, £150k/week on Milner etc..

The best and most successful sides have multiple quality options in each position. If we want to be one of the best sides we can't be satisfied with relying on a couple of £5-10m signings to consistently perform to a high standard if our nominal starters aren't fit, we need quality and obviously that sort of quality is going to cost more.

Fortunately Lallana is of that standard and we can happily rotate he, Coutinho or Sterling through those attacking midfield positions throughout the course of the season without suffering a significant drop off in quality in that part of the field. Personally I've got no issue with Lallana or the price we paid for him (£20-25m is pretty standard going for any half decent footballer in that part of the field these days) and thought he actually had a pretty good season. Unfortunately the output of creative players like him is generally a function of the potency of the striker they're feeding. No doubt the likes of Lallana, Coutinho & Sterling were stunted this season by the lack of a legitimate goalscorer ahead of them.

Looks like we're doing our best to correct that deficiency in terms of adding quality, movement and goals in the final third this window though which is great to see. With that in mind I think I'm going to enjoy watching you eat humble pie re: Lallana next season! :D
I hope he does mate, if it means that the team performs well.

Again, I've never said that he can't play. And I understand the signing from a playing style standpoint. I've expressed my opinion that he is a Joe Cole/Yossi Benayoun sort of player, a useful squad player but not a stand-out or someone who is good enough to be a central player for a side that has aspirations of challenging for major honours.

But I don't think paying £25m for him represents anything like value in any transfer market under any market conditions. He was grossly overpriced and if we were so intent on signing an attacking midfielder then I think we could have got the same sort of player from other European leagues for half or even less than half of what we paid for Lallana. But we were (and perhaps, still are) obsessed with buying "Premier League proven" players, as if that automatically meant "capable of performing at the top level".

A £25m signing should be a nailed-on first-teamer, particularly when we don't, unlike the other top sides, already have the nailed-on first-teamers in place. £25m should get you a genuine difference-maker. Of course, that's not Lallana's fault and I'm not blaming him. But £25m should get you more than a squad player. I just think it was a poor allocation of resources.
 
Joined
Jun 24, 2015
Posts
22
Likes
48
AFL Club
Essendon
I hope he does mate, if it means that the team performs well.

Again, I've never said that he can't play. And I understand the signing from a playing style standpoint. I've expressed my opinion that he is a Joe Cole/Yossi Benayoun sort of player, a useful squad player but not a stand-out or someone who is good enough to be a central player for a side that has aspirations of challenging for major honours.

But I don't think paying £25m for him represents anything like value in any transfer market under any market conditions. He was grossly overpriced and if we were so intent on signing an attacking midfielder then I think we could have got the same sort of player from other European leagues for half or even less than half of what we paid for Lallana. But we were (and perhaps, still are) obsessed with buying "Premier League proven" players, as if that automatically meant "capable of performing at the top level".

A £25m signing should be a nailed-on first-teamer, particularly when we don't, unlike the other top sides, already have the nailed-on first-teamers in place. £25m should get you a genuine difference-maker. Of course, that's not Lallana's fault and I'm not blaming him. But £25m should get you more than a squad player. I just think it was a poor allocation of resources.
Pretty much agree with all this but I'd say the money should've gone to a striker more specifically

Unfortunately we don't have the resources to spend 25 mil on a player and for him not to start most games (75-80%), gotta invest wisely

Lallana's a good player, don't get us wrong, but just don't think he is "greeeat". Pretty sure jod and I were wanting Firmino instead of him last summer, but all's well that ends well :)
 

Papermate

Premiership Player
Joined
Mar 11, 2012
Posts
4,058
Likes
4,725
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Liverpool, New England, Stanford
You won't find it, it was all deleted.

Unluckily for mods, we still see deleted posts ffs :mad:

I have no idea which thread it was in and I'm really glad about that. We definitely don't need that to come up again!
Was it worse than the time we found him posing with a Pikachu doll?
 

BlueBen

Premiership Player
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Posts
4,663
Likes
3,463
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Liverpool
Pretty much agree with all this but I'd say the money should've gone to a striker more specifically

Unfortunately we don't have the resources to spend 25 mil on a player and for him not to start most games (75-80%), gotta invest wisely

Lallana's a good player, don't get us wrong, but just don't think he is "greeeat". Pretty sure jod and I were wanting Firmino instead of him last summer, but all's well that ends well :)
Welcome back mate. :thumbsu:

That's pretty much it - you put it a lot more succinctly than I did! Haha.

To think that we spent a combined £45m on Lallana and Lovren! :cry:
 

Cooldude

Hall of Famer
Joined
Dec 12, 2003
Posts
44,236
Likes
21,714
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Bombers/Liverpool FC
Welcome back mate. :thumbsu:

That's pretty much it - you put it a lot more succinctly than I did! Haha.

To think that we spent a combined £45m on Lallana and Lovren! :cry:
Yes I agree with Coooldude, too :)

Good to be back in old skin

And let's make Ilori third choice and Lovren can fold the kits pre game. Watched the Palace game, not sure how every Palace player looked like Messi/Ronaldo as soon as they were 1v1 with Lovren

Having said all that about buying Soton players, it'd be nice to get Clyne for the price quoted

PS: Thanks mate, hope you've been well
 
Last edited:

ADL9798

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Posts
11,262
Likes
12,149
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Liverpool
I hope he does mate, if it means that the team performs well.

Again, I've never said that he can't play. And I understand the signing from a playing style standpoint. I've expressed my opinion that he is a Joe Cole/Yossi Benayoun sort of player, a useful squad player but not a stand-out or someone who is good enough to be a central player for a side that has aspirations of challenging for major honours.

But I don't think paying £25m for him represents anything like value in any transfer market under any market conditions. He was grossly overpriced and if we were so intent on signing an attacking midfielder then I think we could have got the same sort of player from other European leagues for half or even less than half of what we paid for Lallana. But we were (and perhaps, still are) obsessed with buying "Premier League proven" players, as if that automatically meant "capable of performing at the top level".

A £25m signing should be a nailed-on first-teamer, particularly when we don't, unlike the other top sides, already have the nailed-on first-teamers in place. £25m should get you a genuine difference-maker. Of course, that's not Lallana's fault and I'm not blaming him. But £25m should get you more than a squad player. I just think it was a poor allocation of resources.
But this is the crux of it I think. The fact that we didn't sign a star striker is constantly used as a stick to beat Lallana with, and I think it's unfair to set the goalposts like that for him. He's a very, very good footballer, and no he's not going to score 20 goals a season, but then that's not what he was signed for (that was supposedly Balotelli's job!).

Had we signed a striker that had actually done their job (just for something different!), then I guarantee that no-one would have had any complaints whatsoever about the Lallana signing because as I said, while he didn't light up the league as he did in 2013/14, he didn't actually have a bad season all things considered. His only flaw is that we were all expecting a Luis Suarez replacement to be signed last summer, and he isn't Luis Suarez. The fact that we didn't sign Alexis Sanchez doesn't make Lallana a bad signing, and quite clearly given we submitted a £30m+ offer for Sanchez after signing Lallana, from a financial perspective at least we were perfectly capable of signing both in the same window so resource allocation doesn't really come into it either.

And yes he's behind £50m Sterling and £40m(?) Coutinho in the pecking order for attacking midfield spots, but I'd say that if you look at any side that has aspirations of challenging for major honours in any league, they would all have players of Lallana's calibre (and probably Lallana's price) ready to come off the bench and have an impact or rotate into the first team in the event of long term injuries at a moment's notice. A £25m signing is only a nailed on first teamer if you don't already have attackers who are more valuable and of greater quality in that position (as we do). If Chelsea signed a £25m striker, would he be guaranteed to start ahead of Costa? Even saying that, Lallana still made 40+ appearances too which was a pretty decent return given he was injured for the first 2 months of the season (which is why I don't think it makes sense to categorize players as 'starters' and 'subs', because that classification obviously changes throughout the season as form fluctuates).

I just don't get it, I'm really not seeing what the issue is with Lallana. For me the issue is that we signed Balotelli for £16m and £100k+/week instead of a top quality forward who fits the way we play and actually puts the ball in the back of the net, that's the mistake we should be directing our anger at.
 

Dagger5

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Apr 12, 2009
Posts
7,282
Likes
419
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Liverpool, Dallas Cowboys
I know our CB's are much maligned but could it be that the goalkeeper behind them is just as useless at helping organising them? I don't trust Mignolet one bit, he just doesn't inspire any confidence. If we could concede less then we wouldn't need to rely on scoring at least 2 goals every match.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

kane249

New cup, who dis?
Joined
Oct 27, 2006
Posts
39,989
Likes
37,000
Location
Behind enemy Lines
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Sth Freo, Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
where art thou padman? Can't find him on the system. Must be permabanned. Probably had a meltdown during one of our many frustrating matches last season.
Yeah I think he got permabanned again. With the amount of cards he picked up he probably exceeded his total points quota and qualified for a perma.
 

Cooldude

Hall of Famer
Joined
Dec 12, 2003
Posts
44,236
Likes
21,714
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Bombers/Liverpool FC
I just don't get it, I'm really not seeing what the issue is with Lallana. For me the issue is that we signed Balotelli for £16m and £100k+/week instead of a top quality forward who fits the way we play and actually puts the ball in the back of the net, that's the mistake we should be directing our anger at.
I think the problem with Lallana is, he's good on the ball, but he often takes too many touches to do something. He is not slow but he is not quick either. He misses some glaringly simple chances then takes a good goal. He floats aimless airy crosses too many times then suddenly plays a good throughball. He basically is jack of all trades master of none

I think he's more in line with a Dirk Kuyt, except Derek had more goals in him and Lallana has a better touch. Decent and very likeable player who is never gonna do anything groundbreaking. and Dirk cost wha 8 mil?

Mario gets a lot of stick and rightly so but even AC Milan got a lot more out of him than we did, somewhere along the line the club has to take some of the blame as well

Basically our transfer business's been bad, which is why I'm curious as to whether the committee still exists and who is doing the business now
 
Last edited:

BlueBen

Premiership Player
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Posts
4,663
Likes
3,463
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Liverpool
But this is the crux of it I think. The fact that we didn't sign a star striker is constantly used as a stick to beat Lallana with, and I think it's unfair to set the goalposts like that for him. He's a very, very good footballer, and no he's not going to score 20 goals a season, but then that's not what he was signed for (that was supposedly Balotelli's job!).

Had we signed a striker that had actually done their job (just for something different!), then I guarantee that no-one would have had any complaints whatsoever about the Lallana signing because as I said, while he didn't light up the league as he did in 2013/14, he didn't actually have a bad season all things considered. His only flaw is that we were all expecting a Luis Suarez replacement to be signed last summer, and he isn't Luis Suarez. The fact that we didn't sign Alexis Sanchez doesn't make Lallana a bad signing, and quite clearly given we submitted a £30m+ offer for Sanchez after signing Lallana, from a financial perspective at least we were perfectly capable of signing both in the same window so resource allocation doesn't really come into it either.

And yes he's behind £50m Sterling and £40m(?) Coutinho in the pecking order for attacking midfield spots, but I'd say that if you look at any side that has aspirations of challenging for major honours in any league, they would all have players of Lallana's calibre (and probably Lallana's price) ready to come off the bench and have an impact or rotate into the first team in the event of long term injuries at a moment's notice. A £25m signing is only a nailed on first teamer if you don't already have attackers who are more valuable and of greater quality in that position (as we do). If Chelsea signed a £25m striker, would he be guaranteed to start ahead of Costa? Even saying that, Lallana still made 40+ appearances too which was a pretty decent return given he was injured for the first 2 months of the season (which is why I don't think it makes sense to categorize players as 'starters' and 'subs', because that classification obviously changes throughout the season as form fluctuates).

I just don't get it, I'm really not seeing what the issue is with Lallana. For me the issue is that we signed Balotelli for £16m and £100k+/week instead of a top quality forward who fits the way we play and actually puts the ball in the back of the net, that's the mistake we should be directing our anger at.
Fair enough mate, you obviously rate him more highly than I do, which is fine.

And again, the problem isn't with Lallana as such - he didn't demand that we spend £25m on him! The problem in my opinion is that he was not an absolutely necessary signing, and yet one for which we nevertheless forked out £25m (our second most expensive transfer outlay for a player), and that if we were intent on signing a player like him then we could have got far better value for our money elsewhere.

And I don't think anyone would claim that Balotelli has been a good transfer. But at the time it appeared low-risk and value for money, even though it obviously hasn't worked out.
 

jod23

TheBrownDog
Joined
Apr 2, 2000
Posts
61,500
Likes
17,887
Location
Perth, Australia
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Emre Can picking up some rave reviews after another very good game for Germany U21 in a 1-1 draw with the Czech Republic which sends the Germans through to the semi finals of the U21 Euros. At this stage he's on track to be named in the team of the tournament alongside Portugal's Carvalho in midfield.
Careful ADL9798

We've just signed Firmino. This kinda talk on my boy Emre.

Well my dick cant get any harder so...
 

jod23

TheBrownDog
Joined
Apr 2, 2000
Posts
61,500
Likes
17,887
Location
Perth, Australia
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Amidst news of the signing of Brazilian forward Roberto Firmino, Gianluca Di Marzio reported that Liverpool had also begun talks with Inter Milan over midfielder Mateo Kovacic.


The 21 year old Croatian midfielder looks set to leave Inter Milan this summer with the club demanding a €30m fee for his services.




Respected Italian journalist Gianluca Di Marzio believes the €30 (£21.3m) fee will not scare off Liverpool at the negotiation table.
Seriously, what did I just say about my dick not being able to get any harder than it already is.

Would be epic if we got him too. Then just a balls deep striker and a RB, hopefully Clyne and we are good to go next season!
 
Last edited:

jod23

TheBrownDog
Joined
Apr 2, 2000
Posts
61,500
Likes
17,887
Location
Perth, Australia
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
jod23 you must be ecstatic, have been demanding Firmino for probably 12 months
Yep I have championed him for a loooong time. These were the events that took place.

So first off this is me in front of my computer when first hearing the news.



I then immediately turned to my roommate who also is a huge Red and this happened.



Then after the shock kind of died down, I began to get happy.



Which in turn, turned into this...



Then this happened.



Then the happiness died down.



Because I got emotional.



Then after pulling myself together I went outside and my day kinda just went like this.

 
Last edited:

jod23

TheBrownDog
Joined
Apr 2, 2000
Posts
61,500
Likes
17,887
Location
Perth, Australia
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Yes I agree with Coooldude, too :)

Good to be back in old skin

And let's make Ilori third choice and Lovren can fold the kits pre game. Watched the Palace game, not sure how every Palace player looked like Messi/Ronaldo as soon as they were 1v1 with Lovren

Having said all that about buying Soton players, it'd be nice to get Clyne for the price quoted

PS: Thanks mate, hope you've been well
CD!

So good to see you my man. Welcome back! Glad to hear things are ok with your Dad. We were all thinking of you whilst you were away.

Excellent timing for your return as this transfer window so far is going quite swimmingly.
 

Milenko

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Nov 7, 2003
Posts
5,991
Likes
3,932
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
LiverpoolFC | Golden State Warriors
4-3-3

Bacca (/Studge)
Firmino Coutino
Hendo Milner Can
Moreno Sakho Skrtel Clyne

4-4-2 diamond

Bacca (/Studge) Firmino
Coutino
Hendo Milner
Can
Moreno Sakho Skrtel Clyne
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom