The biggest "What could've been?"

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #1
There are many sliding door moments throughout VFL/AFL history that make you think, "What could have been?". From players, to administrative, what are some that stand out in your mind?

Original VFL Park Capacity
Having the train line extended to the stadium and the full plans for the stadium capacity fulfilled, would it be hosting the Grand Final from now on? 150,000 fans packed out in the eastern suburbs could have been possible if the infrastructure supported it. Or would it have been the great white elephant for the VFL?

Promotion/Relegation National League
There was talk sometimes in the 50s to have a national league that incorporated promotion/relegation from the state leagues. Would that have been the more ideal setup to the eventual VFL/AFL transition? Would this have been your preferred method?

Nathan Ablett Retiring
This is just one for cats fans, but a young player with so much potential and promise pulls the plug early on his career. What would it have meant for the Cats group of 2008+ if he was still playing? I always feel it would have made our 2008 campaign a bit better without having to play Lonergan forward.

What else is there?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Nov 23, 2016
Posts
10,562
Likes
6,890
AFL Club
GWS
#2
There are many sliding door moments throughout VFL/AFL history that make you think, "What could have been?". From players, to administrative, what are some that stand out in your mind?



Promotion/Relegation National League
There was talk sometimes in the 50s to have a national league that incorporated promotion/relegation from the state leagues. Would that have been the more ideal setup to the eventual VFL/AFL transition? Would this have been your preferred method?



What else is there?
This idea is fascinating and it would have allowed a pathway to thrive fir the once great state league clubs. Great for the SANFL, WAFL and the VFL, which are inevitably declining to the point rhey'll have to be supported by the AFL to keep grass roots footy alive as a nursery for players. Or perhaps the hunger for talent by the AFL will eventually make them irrelevant with a seoarate pathway for the elite which is starting to happen now.

Couldn't be done with the draft though or clubs stepping up would fall down before they could develop talent to sustain themselves at the elite level.

The Northern states who cant sustain a competition to the required level would never be able to participate at the elite level.
 

telsor

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 29, 2004
Posts
30,057
Likes
26,490
Location
Here
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Habs
#5
Original VFL Park Capacity
Having the train line extended to the stadium and the full plans for the stadium capacity fulfilled, would it be hosting the Grand Final from now on? 150,000 fans packed out in the eastern suburbs could have been possible if the infrastructure supported it. Or would it have been the great white elephant for the VFL?
It was out of the way an difficult to get to when it was the VFL.

Roll forward to the AFL, and imagine interstate teams fans trying to get there for the grand final.

For good or ill, the central location of the MCG is a massive benefit, but especially for those from other states.
 

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #7
This idea is fascinating and it would have allowed a pathway to thrive fir the once great state league clubs. Great for the SANFL, WAFL and the VFL, which are inevitably declining to the point rhey'll have to be supported by the AFL to keep grass roots footy alive as a nursery for players. Or perhaps the hunger for talent by the AFL will eventually make them irrelevant with a seoarate pathway for the elite which is starting to happen now.

Couldn't be done with the draft though or clubs stepping up would fall down before they could develop talent to sustain themselves at the elite level.

The Northern states who cant sustain a competition to the required level would never be able to participate at the elite level.
Yeah, the Northern states would be the hardest part to sustain. People wouldn't go because it wasn't the elite competition, creating a larger divide to the established state competitions. It was much easier to set up a single club in NSW/QLD compared to setting up an entire competition to many levels.

I wonder what would happen if a lower club with a star player dropped back down to the state league. Would that club be able to retain them? Would that create the yo-yo effect that some clubs have in the premier league of forever bouncing back and forth between divisions?
 

Proper Gander

Owl whisperer and secret agent
Joined
Feb 15, 2015
Posts
15,087
Likes
24,384
Location
Port Melbourne
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Mt Buller Demons
#9
If ... Melbourne had merged with Hawthorn

then ...

We would have stuffed them up somehow, anyhow. There would be no dynasty - the hybrid would have ended up on the Gold Coast and we would have lost to Port in China because Cale Morton
 

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #10
It was out of the way an difficult to get to when it was the VFL.

Roll forward to the AFL, and imagine interstate teams fans trying to get there for the grand final.

For good or ill, the central location of the MCG is a massive benefit, but especially for those from other states.
I think at the time of proposal, there was definitely the train station that was meant to be build near the stadium and I think there was talk of an eastern suburbs airport. If the Grand Final was locked in to VFL park before the competition became national, but became national in the same way, it might have been in the better interest of the the Victorian government to invest more in the infrastructure to make it accessible.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Cooksen

Moderator
Joined
Jun 18, 2011
Posts
33,052
Likes
49,803
Location
Flying On A Prawn
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Man Utd, NE Pats
Moderator #12
How was that proposed to happen? A re-draw of the zones every year?
The country zones were to be roated around every year to ensure that no club could dominate but 2 clubs Hawthorn and Carlton did not want to be rotated because they had the best zones.
 

telsor

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 29, 2004
Posts
30,057
Likes
26,490
Location
Here
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Habs
#13
I think at the time of proposal, there was definitely the train station that was meant to be build near the stadium and I think there was talk of an eastern suburbs airport. If the Grand Final was locked in to VFL park before the competition became national, but became national in the same way, it might have been in the better interest of the the Victorian government to invest more in the infrastructure to make it accessible.
Rail line, sure, an eastern airport would be past Dandenong, so not that beneficial, and then there is all the rest of the infrastructure...hotels, restaurants, bars, etc etc etc. It's just too far from all those things.
 

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #14
The country zones were to be roated around every year to ensure that no club could dominate but 2 clubs Hawthorn and Carlton did not want to be rotated because they had the best zones.
Zoning was always terrible and the draft is a much easier system to manage. If it was clear that certain zones were generating better players, they could have merged the 2 ideas to give lower clubs the choice to pick up a player from ANY zone. 2nd bottom might mean everything expect the best zone, or perhaps the previous zone wouldn't be available.
 

telsor

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 29, 2004
Posts
30,057
Likes
26,490
Location
Here
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Habs
#15
The country zones were to be roated around every year to ensure that no club could dominate but 2 clubs Hawthorn and Carlton did not want to be rotated because they had the best zones.
The other side of it was that the clubs were supposed to help with development in their zones, and that was never going to happen if the zones rotated.

Moving the boundaries was more likely/possible.
 

TheUndertaker

The Phenom from Death Valley
Joined
Oct 2, 2008
Posts
6,792
Likes
9,486
Location
Death Valley
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Brothers of Destruction
#16
What if...

North Melbourne has relocated to the GC? Would they have bastardised further with another move to Tasmania?

Fitzroy had always stuck with their 'Gorilla' name, would they have the opportunity to re-enter the league as the Fitzroy Gorillas?

What If Fitzroy survived up until the new television rights deal came through?

What if everyone finds out what Essendon's original nickname was?... it's not pretty, let me tell ya...
 

Aramis

Premiership Player
Joined
Jul 31, 2016
Posts
3,524
Likes
7,164
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#17
All Hawthorn's wasted high picks in the mid 2000's....
2005 Draft
Pick 3 - Xavier Ellis... chosen over Scott Pendlebury and Josh Kennedy (WCE)
Pick 6 - Beau Dowler... chosen over Paddy Ryder, Nathan Jones and Shannon Hurn
2006 Draft
Pick 6 - Mitch Thorp... chosen over Joel Selwood, David Armitage and Jack Riewoldt
Pick 24 - Brent Renouf... chosen over Kurt Tippett, Tom Hawkins, Todd Goldstein and Robbie Gray
2007 Draft
Pick 29 - Brendan Whitecross... chosen over Jack Steven and Easton Wood

One final one that hurts is 2010 Draft...
Pick 38 - Mitch Hallahan to Hawthorn
Pick 40 - Luke Parker to Sydney..... :'(:'(:'(
 

Young Gun #6

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 24, 2008
Posts
5,645
Likes
3,779
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Juventus, Suns
#20
What if Moore kicked that shot or Hodge wasn't incorrectly awarded holding the ball in the 2014 prelim. No 3 peat, No 2 peat, Hawks discussed very differently and Port win a premiership as the only team outside the top 4 in the current system without a bye week.
 

Ed_Gein

You are nex !
Joined
Dec 17, 2003
Posts
14,975
Likes
5,501
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
LFC, BVB, Rangers, Valencia, Storm
#25
Paul Kelly kick to Lockett that fell just short of him taking a chest mark about 30m out in the second qtr of the 96 grand final. He would have been lining up to give us a 4-5 goal lead but as it turns out the ball spilt free and north goaled 20 seconds later. Huge shift in momentum and north never looked back from then on. A real 12 pointer.

Always wonder how far we could have went had Lockett marked and goaled as north were very much on the backfoot .
 
Top Bottom