The biggest "What could've been?"

Marmozet

Premium Gold
Joined
Apr 10, 2014
Posts
10,483
Likes
21,323
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#76
- Franklin stayed at Hawthorn
- There wasn't a bye pre-2016 finals
- If drawn Grand Finals went into extra time back in 2010
- Collingwood got past Geelong in the 2007 PF
- Port Adelaide didn't keep choking in the early 2000s
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Syd

Kiss my Assterisk*
Joined
Mar 13, 2003
Posts
19,855
Likes
7,383
Location
Die Kaffeeklatch
AFL Club
Sydney
#77
Paul Kelly kick to Lockett that fell just short of him taking a chest mark about 30m out in the second qtr of the 96 grand final. He would have been lining up to give us a 4-5 goal lead but as it turns out the ball spilt free and north goaled 20 seconds later. Huge shift in momentum and north never looked back from then on. A real 12 pointer.

Always wonder how far we could have went had Lockett marked and goaled as north were very much on the backfoot .
Conversely Plugger marks and goals and we win '96 do we get the Bloods era and 2005 and 2012?
 

Ed_Gein

You are nex !
Joined
Dec 17, 2003
Posts
14,978
Likes
5,501
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
LFC, BVB, Rangers, Valencia, Storm
#79
Conversely Plugger marks and goals and we win '96 do we get the Bloods era and 2005 and 2012?
Never know. But Eade was spent by the time he left which was 6 years later, not sure how much he could have built on '96 had we won it.

The big what if in regards to 05 and 12 is would they have happened had we gone ahead with Terry Wallace instead of Roos
 
Last edited:

Total_Juddshanks

Premiership Player
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Posts
4,163
Likes
3,778
Location
Fee
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
The good ones
#80
What if Ben Cousins, six months sober and being regularly drug tested, didn't do his hamstring in the third quarter of the 2007 QF against port?

Immediate consequences

- West coast win that game instead of losing by 3 pts to the eventual grand finalist

- With cousins kerr and judd, whose chronic OP benefits from the extra week of rest, west coast dismember north in the PF, and make a third successive grand final, where their experience on the big day easily accounts for untested Geelong on 29 September 2017.

- Mainwaring is not home alone on 1 October 2017, he's in Melbourne covering a fourth eagles premiership for ch 7, and flying back to attend the victory rally at subi.
 

Boxhead_31

Rompinwins is my Chauffeur
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Posts
32,466
Likes
41,693
Location
This Drinking Team has a Football Problem
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
South BHFL, 49ers
#82
Travis Varcoe kicks the goal at the end of the 2013 prelim. I reckon we beat Geelong and all the Ross Lyon threads on big footy aren't created and Chief has one less luxury car.

Morabito - many freo fans would've said at the end of 2010 he'd have a better career than Fyfe.
Wouldn't that have just forced extra time?
 

Boxhead_31

Rompinwins is my Chauffeur
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Posts
32,466
Likes
41,693
Location
This Drinking Team has a Football Problem
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
South BHFL, 49ers
#83
What if Ben Cousins, six months sober and being regularly drug tested, didn't do his hamstring in the third quarter of the 2007 QF against port?

Immediate consequences

- West coast win that game instead of losing by 3 pts to the eventual grand finalist

- With cousins kerr and judd, whose chronic OP benefits from the extra week of rest, west coast dismember north in the PF, and make a third successive grand final, where their experience on the big day easily accounts for untested Geelong on 29 September 2017.

- Mainwaring is not home alone on 1 October 2017, he's in Melbourne covering a fourth eagles premiership for ch 7, and flying back to attend the victory rally at subi.
What if Ben Cousins said yes to Geelong's Father Son offer and got away from the influences in Perth that lead him down the self-destructive path?
 

BigVic

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 7, 2009
Posts
2,420
Likes
1,101
Location
Bull Creek WA
AFL Club
West Coast
#84
What if Stephen Milne kicked the goal in the 2010 Drawn Grand final.
Jack Darling marks in the 2015 Grand Final
Lynch caught holding the ball in the dying seconds of the 2006 Grand Final
No Scarlett toepoke
Ben Cousins healthy all of 2007
 

Syd

Kiss my Assterisk*
Joined
Mar 13, 2003
Posts
19,855
Likes
7,383
Location
Die Kaffeeklatch
AFL Club
Sydney
#85
Never know. But Eade was spent by the time he left which was 6 years later, not sure how much he could have built on '96 had we won it.

The big what if in regards to 05 and 12 is would they have happened had we gone ahead with Terry Wallace instead of Roos
Eade could've been Clarkson...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Wallaby

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 8, 2007
Posts
8,299
Likes
8,737
Location
vic
AFL Club
Richmond
#88
And we hadn't have sacked Norm Smith......
Richmond won the flag in 74. Made prelim final in 75. Missed finals in 76 (still won 10 games).

So - 4-time premiership coach out the door after one year of missing finals. Goes to Collingwood and gets them from the Wooden spoon to a drawn GF in his first year (admittedly, 1976 was the only time Collingwood missed finals from 69-81, so they weren't that bad).

If Hafey had stayed on at Richmond, and won the 80 GF with Mark Lee (age 21), Dale Weightman (20), Michael Roach (21) and the rest - we could have won a couple more along the way.............................
 

King Brown

Club Legend
Joined
Aug 12, 2017
Posts
2,582
Likes
3,650
AFL Club
Essendon
#89
All Hawthorn's wasted high picks in the mid 2000's....
2005 Draft
Pick 3 - Xavier Ellis... chosen over Scott Pendlebury and Josh Kennedy (WCE)
Pick 6 - Beau Dowler... chosen over Paddy Ryder, Nathan Jones and Shannon Hurn
2006 Draft
Pick 6 - Mitch Thorp... chosen over Joel Selwood, David Armitage and Jack Riewoldt
Pick 24 - Brent Renouf... chosen over Kurt Tippett, Tom Hawkins, Todd Goldstein and Robbie Gray
2007 Draft
Pick 29 - Brendan Whitecross... chosen over Jack Steven and Easton Wood

One final one that hurts is 2010 Draft...
Pick 38 - Mitch Hallahan to Hawthorn
Pick 40 - Luke Parker to Sydney..... :'(:'(:'(
Every club has these - you've done better than most in drafting.
 

HeathComeBack

Premiership Player
Joined
Mar 17, 2014
Posts
4,003
Likes
3,241
AFL Club
Collingwood
#91
What if JPod doesnt get injured and goes off in the 2011 Grand Final.
Collingwood arguably wins the premiership, succession plan out the window. MM stays for a few more years , players stay because they get on with MM, we have a totally different looking list and we may have won 2 to 3 premierships in the meantime,
meanwhile... ughh
 

adammania9

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Posts
9,096
Likes
17,633
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
University
#92
What if Steve Johnson passed his Collingwood medical in 2006?

The Pies might have won the 2007 premiership instead of Geelong, the Buckley succession plan never would have happened, 2010 might not have been won if Malthouse knew his long term future was at Collingwood and not topped up on Ball+Jolly. Geelong's success might never have been built if they didn't win 2007 and as such, Gary Ablett Jr never would have left for the Suns who might have recruited Kurt Tippett instead and the Crows wouldn't have had their salary cap saga and had picks stripped.

I'm overthinking this.
 
Joined
May 30, 2012
Posts
2,537
Likes
2,608
Location
-
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#94
Freo easily. Geelong were cooked at the end of the PF. Hate to see how the GF that year would have gone for the Cats. Grateful that Hawthorn won as we'd never hear the end of a freo flag...
Geelong were cooked at the end of that prelim exactly, so the Hawks would have won extra time and still managed to beat Free the next week.
 

magpienato

The Swooping Magpie
Joined
Oct 27, 2016
Posts
2,893
Likes
3,257
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Toronto Raptors,Melbourne Renegades
#97
Promotion/Relegation National League
There was talk sometimes in the 50s to have a national league that incorporated promotion/relegation from the state leagues. Would that have been the more ideal setup to the eventual VFL/AFL transition? Would this have been your preferred method?
I honestly never knew about this and it is actually interesting. A system familiar to many suburban football leagues where there are multiple divisions and the Grand Finalist of each division is relegated up to the next division, whilst the wooden spooner from the above league is relegated down. During the 50's this would have been an amazing idea. It would make league expansion a lot more common however i would admit it would be a lot more boring to watch.
 

Nomad12

Team Captain
Joined
Nov 19, 2013
Posts
455
Likes
635
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
OKC
#98
If Ryan Griffen never walked out on the dogs... Bob Murphy wouldnt of been made captain. That was defintley a turning point in the club and for all the unjustufied hate Murph gets he was a crucial part in turning it around and stepped up when the club desperately needed unlike pea heart.

Also Tom Boyd wouldnt of been a bulldog and for all the shit he cops he was a beast through finals and especially the GF. I thought he deserved the norm smith.
 

magpienato

The Swooping Magpie
Joined
Oct 27, 2016
Posts
2,893
Likes
3,257
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Toronto Raptors,Melbourne Renegades
#99
Hawthorn lose the 2013 prelim.

Game goes other way - would Hawks have stuck with Clarkson?
I'll send one back at you: Collingwood doesn't choke their lead in the Q3 of 2011 GF and win (only in my dreams :(). My bet is Malthouse would be coaching the Pies until 2015 probably and Chris Scott's future would be very uncertain.
 
Top Bottom