The biggest "What could've been?"

(Log in to remove this ad.)

adammania9

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Posts
9,096
Likes
17,633
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
University
What if Buckley never left the Bears.
Would he have prevented the development of a young mid like Black/Power or to a lesser degree McRae? The Lions would never have drafted Chris Scott and therefore never would have recruited Brad Scott - meaning Brisbane's back line is underdeveloped in their prime era and Nick Riewoldt's collarbone remains in tact?

Brad Scott might never have returned to AFL footy so would never have become a coach. Chris Scott would not have had such a successful playing career and likely would not have pursued a coaching career either. Brendan McCartney would have become senior coach at Geelong succeeding Bomber and who knows what happens after that.
 

bradrowe#32

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Posts
14,125
Likes
6,856
Location
Perth
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Rochester FC, Waroona FC, Pacers
Promotion/Relegation National League
There was talk sometimes in the 50s to have a national league that incorporated promotion/relegation from the state leagues. Would that have been the more ideal setup to the eventual VFL/AFL transition? Would this have been your preferred method?
I've often thought about that and it would have been a logistical/financial nightmare, especially in the 1950s. But it would have been pretty cool. The VFL as Division 1, SANFL as Division 2, WAFL as Division 3 (or swap the two), a united Tassie league as Division 4, NSW/ACT as Division 5 and QLD/NT as Division 6. Bottom two from each division get relegated for the top two of the division below. There would be a much bigger, focused interest in the whole competition as results from each division would affect other divisions. All of the clubs would maintain their own identity and local WAFL (or whoever) game would have got good attendance, more trading/FA, interesting State of Origin matches, etc. There could have been a Tuesday night FA Cup-style knock out league.

But, as I mentioned, it would cost a heap to do and travelling around the country would be difficult.
 

Sylvia Saint

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 20, 2004
Posts
6,901
Likes
5,880
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Crusaders
What if Moore kicked that shot or Hodge wasn't incorrectly awarded holding the ball in the 2014 prelim. No 3 peat, No 2 peat, Hawks discussed very differently and Port win a premiership as the only team outside the top 4 in the current system without a bye week.
I like your sliding doors thinking but would Port have been able to beat Sydney? I doubt it. Maybe.

I think people look at things too rigidly and Don't take the nature of the universe into effect. Who's to say Sydney wouldn't have flogged Hawthorn on another day? Case in point is 2010 GF vs replay. Draw vs Collingwood smashing them.
The Swans had a really bad 2 hours in 2014 and now history doesn't look at them kindly.
 

Young Gun #6

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 24, 2008
Posts
5,652
Likes
3,799
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Juventus, Suns
I like your sliding doors thinking but would Port have been able to beat Sydney? I doubt it. Maybe.

I think people look at things too rigidly and Don't take the nature of the universe into effect. Who's to say Sydney wouldn't have flogged Hawthorn on another day? Case in point is 2010 GF vs replay. Draw vs Collingwood smashing them.
The Swans had a really bad 2 hours in 2014 and now history doesn't look at them kindly.

History has shown fairly often in the last 15 years the team with a tough close prelim usually fairs a lot better than if the other team belted someone on their prelim..

Can be used as an excuse on that day but I think it's something that occurs to often to be thought of as just a bad day rather than complancency or lack of gritt/mental preparation without having a contest the week before.
 

Hap Hapablap

I'm off to Nepal to become a mountain goat.
Joined
Jun 27, 2006
Posts
11,414
Likes
2,393
Location
Where the cows go bong.
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Lakers,Inter,Man U
All Hawthorn's wasted high picks in the mid 2000's....
2005 Draft
Pick 3 - Xavier Ellis... chosen over Scott Pendlebury and Josh Kennedy (WCE)
Pick 6 - Beau Dowler... chosen over Paddy Ryder, Nathan Jones and Shannon Hurn
2006 Draft
Pick 6 - Mitch Thorp... chosen over Joel Selwood, David Armitage and Jack Riewoldt
Pick 24 - Brent Renouf... chosen over Kurt Tippett, Tom Hawkins, Todd Goldstein and Robbie Gray
2007 Draft
Pick 29 - Brendan Whitecross... chosen over Jack Steven and Easton Wood

One final one that hurts is 2010 Draft...
Pick 38 - Mitch Hallahan to Hawthorn
Pick 40 - Luke Parker to Sydney..... :'(:'(:'(
wce has been far worse as of late
 

Anja_Nees

Premiership Player
Joined
Aug 14, 2001
Posts
4,281
Likes
4,615
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Not giving away Luke Ball for nothing might have helped too.
Yeah Collingwood took Ball with the pick they offered for him. In hindsight Saints may as well have just taken it. If they'd packaged pick 16 (the Lovett pick) and pick 30 who knows who they might have lured.

Alternatively if Lovett had held it together and lasted the preseason he might have made the difference.

Arguably the trade period that cost them the flag.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

LeverPuller

BigFooty Tanker
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Posts
30,966
Likes
33,915
Location
Q49, Olympic Stand
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Newcastle United Seattle Seahawks
Actually, another interesting one from a Melbourne perspective is the immediate post-186 situation.

Instead of sacking Dean Bailey, the club proceeds with the original plan and sacks Cameron Schwab. The board is forced to begin the hunt for a new CEO. Bailey remains at the club and receives a 2-year contract extension to the end of 2013.

Then what? Given Bailey died in early 2014 and would have been suspended for the tanking saga, who knows what happens.
 

LeverPuller

BigFooty Tanker
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Posts
30,966
Likes
33,915
Location
Q49, Olympic Stand
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Newcastle United Seattle Seahawks
Jack Trengoves trade to Richmond falls through because of foot injury... potentially could've been playing in the prelim for all we know

Instead delisted today. Poor bloke
Busted his foot in the physical for them.

The flipside is that Melbourne drafts Jake Lever. The suggestion was Trengove + Melbourne's 2nd for Richmond's 1st was the deal.
 

Deep

Genius on Drugs
Joined
Jun 16, 2017
Posts
5,410
Likes
7,754
Location
Waterfall Gully
AFL Club
Geelong
If Gary Ablett Jr stayed at Geelong, then I'm certain Geelong would have been 2013 premiers.
Well if Enright wasn't injured and Chapman suspended we would've won that prelim.

However with Ablett in our squad the ladder position likely changes and most likely we meet Hawthorn and get some 08 payback.
 

Deep

Genius on Drugs
Joined
Jun 16, 2017
Posts
5,410
Likes
7,754
Location
Waterfall Gully
AFL Club
Geelong
I've often thought about that and it would have been a logistical/financial nightmare, especially in the 1950s. But it would have been pretty cool. The VFL as Division 1, SANFL as Division 2, WAFL as Division 3 (or swap the two), a united Tassie league as Division 4, NSW/ACT as Division 5 and QLD/NT as Division 6. Bottom two from each division get relegated for the top two of the division below. There would be a much bigger, focused interest in the whole competition as results from each division would affect other divisions. All of the clubs would maintain their own identity and local WAFL (or whoever) game would have got good attendance, more trading/FA, interesting State of Origin matches, etc. There could have been a Tuesday night FA Cup-style knock out league.

But, as I mentioned, it would cost a heap to do and travelling around the country would be difficult.
If only Australia had the money to make this happen. To a footy lover it'd cause a lot of pre-ejaculate.
 

Aramis

Premiership Player
Joined
Jul 31, 2016
Posts
3,530
Likes
7,168
AFL Club
Hawthorn
wce has been far worse as of late
Hmm am I missing anything apart from this quick list:

2013 Draft
Pick 11 - Dom Sheed - over Patrick Cripps (13), Cam McCarthy (14), Matt Crouch (23), Zach Merrett (26)
2014 Draft
Pick 11 - Liam Duggan - over Jake Lever (14)
2016 Draft
Pick 13 - Daniel Venables - over Berry (17), SPP (18)

hardly worse unless i'm missing something...
 

Topkent

Premium Platinum
Joined
Aug 29, 2010
Posts
32,257
Likes
38,875
Location
Canada
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Winnipeg Jets
Definitely... multiple list managers over that period though....
Think of what COULD have been.... Ryder, Selwood, R Gray, Wood and Pendlebury added to our team....
That's not how shit works. If you had all those blokes you might have lost Lewis Mitchell Franklin or Hodge in a salary squeeze. Dew wouldn't have come in in 08 nor Gibbo Hale Lake etc
 

SizeMatters

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 14, 2012
Posts
12,699
Likes
11,411
Location
Reality
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Would he have prevented the development of a young mid like Black/Power or to a lesser degree McRae? The Lions would never have drafted Chris Scott and therefore never would have recruited Brad Scott - meaning Brisbane's back line is underdeveloped in their prime era and Nick Riewoldt's collarbone remains in tact?

Brad Scott might never have returned to AFL footy so would never have become a coach. Chris Scott would not have had such a successful playing career and likely would not have pursued a coaching career either. Brendan McCartney would have become senior coach at Geelong succeeding Bomber and who knows what happens after that.
well that's certainly one way to look at it!
 

Roddy

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 10, 2006
Posts
9,385
Likes
8,178
Location
M-Town
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Aussie Cricket team.
What if Gary Ablett Snr had have stayed at Hawthorn for his entire career, with his brothers and brother in law? We may have got Jnr too as Father/son. Those 2 would have minimum 9 flags between them, and with those two in our sides during those glory periods, quite conceivably more, instead of 2. I reckon we would have won '84 and '12 respectively if we'd had those in those sides. Would have been 11 flags between them instead of 2.
That one boggles my mind.
 
Top Bottom