The biggest "What could've been?"

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #151
I've often thought about that and it would have been a logistical/financial nightmare, especially in the 1950s. But it would have been pretty cool. The VFL as Division 1, SANFL as Division 2, WAFL as Division 3 (or swap the two), a united Tassie league as Division 4, NSW/ACT as Division 5 and QLD/NT as Division 6. Bottom two from each division get relegated for the top two of the division below. There would be a much bigger, focused interest in the whole competition as results from each division would affect other divisions. All of the clubs would maintain their own identity and local WAFL (or whoever) game would have got good attendance, more trading/FA, interesting State of Origin matches, etc. There could have been a Tuesday night FA Cup-style knock out league.
I always imagined it more of a national league that exists above the state leagues, and the bottom 3 teams of each state are replaced with the winners of their respective state competitions. Although that could theoretically mean that in an 18 team comp (that is split between 3 teams from each state), if the bottom 12 was 6 SA teams and 6 WA teams, the Vic team that finished in 7th could get relegated. This is too much for me to try figure out this morning.

Promotion from the VFA to VFL would have worked though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Total_Juddshanks

Premiership Player
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Posts
4,163
Likes
3,778
Location
Fee
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
The good ones
Geelong would've still won 07. Amazing side.
Possibly,although they were just starting to become an amazing side.

Obviously we will never really know for sure but bear in mind that in real life they beat Collingwood by less than a goal in the PF- the previous week without judd or cousins the eagles pushed Collingwood to extra time.

Also, bear in mind that at that point Geelong had zero grand final experience on their list, whereas almost every west coast player would have been looking at their third consecutive grand final- I think that counts for something- and against better, more finals hardened opposition than port, it could have ended up being Geelong's 'you have to lose one to win one' year.

Also it's my what-if scenario and I'm telling you west coast won. Was a great game, I remember it clearly :p
 

Countrypie

Club Legend
Joined
Apr 10, 2012
Posts
2,482
Likes
3,272
Location
Ararat
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Kookaburras, Grampians Hockey
How did you lose 70 and 73???? Man! You guys have lost a lot of Grand Finals!
1970 was a nightmare.
McKenna had kicked 6 to half time. Tuddy knocked him into next week just before half time. Carlton would've still come back, but Mckenna would've kicked tow or three in the 2nd half if he was awake. 1973 was a direct result of 1970 - the ghosts came back to haunt too many good players. Set shots missed in the last 15 minutes were critical.
If the pies had won in 1970, they would have won in 73 and probably held on in 77.
The biggest if only though is if only John Greening had played a full career rather than be struck down when he was still a kid. Polled 14 votes in 12 games in 1973.
 

telsor

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 29, 2004
Posts
30,087
Likes
26,533
Location
Here
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Habs
Yep.

Can only look back and question if the decision was made the best information at hand.
and you also need to consider the flow on from it.

If Richmond had taken Franklin over Tambling, we probably wouldn't have a large chunk of our best players (more specifically, Cotchin & Martin).

Might it have been better overall...Perhaps, but it's really impossible to tell. Franklin may not have developed the same and the question marks over his attitude, etc that existed at draft time may have turned out to go the other way (our off field support/development was woeful back then). That choice may have cost the game a champion, and nobody would have known any different....(as another, impossible to answer, 'what if', what forgotten 'nobodies' could have been far better if drafted elsewhere...)
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Posts
241
Likes
218
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Chicago Bulls, Arsenal, Scorchers
If Sheridan hadn't dropped that mark
If Mora hadn't done his knee
If Fyfe had kicked those first two goals in the Granny
If we had beaten Sydney in the Prelim in 06
If we hadn't sacked Harvey & Neesham
 
Joined
Nov 11, 2010
Posts
1,768
Likes
3,571
Location
Punt Rd End
AFL Club
Richmond
Promotion/Relegation National League
There was talk sometimes in the 50s to have a national league that incorporated promotion/relegation from the state leagues. Would that have been the more ideal setup to the eventual VFL/AFL transition? Would this have been your preferred method?
I think in Victoria now, we are quickly moving to a similar league at VFL level to the one you're discussing here. More teams are creating reserve VFL teams but some of stand alone teams still continue to dominate. It would be great of this sort of system to occur at that level. I wouldn't necessarily move the AFL Reserve teams up and down but I would move the stand alone teams ensuring that they are always competitive and ensure the AFL affiliated team (and the AFL players there in) are playing to the highest standard they can.

The Foxtel Cup was a great idea but because it only reached 30% of the market place and had stand alone teams in it (correct me if I'm wrong here), the interest wasn't as high. Why not include any team that finished 1st/2nd regardless of their affiliations? Imagine if the Crows, Eagles and Pies affiliated teams were included. The interest would be far higher.

I would also love to see the grand finalist teams of the competition included in the AFL practice match schedule. Would give the AFL a genuine hit out and promote the 2nd tier system (and players participating) too.

If there ever comes a time when we get a Tasmanian team, to avoid a bye with having an odd number, perhaps using this system to include a VFL/WAFL/SANFL etc team could be solution?

Anyway, pie in the sky ideas but could create addition interest
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

footyfan78

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 27, 2014
Posts
18,185
Likes
17,628
Location
spacetime
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
there are no other teams worthy
Ball bounces opposite way for Milne and into his lap.
Harmes does not chase down the wet ball slewed off his kick in muddiest grand final in our lifetime.
 

Countrypie

Club Legend
Joined
Apr 10, 2012
Posts
2,482
Likes
3,272
Location
Ararat
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Kookaburras, Grampians Hockey
Ball bounces opposite way for Milne and into his lap.
Harmes does not chase down the wet ball slewed off his kick in muddiest grand final in our lifetime.
I know it's part of folklore but as I remember it that act put you 11 pts up and although we kicked one after the bounce, there's no guarantee we would've cleared the ball from that pocket anyway. A great act of desperation that didn't necessarily make the difference one way or the other.
 

chiwigi

I’ll make tears from your Wines.
Joined
Apr 9, 2009
Posts
15,883
Likes
25,994
Location
Port Adelaide Zone
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
If Ross Oakley hadn't tricked Port into thinking they would get a team in before the crows were created

The crows would never have formed


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
This is true and it is equally true that if Norwood hadn't pretended that they hadn't applied and stood by Port, we would have a fantastic and traditional rivalry in the AFL instead of the spiteful and petty crap we get now. Hell, by now there may have been a third traditional club.
 

BigVic

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 7, 2009
Posts
2,420
Likes
1,101
Location
Bull Creek WA
AFL Club
West Coast
Original VFL Park Capacity
Having the train line extended to the stadium and the full plans for the stadium capacity fulfilled, would it be hosting the Grand Final from now on? 150,000 fans packed out in the eastern suburbs could have been possible if the infrastructure supported it. Or would it have been the great white elephant for the VFL?
Had VFL Park got it's original capacity, it would've been the largest sports stadium in the world.
 

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #167
From the Geelong board

In the 1940s the secretary (CEO) of the League, Likely McBrien recommended that an 'MCG sized' stadium be developed in Kardinia Park - more centrally located in the Park than the Eastern Oval (site of current stadium) being used for League matches. Post-war shortages of funds and building materials meant that nothing came of the plan.

Wouldn't have been too hard to accomplish down in Geelong with the state of KP at the time. Not thinking that the relocation of the stadium would have led to a 100,000 seat stadium now existing in Geelong, but it would definitely have been easier to redevelop the stadium if it wasn't located so close to Moorabool St.

This is how it looked circa 1957.

upload_2017-9-13_12-35-25.png
 

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #169
This is true and it is equally true that if Norwood hadn't pretended that they hadn't applied and stood by Port, we would have a fantastic and traditional rivalry in the AFL instead of the spiteful and petty crap we get now. Hell, by now there may have been a third traditional club.
Think there would ever be room for a 3rd Adelaide team?
 

Countrypie

Club Legend
Joined
Apr 10, 2012
Posts
2,482
Likes
3,272
Location
Ararat
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Kookaburras, Grampians Hockey
This is true and it is equally true that if Norwood hadn't pretended that they hadn't applied and stood by Port, we would have a fantastic and traditional rivalry in the AFL instead of the spiteful and petty crap we get now. Hell, by now there may have been a third traditional club.
I remember at the time really wanting the traditional clubs to come in - both in SA and WA. Yes, the Crows have been a great success, but the idea of Norwood, Glenelg & POrt playing in the AFL feels better from a "romantics " point of view
 

Gydafud

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Posts
2,713
Likes
4,533
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur
Thread starter #172
LOL @ 100k seat stadium in Geelong in the 1940s when the population was about 50k.
From memory, the 1940s version of the MCG only had the MCC stand and the Southern Stand (The Olympic stand had yet to be built for the Olympics). Not sure on the seating capacity, as it was mostly standing room around the bays/edge. Not a huge ask back then, and they didn't have to build the stands, just the open space around the ground.
 

Scotland

Hall of Famer
Joined
May 5, 2006
Posts
47,256
Likes
48,762
AFL Club
West Coast
What could've been... if the VFL clubs voted no to expansion.

Would we have a super league of new clubs?
Would we have a new league of VFL/WAFL/SANFL clubs?
Would bankrupt clubs have disappeared?
 
Top Bottom