Oh how did I miss this. Since I can't bloody sleep and have to get up in an hour I've given up, so here goes. There seems to be some differing opinions of Charlie, one is despite his lack of offensive contribution and shitful use of the ball and finishing, his defensive pressure made up for it and he would turn it on in the finals. As it turned out, he thankfully turned it on in the prelim and was an offensive weapon. It's interesting though that we are supposed to give him an apology based on him doing what we were critical of him not doing. His game isn't being lauded for his defensive pressure but his goal scoring, funny that. I called for him to be dropped in the later half of the year because his form deserved it. Others said he we was still performing, but at that stage he was performing a role no better than Petrenko. As we approached the finals, it was too late to make a change. He was a clanger king against GWS but that didn't matter according to some, he still played well. Against Geelong he was a gun. I hope like hell he reproduces his Geelong game in the GF and not the GWS because that will mean he will be turning the ball over to Richmond and with their speedy forwards could catch our defenders out of position.