Mega Thread The Daniher Debacle

[Punts]

Well actually none of us have the real facts.

Yes so not point bringing up buddy

 

[Tedeski]

Yes so not point bringing up buddy

Why?

 

[DobmusEdge]

So not facts

ok

We all know a lot more about Franklin’s contract than we do Tippet’s.

That’s a fact.

If you have more facts about Tippet’s contract, don’t hesitate to regale us

 

[Millky95]

*s me off this arguing about Tippett and all this if we didn't drink bathwater in 14 and get shafted in 16.

Those 2 days go differently who gives a * about what he was on or what he did or didn't do cause of the medals around his neck

 

[Punts]

Wish we played someone with a little go like nankervis in 16

Boyd got a hold of the all Australian Tippett thst day

Did Tippett make the squad that year since he was so dominant?

 

[caesar88]

fu**s me off this arguing about Tippett and all this if we didn't drink bathwater in 14 and get shafted in 16.

Those 2 days go differently who gives a fu** about what he was on or what he did or didn't do cause of the medals around his neck

Somehow I think medal or not, he'd still be a contentious subject on this board.

Reid has a medal but it's done nothing to change my views on him 8 years later.

 

[Millky95]

Somehow I think medal or not, he'd still be a contentious subject on this board.

Reid has a medal but it's done nothing to change my views on him 8 years later.

But look at when Reid got his medal though. A much younger and promising player. We have seen Reid peak with glimmers of brilliance surrounded by not much else

 

[RW]

Tippett did play some good footy for us, but he did also fail on the big stage. Can we at least agree on those two things so we can all move on?

 

[Punts]

Tippett did play some good footy for us, but he did also fail on the big stage. Can we at least agree on those two things so we can all move on?

Disgrace is both gf

 

[The King!]

Tippett did play some good footy for us, but he did also fail on the big stage. Can we at least agree on those two things so we can all move on?

agree

wasnt a natural footballer, which surprises me as he is a member of the Daniher family im guessing?

 

[The King!]

Disgrace is both gf

so was parker and hes captain of the club

 

[caesar88]

so was parker and hes captain of the club

McVeigh was poor in both too, shouldn’t have played in the second.

 

[Ticky009]

 

[Punts]

McVeigh was poor in both too, shouldn’t have played in the second.

Not 12?

 

[The King!]

i look forward to Joe playing round 1 for sydney 2021

 

[Punts]

Still reckon he will come

we need a marketing player with buddy retiring at years end

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Still reckon he will come

we need a marketing player with buddy retiring at years end

Think 2020 is his last?

 

[caesar88]

Not 12?

Was good in 2012, though not sure what that has to do with 14 or 16

 

[Punts]

Think 2020 is his last?

Ted said he thinks the club and him will come to an agreement

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Ted said he thinks the club and him will come to an agreement

So if he does finish up in 2020 he still has 2 years left on his contract?

 

[DobmusEdge]

fu**s me off this arguing about Tippett and all this if we didn't drink bathwater in 14 and get shafted in 16.

Those 2 days go differently who gives a fu** about what he was on or what he did or didn't do cause of the medals around his neck

I’d give a * if those days went differently

 

[The King!]

Well actually none of us have the real facts.

well we know tippett was paid to not play at all, thats a fact

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

well we know tippett was paid to not play at all, thats a fact

Cmon King he was well worth the gamble he had bad luck with a Carlton player collapsing on his leg and a thug breaking his jaw.

 

[The King!]

Cmon King he was well worth the gamble he had bad luck with a Carlton player collapsing on his leg and a thug breaking his jaw.

didnt comment on his ability there, just saying he was paid not to play for 2 years is a fact

getting tippett was worth the risk,though not sure why we went for him and buddy

he was always hot and cold, started well for us though, but how we got extensions is beyond me, not his fault

it was a fail overall, but yeah worth the risk i cant argue with that

not sure he was ever a natural footballer, but then again being a forward in our team is ******* impossible at times and he didnt pay himself etc

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

didnt comment on his ability there, just saying he was paid not to play for 2 years is a fact

getting tippett was worth the risk,though not sure why we went for him and buddy

he was always hot and cold, started well for us though, but how we got extensions is beyond me, not his fault

it was a fail overall, but yeah worth the risk i cant argue with that

not sure he was ever a natural footballer, but then again being a forward in our team is ******* impossible at times and he didnt pay himself etc

Cause when Tippett and Franklin worked we looked unbeatable in 2014 after our 1-4 start we averaged a winning margin of 10 goals till the finals.

We just didnt see it enough