Not that I recall. I know it was close but I thought we ended up winning by about 4 goals. Does footywire go back that far, I'll check.
The David Mackay thread
- Thread starter Scorpus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Not that I recall. I know it was close but I thought we ended up winning by about 4 goals. Does footywire go back that far, I'll check.
we won by 25, so hard to say.
Mackay?
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
Or Hamill? Can’t believe Hamill dropped and DMac still there!
Absolutely agree. He is taking up room that should be for a player in our future. Cant wait to hear the story behind dropping Hamill
Balance
BringbackWebb
Debutant
- May 30, 2019
- 73
- 151
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I would like to congratulate '1970crow' on the foresight or insight to post this prior to selection, we have seen some amazing selections this year as many of the esteemed posters on this site have clearly pointed out but the continued selection of David Mackay appears to have now achieved some form of cult status.
I personally am frustrated with the clubs selection policy and clear lack of commitment to developing our young players that it is impossible to find the right words! As another poster in the selection thread pointed out, we have basically chosen every senior player possible all year, to the detriment of team structure for one, but more importantly to deny opportunity to many of our future players and therefore delay further sustainable future success, of course we are still getting pretty well flogged each week.
As for Ronin O'Connor I hope he has had a clear discussion with the coaching group and understands why he is being dropped, I thought for a first game and only 50% game time he did quite well, but of course what would I know, as far as I can tell he deserved at least another run!
I also thought Sam Berry showed more leadership standing up to take that high ball mark than David Mackay showed in the entire game. The funny thing about youngsters is that they often don't know they can't do something until someone else tells them they can't, what sort of message is the coaching group of the Crows sending to their developing group?
I personally am frustrated with the clubs selection policy and clear lack of commitment to developing our young players that it is impossible to find the right words! As another poster in the selection thread pointed out, we have basically chosen every senior player possible all year, to the detriment of team structure for one, but more importantly to deny opportunity to many of our future players and therefore delay further sustainable future success, of course we are still getting pretty well flogged each week.
As for Ronin O'Connor I hope he has had a clear discussion with the coaching group and understands why he is being dropped, I thought for a first game and only 50% game time he did quite well, but of course what would I know, as far as I can tell he deserved at least another run!
I also thought Sam Berry showed more leadership standing up to take that high ball mark than David Mackay showed in the entire game. The funny thing about youngsters is that they often don't know they can't do something until someone else tells them they can't, what sort of message is the coaching group of the Crows sending to their developing group?
- May 10, 2016
- 16,259
- 13,252
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
His pick 2 experience is needed guys.
View attachment 1132626-9f8ab97aaefb34be50c55c5e819548c4.mp4
View attachment 1132626-9f8ab97aaefb34be50c55c5e819548c4.mp4
Worth more than Hamill's 6 touches factored by 20 experience points. 240 x 4 >>>>>>>>>>> 6 x 20. And that is how we select a 22. 240 games will always beat 20 games.
And whilst we're on it, both Keays and Sloane playing with one bung hand each. But instead of getting them right and prioritising 2022, the continue to push through as mids that only plin the stoppage rotation. Keays 12 and Sloane 10. These are 2 of our 3 prime movers presently denying jumuior midfielders of minutes.
And whilst we're on it, both Keays and Sloane playing with one bung hand each. But instead of getting them right and prioritising 2022, the continue to push through as mids that only plin the stoppage rotation. Keays 12 and Sloane 10. These are 2 of our 3 prime movers presently denying jumuior midfielders of minutes.
dogs105
Sweet Kennels Proprietor
He'll be dropped this week.
Our coaching panel consists of many idiots.
Billy should never play again.
MacKay should never play again.
STOP PLAYING INJURED SENIOR PLAYERS WHEN THEIR INJURY CLEARLY EFFECTS THEIR PERFORMANCE. Lynch, Tex, Sloane, Keays, Brown.
So many things that should be very a simple decision, we just keep getting them wrong.
Billy should never play again.
MacKay should never play again.
STOP PLAYING INJURED SENIOR PLAYERS WHEN THEIR INJURY CLEARLY EFFECTS THEIR PERFORMANCE. Lynch, Tex, Sloane, Keays, Brown.
So many things that should be very a simple decision, we just keep getting them wrong.
Sloane 17 to back up his 18 from last week. Funny thing is that he's hit his yearly high TOG at 89%. So not onky id he not winning possession, which is his job, he's also not leaving the field of play as much as he was prior to injury. So more time on ground for less outcome, great stuff Rory.
Mackay another masterful 14 touch game. Viva la 250 mother flippers. Cannot wait fir 2022 to see this kid hit his straps.
Mackay another masterful 14 touch game. Viva la 250 mother flippers. Cannot wait fir 2022 to see this kid hit his straps.
- May 7, 2007
- 5,109
- 6,047
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Our lowest score ever. I'm sure a midfield of our kids would have done better.
WTF were they thinking selecting blokes playing injured?
WTF were they thinking selecting blokes playing injured?
Who have we got left who is not injured and not in the team already? Hately? I wouldn't mind seeing him play the rest of the season.
Just looking at ins and outs is so stupidly simplistic. There's changes within this week's selected 22 that need to be discussed first.
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 77,391
- 152,124
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #575
Came home with a wet sail
Similar threads
