Unsolved The Family Murders

The Who's Who List

Out of Sight - The Untold Story of Adelaide's Gay Hate Murders

The Cases of Forensic Pathologist Colin Manock

Use this thread below to lodge media, maps and photos for quick reference.

 
Last edited:

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
Don't think that was going to be enough. He's a depraved piece of filth too. He most definitely participated with bve in drugging and abusing victims, maybe not cruising with the trans and picking the victims up, but participating no doubt in their vile acts.
FTFY Kurve
 
If I had any shred of evidence on any of these maggots, the cops would get it.
It is known that for periods of time bve and dsd rented units/flats/townhouses/houses, in addition to their primary places of residence for the express purpose of using for their nefarious activities.
Even drawing a long bow, and suggesting dsd wasn't involved is a stretch in my opinion.
And even in the remote possibility that were the case, that dsd wasn't involved in vile acts with bve, that makes him akin to a priest who has not committed sexual abuse, but has sheltered those that did/do. And I'm hypothesizing here, as it's pretty clear they were close friends who enjoyed 'rough trade'

The only independent witness account I've seen that BVE even knew DSD was the retelling of seeing BVE showing DSD abuse images and DSD exclaiming 'ooh that's evil' and that he was a witness at the trial I presume, testifying to BVEs hair appointment.
 

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
The only independent witness account I've seen that BVE even knew DSD was the retelling of seeing BVE showing DSD abuse images and DSD exclaiming 'ooh that's evil' and that he was a witness at the trial I presume, testifying to BVEs hair appointment.
The very same dsd that had been dyeing bve's prematurely greying/whitening hair for many years?
The very same dsd that had been friends with bve for many years?
That dsd.
 

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
The only independent witness account I've seen that BVE even knew DSD was the retelling of seeing BVE showing DSD abuse images and DSD exclaiming 'ooh that's evil' and that he was a witness at the trial I presume, testifying to BVEs hair appointment.
Also in the very same story about the Trevor Peters diary entries, where bve is showing dsd photos, it mentions dsd telling Trevor P that he and bve rented premises, outside of their primary residences, together for 'weekends'
 
Also in the very same story about the Trevor Peters diary entries, where bve is showing dsd photos, it mentions dsd telling Trevor P that he and bve rented premises, outside of their primary residences, together for 'weekends'

Yeh I've read the diary entries. If BVE had access to a shared place with DSD, why would he need to take Richard Kelvin to his own house in Paradise and other drugged victims over time to the share house where Pru and Lewis lived? DSD doesn't make an appearance at these times, the 'businessman' did. I don't recall Mr. B naming DSD either?
 
Anybody know if Denis St Denis was a witness for the defence or the prosecution? I'm thinking with the hair snips found inside Richard's jeans, DSD was probablty secured for the prosecution to support their case that it was consistent with the haircut BVE had the day after Richard was abducted.
 

SquiffyRae

Team Captain
Sep 28, 2020
364
1,066
AFL Club
Collingwood
Also as point of interest to some, I was researching clocks shops in the inner southern suburbs as one does. I noticed a certain clock shop, whose business name includes the name of a person and decided to check it out. There are some goo gle reviews on there which are quite amusing from the last month, and they pertain to........well maybe check it out.

Now this I'm surprised with as usually said owner is extremely quick to jump on anything that might connect him to this case. His shop used to have an entry on either TripAdvisor or Yelp where there was a way to see deleted reviews and there was a single actual review that was kept up and the rest were all similar to what's on Google now.

What's interesting though is that a lot of the accounts posting those reviews do have a history and other reviews left by them seem to be genuine (even if they seem to mostly use google reviews to complain). So it's not just anonymous trolls doing it people seem to have genuinely found out his name despite his best efforts to hide it.

Odd that they'd be up there for over a month without either him or his legal team stepping in. Is mr businessman indisposed perhaps? He is older than BvE after all and BvE isn't exactly a spring chicken. Or has just been too lazy or forgetful to check google lately?
 

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
Yeh I've read the diary entries. If BVE had access to a shared place with DSD, why would he need to take Richard Kelvin to his own house in Paradise and other drugged victims over time to the share house where Pru and Lewis lived? DSD doesn't make an appearance at these times, the 'businessman' did. I don't recall Mr. B naming DSD either?
If I could answer that question, I'd be on the way to claiming the reward money on offer for these unsolved crimes.
Many times it is mentioned in the various sources of information available on this vile series of crimes, of the way in which bve socialised in different circles. In the sense of having multiple groups of friends/associates that whilst known to each other didn't interact.
The sharing of units/townhouses between dsd & bve may have been intermittent. But it happened.
Dsd is (was) one of bve's oldest and dearest friends, right up there with mr r.
 
Last edited:

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
Now this I'm surprised with as usually said owner is extremely quick to jump on anything that might connect him to this case. His shop used to have an entry on either TripAdvisor or Yelp where there was a way to see deleted reviews and there was a single actual review that was kept up and the rest were all similar to what's on Google now.

What's interesting though is that a lot of the accounts posting those reviews do have a history and other reviews left by them seem to be genuine (even if they seem to mostly use google reviews to complain). So it's not just anonymous trolls doing it people seem to have genuinely found out his name despite his best efforts to hide it.

Odd that they'd be up there for over a month without either him or his legal team stepping in. Is mr businessman indisposed perhaps? He is older than BvE after all and BvE isn't exactly a spring chicken. Or has just been too lazy or forgetful to check google lately?
Yes, that's an interesting one. Could be one of a number of scenarios as you said. Sickness/ill health is a realistic possibility.
It may well be that he's accepted that people (and there's plenty of true crime buffs out there) know his name and the associated suspicions, shall we say, and he has long known himself he and his partner among others have gotten away with it, despite police knowing mostly who and what for decades.
 

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
Yeh I've read the diary entries. If BVE had access to a shared place with DSD, why would he need to take Richard Kelvin to his own house in Paradise and other drugged victims over time to the share house where Pru and Lewis lived? DSD doesn't make an appearance at these times, the 'businessman' did. I don't recall Mr. B naming DSD either?
Bve grew up (up to mid/late teens) in the suburb of Mile End.
Dsd Grew up in nearby Allenby Gardens.
They have been friends since they were early teenagers, if not earlier.
This is widely known and no breaking news.
As I stated dsd is right up there in bve friends, apart from only mr r and had known bve longer than mr r.
Again no breaking news there, pretty standard stuff for this gruesome series of crimes.
 

DropBearess

Premium Platinum
Apr 3, 2019
369
1,036
AFL Club
Adelaide
As we are all aware, the person known as "the businessman" has his name suppressed. This order is current and will continue until the suppression order is lifted.

I am guessing many of us know his name and business. There is a good laugh to be had should one happen to google recent reviews for the said name and business.

I won't post the link. I know it's funny, but please don't post it either.
 

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
The only independent witness account I've seen that BVE even knew DSD was the retelling of seeing BVE showing DSD abuse images and DSD exclaiming 'ooh that's evil' and that he was a witness at the trial I presume, testifying to BVEs hair appointment.
Denis St Denis
  • BVE's hairdresser friend
  • Had a salon in Hazelwood Park




  • His nickname was "Pussy"
  • BVE went to his salon and had his dyed the day after Kelvin went missing
  • Allegedly rented a unit with BVE in the inner eastern suburbs - maybe Norwood, Kent Town or Dulwich. Both lived with their mothers and needed a place to take young men/boys.
  • Diaries of one of his friends (Trevor Peters) were found that document suspicious discussions between BVE and St Denis, as well as the witnessing of photos of an unconscious Alan Barnes
  • Kelvin was in captivity for 5 weeks and in that time his hair had been cut. SAPOL believe this was St Denis
  • https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news...y/news-story/eaf66c4823f20f55981177c02d2bb657
From post#411, November 4th 2019
 
Kelvin was in captivity for 5 weeks and in that time his hair had been cut. SAPOL believe this was St Denis

Back to the same question I've had that I haven't found answer to.

How did they know Richard's hair was cut?

Was it an assumption that it must have been cut because it hadn't grown the expected and approximate 2cm to an inch in the time he was missing? Or was it FAR shorter than it was when he was abducted?

The other question I have is, was his hair length raised at the trial?

I'm not asking you directly, I'm not sure anybody in here knows the answers.
 
Kelvin was in captivity for 5 weeks and in that time his hair had been cut. SAPOL believe this was St Denis

Also from Nigel Hunt at the Advertiser 2 April, 2008. We now know this last line isn't true as he's referring to Mr. B and it's been confirmed by Charlie and others that Mr. B didn't die. Who knows where the idea to kill Mr. B off came from. :rolleyes:


In 1989, a key witness – one of von Einem's former close associates – provided detectives with a statement alleging the businessman met von Einem after Alan Barnes had been picked up and drugged. The witness said after von Einem and he had picked Barnes up, von Einem stopped and rang the businessman from a telephone box on Main North Rd. They then drove to the "Number One" gay beat at Jolly's Boathouse, opposite the Torrens Parade Ground. Once there – with an unconscious Barnes in the vehicle – they met the businessman and von Einem chatted with him for a short time. The witness claims von Einem had then asked him if he wanted "to watch him do some surgery on this guy".

The witness, who died in Sydney several years ago, said he did not go with the pair because he did not like the businessman.
 

DropBearess

Premium Platinum
Apr 3, 2019
369
1,036
AFL Club
Adelaide
Back to the same question I've had that I haven't found answer to.

How did they know Richard's hair was cut?

Was it an assumption that it must have been cut because it hadn't grown the expected and approximate 2cm to an inch in the time he was missing? Or was it FAR shorter than it was when he was abducted?

The other question I have is, was his hair length raised at the trial?

I'm not asking you directly, I'm not sure anybody in here knows the answers.

As far as l know, Richard's hair length wasn't raised at the trial. I can't find any references to it at all before 2014. I would think this evidence would have been quite sensational if it occurred during the trial but I could be absolutely wrong.

The first l heard of this was in February 2014, when Trevor Peter's diary was handed to police by a relative.

The hair issue is an interesting one. Studies have shown that a person's hair can fail to grow during extreme stress or illness. Or, as suggested, Richard's body could have been frozen for weeks. We need to remember who the S.A. Chief Forensic Pathologist was at this time.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20220616-150317_Chrome.jpg
    Screenshot_20220616-150317_Chrome.jpg
    189.7 KB · Views: 80
From post#411, November 4th 2019

Having just gone right through the article linked and checked post #411, I can't find anything that confirms SAPOL also believe Denis St Denis cut Richard's hair. It only refers to the diary entry.

The length of his hair at the time of autopsy is something they might have looked in to following up on the diary entries.

Peters states in the diary that a woman, whom he named and who was questioned by detectives during investigations, "said that she had been told Richard Kelvin had been held in a unit and that Denis St Denis had cut Kelvin's hair during that time. She said that several people had visited the unit while Kelvin was there''.
 

acermark

Draftee
Jun 25, 2005
14
22
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
Lions
As far as l know, Richard's hair length wasn't raised at the trial. I can't find any references to it at all before 2014. I would think this evidence would have been quite sensational if it occurred during the trial but I could be absolutely wrong.

The first l heard of this was in February 2014, when Trevor Peter's diary was handed to police by a relative.

The hair issue is an interesting one. Studies have shown that a person's hair can fail to grow during extreme stress or illness. Or, as suggested, Richard's body could have been frozen for weeks. We need to remember who the S.A. Chief Forensic Pathologist was at this time.
The 2014 article on Trevor Peters' diaries was the first time for me too that I had heard anything about Richard's hair being cut while being held captive. The most often published photo of Richard was taken about four weeks prior to him getting abducted, not sure if it would been long enough to have cut between then and 5/6/1983?

Also Trevor Holmes described Richard's hair as greasy on the Crime & Investigation Australia documentary when he recalled finding his body, perhaps it had some length?
 
The most often published photo of Richard was taken about four weeks prior to him getting abducted, not sure if it would been long enough to have cut between then and 5/6/1983?

Do you mean this black and white one acermark ?

images (1).jpg
 

Loony Juice

Club Legend
Jun 10, 2022
1,984
3,491
Rubicon
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rabbitohs, Chiefs, Villa, Coopers
Now this I'm surprised with as usually said owner is extremely quick to jump on anything that might connect him to this case. His shop used to have an entry on either TripAdvisor or Yelp where there was a way to see deleted reviews and there was a single actual review that was kept up and the rest were all similar to what's on Google now.

What's interesting though is that a lot of the accounts posting those reviews do have a history and other reviews left by them seem to be genuine (even if they seem to mostly use google reviews to complain). So it's not just anonymous trolls doing it people seem to have genuinely found out his name despite his best efforts to hide it.

Odd that they'd be up there for over a month without either him or his legal team stepping in. Is mr businessman indisposed perhaps? He is older than BvE after all and BvE isn't exactly a spring chicken. Or has just been too lazy or forgetful to check google lately?

I just noticed one of the reviews had been taken down, the one that mentions someone says hello.

One has been modified too. Not sure if that is the businessman himself, but I can't see how an online review with a name could be getting into legal territory?
 

DropBearess

Premium Platinum
Apr 3, 2019
369
1,036
AFL Club
Adelaide
I just noticed one of the reviews had been taken down, the one that mentions someone says hello.

One has been modified too. Not sure if that is the businessman himself, but I can't see how an online review with a name could be getting into legal territory?

Saw that. Tehe. The family business remains unscathed.
 

SquiffyRae

Team Captain
Sep 28, 2020
364
1,066
AFL Club
Collingwood
I just noticed one of the reviews had been taken down, the one that mentions someone says hello.

One has been modified too. Not sure if that is the businessman himself, but I can't see how an online review with a name could be getting into legal territory?
I guess if you were Mr R's lawyer you could probably make a pretty convincing legal argument that when suppression orders on your name relate to your alleged involvement in crimes committed by Bevan Spencer von Einem, having an obviously bogus review on your antiques business bearing your name could be considered identifiable - especially when you've become known variously by the names Mr R, the businessman and occasionally more specifically as an antiques dealer. It's not specifically breaking any suppression order on his name by mentioning Bevan but could probably be considered close enough to outing him that he could get it removed.

But I dunno. Maybe he was just really good friends with former Australian batsman Michael Bevan and Michael wants to reconnect

I guess we can take this as confirmation Mr R is still in the land of the living. Someone wanted those reviews taken down/modified
 

theredrooster

Draftee
Jun 23, 2022
5
11
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Hello John Barnes,

Firstly. Thank you for opening yourself up in the very honest and forthright way you have in this forum. I am sure it’s extremely painful to continue to relive this filth over and over again.

I am deeply sorry for all that your family has been through over the last 4+ decades, but hopefully, your bravery in speaking up here is keeping the cases buoyant and the pressure on the police to hopefully bring these atrocities to licit convictions.

I have followed these cases for some time and have a fairly good understanding of most information that is publicly available. I would, however, like to ask you a few questions, if I my?

If you feel any of the questions are getting into dangerous or uncomfortable territories, legally or personally, please feel free to refrain. (But, my understanding is, you can’t defame nor need to suppress those who are already dead.)

  1. Firstly, do you believe BVE was involved in picking up 100s of young men, drugging them and sexually assaulting them over the 5-10+ year period? What approximate total number would your intel and/or instinct suggest?
  2. Do you believe BVE potentially, all of the time and/or some of the time, invited other associates to join the nonconsensual, unconscious rape of these victims?
  3. Whilst each incident most probably involved different co-conspirators, do you believe these attackers were more than just the transexual, friend housemates who it’s been reported, on occasion, provided BVE with a venue?
  4. Do you believe BVE was also delivering these unconscious young men to “higher level” co-conspirators ie: doctors, politicians, lawyers, professionals etc who also potentially shared a-joint, sadist lust for docile youths?
  5. Do you believe Alan was one of the 100s of hitchhikers coaxed into the car and drugged, but that he was accidentally killed during his attack? Or, do you feel it was premeditated for “his pack” to take his life? If so, do you have a theory why he was singled out not to be released?
  6. Do you believe Neil Muir was murdered by “his pack” (for want of a better word, but accepting each attack potentially involved different offenders) for knowing too much about Alan’s purposeful or accidental murder?
  7. Do you believe Peter and Mark were also coaxed and drugged, to be potentially passed around and then released, but also potentially accidentally died during "their" brutality? Or do you feel they were deliberately murdered by “their packs”?
  8. Do you feel the Kelvin case got so big “his pack” had no choice but to murder him?
  9. How many other male youths, do you feel, potentially also died in similar attacks, by these associates, that we simply don’t know about publicly? (Ie: Perhaps they were homeless or in an orphanage or their disappearances were never properly investigated?)
  10. Do you personally feel the late-Premier Don Dunstan may have been involved in interfering with the judicial process, given his well-known, close, personal association with several of those mentioned, many many times in the media, as suspected “pack” members and associates?
  11. Do you personally think Don Dunstan potentially partook in any of the rapes, given he too was gay (slash bi) and attracted to younger men? Do you feel compromising footage may exist of Dunstan, which then potentially forced his intervention? (This was very much the tactic employed in recent years by Jeffrey Epstein and his vile associates).
  12. What evidence do you feel the police still need to lay convictions for the murder of your brother and Peter, Mark and Neil?
  13. What message do you have for all the forum members here? What can we individually and collectively do to help you, and all the victim's families?
 
Back