Opinion The I Was Wrong thread- Where Tom Atkins posts go to die

[Micksy]

I had us finishing 7th, so I guess that's impossible now.

 

[Seeds]

Absolutely. Getting West Coast is a disaster draw. We could have beaten GWS.

Didnt we smash west coast earlier in the year?

 

[Seeds]

Pies at the MCG, WCE at the MCG, Tigers at the MCG if we make it, then probably Pies at the MCG again if we make it.

Has there been a harder run for the flag? Maybe Dogs in 2016? WCE in WA, Hawks at MCG, GWS in Sydney and Sydney at MCG.

We beat all those teams in the home and away and smashed both west coast and Richmond.

 

[winty]

Didnt we smash west coast earlier in the year?

Yeah, but that doesn't count apparently because it was before the Eagles had hit their own purple patch form-wise, plus it was at our cheat ground...

 

[Partridge]

Pies at the MCG, WCE at the MCG, Tigers at the MCG if we make it, then probably Pies at the MCG again if we make it.

Has there been a harder run for the flag? Maybe Dogs in 2016? WCE in WA, Hawks at MCG, GWS in Sydney and Sydney at MCG.

Plenty.

As you called it, Dogs in 2016 easily tougher.
Hawthorn in 2015 easily tougher as well.

 

[thecatattack]

We beat all those teams in the home and away and smashed both west coast and Richmond.

Smashed WCE in Geelong and Richmond with injuries.

I don't think they're exactly relevant to now.

 

[thecatattack]

Plenty.

As you called it, Dogs in 2016 easily tougher.
Hawthorn in 2015 easily tougher as well.

I think Hawks playing Adelaide at the MCG makes it not as tough.

Also TIL North made the PF that year.

 

[BORIS332]

Judging by the drama queens I’ve seen on this board this week, I feel this particular thread will be overloaded come Saturday morning!

 

[Partridge]

I think Hawks playing Adelaide at the MCG makes it not as tough.

Also TIL North made the PF that year.

Two trips to Perth in one finals series makes it far harder. Plus no weeks off.

 

[Partridge]

Judging by the drama queens I’ve seen on this board this week, I feel this particular thread will be overloaded come Saturday morning!

Depends if they win or not.

 

[Seeds]

Smashed WCE in Geelong and Richmond with injuries.

I don't think they're exactly relevant to now.

So a couple of injuries makes a 70 point difference? Richmonds entire midfield played that night and were smashed.

 

[Seeds]

Judging by the drama queens I’ve seen on this board this week, I feel this particular thread will be overloaded come Saturday morning!

Anyone using that term this week is either a moron or has close relationships with officials running the club. Which is it?

 

[thecatattack]

So a couple of injuries makes a 70 point difference? Richmonds entire midfield played that night and were smashed.

It's just not indicative of now. Both teams have gone opposite directions since then, in terms of their onfield play.

 

[Wojcinski]

Judging by the drama queens I’ve seen on this board this week, I feel this particular thread will be overloaded come Saturday morning!

This week? Must be your first week here then..

 

[BORIS332]

Judging by the drama queens I’ve seen on this board this week, I feel this particular thread will be overloaded come Saturday morning!

Can anyone point me to the “I was right” thread???!

 

[BORIS332]

Depends if they win or not.

...

 

[00VicWard001]

I’d expect a few of you shineboys to wear your knee pads and worm your way into this thread.

 

[00VicWard001]

Anyone using that term this week is either a moron or has close relationships with officials running the club. Which is it?

Or just someone who doesn’t bitch and moan when the going gets tough.

 

[allrighty]

 

[catempire]

I was wrong about being wrong about us being a 5-8 ranked team. By 10:30pm Friday night I will be right.

☹

Wrong again.

 

[Vdubs]

Guilty.
Did not think we had it in us to be in a prelim.
Presumably our game is Friday evening?

 

[cats_09]

Guilty.
Did not think we had it in us to be in a prelim.
Presumably our game is Friday evening?

Yep - at least when our fans are out numbered next week it's not our "home" game

 

[Mr Meow]

Wrong again.

I told you.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

“We're a man down with Guthrie playing. It's that simple.”

Shame Nakkers is exiled, that was at HT tonight

 

[Goggin Our Best]

“We're a man down with Guthrie playing. It's that simple.”

Shame Nakkers is exiled, that was at HT tonight

Yeah - but what about you - you must have posted at least 100 times throughout the season that Geel have to play slow tempo - otherwise they will get torched

Yet Wayne Carey - the King - said throughout the call - that the big change tonight - is that the Cats are moving the ball quickly