the judd trade

[bbolt1]

the talk now is that 2 get judd they want pick 3 20 and walker or fisher with jk

 

[MBIB]

where'd you hear that - haven't heard that one yet!

Hopefully not, don't want to lose them, JK either but we might have to bite the bullet on that one

 

[Juddy08]

the talk now is that 2 get judd they want pick 3 20 and walker or fisher with jk

ABSOLUTE CRAP...........ENOUGH SAID

 

[undecided]

no player is worth 4 players. i dont think that will happen

 

[anti.]

no player is worth 4 players. i dont think that will happen

as if.

judd > bentick + bannister + saddington + ackland

 

[undecided]

as if.

judd > bentick + bannister + saddington + ackland

point taken

still i dont think i would be willing to give up 3, 20, fishers and JK

 

[BlueFeaver]

It won't happen. They don't have enough room on their list for the extra players. Remember, every team must make 3 selection in the National Draft.

 

[anti.]

make it 3, 20, and fisher.

 

[SS_Fury]

the talk now is that 2 get judd they want pick 3 20 and walker or fisher with jk

source?

 

[Deej]

I'd walk.

 

[Dk#1]

as if.

judd > bentick + bannister + saddington + ackland

ditto

 

[DonFletch]

i hope richmond sign mark blake, and take him with pick 1 in the PSD!!!! then the weagles will only get...........zip.

 

[Dk#1]

source?

ey fury and west coke supports if you get 3, 20 and maybe 36 who you gonna delist.

 

[bbolt1]

it was on the radio that its pick 3 20 jk and fisher or walker

 

[BlueWorld]

it was on the radio that its pick 3 20 jk and fisher or walker

Which radio? They probably read it here.

 

[Blue Dawn]

It won't happen. They don't have enough room on their list for the extra players. Remember, every team must make 3 selection in the National Draft.

Correct, even if they lose/trade Morton to the Tiges. They seem short on players to cut so, with the minimum required for the draft, it would appear to be VERY unlikely that they would take any more than a combination of 3 picks/players and could even limit it to 2 if the player is to their satisfaction.

This situation makes it even more likely that they're going to want to settle this trade earlier in the week so they can have enough time to 'manage' their list/picks to a suitable conclusion.

 

[walkers a legend]

damn eagles trying to get my two favourite players (fish and walker)

 

[Blueinblood]

the talk now is that 2 get judd they want pick 3 20 and walker or fisher with jk

WTF... they can have walker and 3 but not 20....AND NOT FISH DOG

 

[Prem87]

I doubt it will happen. Pick 3 + Kennedy + Walker/Fisher maybe. But i have the felling that Pick 1 will come onto the table soon its only a matter of time.

 

[Jeremias]

It will be a disgrace if Fisher is traded.

TBH, I'd rather give up pick 1 than Fisher.

If Fish is involved in the deal I will be absolutely ropeable.

 

[Banga19]

I doubt it will happen. Pick 3 + Kennedy + Walker/Fisher maybe. But i have the felling that Pick 1 will come onto the table soon its only a matter of time.

Delusional

 

[mac25]

the talk now is that 2 get judd they want pick 3 20 and walker or fisher with jk

We all know Judd is a star, but if Carlton gave up two picks & two players, this would not be a good outcome for Carlton, no player is worth four players, l would suggest this is just another rumour.

 

[FieryNayta]

If Fish is involved in the deal I will be absolutely ropeable.

Agree. He's just about my favourite player at the club and we have all loved seeing him grow from a pick 73 or so, into a genuine star. Too much sentimentality would be traded away with Fish...its not worth it.

 

[kouta666]

TBH, I'd rather give up pick 1 than Fisher.

I agree! .... Fisher is the future of Carlton

 

[Blue Dawn]

I doubt it will happen. Pick 3 + Kennedy + Walker/Fisher maybe. But i have the felling that Pick 1 will come onto the table soon its only a matter of time.

You better hope that Nisbett and co aren't thinking the same way because friday will come and go with WCE getting zilch, zippo, nada, nothing. I'm not one of those supporters who wants this - i'd prefer a 'clean' trade with the Weagles compensated - but you've got to realise once and for all CARLTON HAVE COMMITTED TO KREUZER. As we need #1 to secure him you ain't gettin it.