Analysis The Leigh Harding memorial list of potatoes who always play well against us and us alone.

[catempire]

Mason ******* Cox.

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Mason cox. Absolute complete spud always tears us apart.

 

[Willo_]

Two thirds of the Collingwood list.

Oh god yes... bloody Mason Cox looks like an elite key forward against us

 

[dazbroncos]

Can only shake head at the ease at which we put eligible opposition players into this thread...

just horrendous we are.. and we do it ALL TO EASILY.

Go Catters

 

[Catsace]

I just remembered another one, must be something about Blues players that love playing Geelong and disappear against everything else. THink he retired (or worse was delisted) last season, but damn Andrejis Everitt....kicked that winner for the Swans from 55 that time, and last year joined Arnfield in that goal fest, which was also probably the last time the Blues deigned to score 100 points as well. Arrrghh!

BUt at least Mason Cox gets another contract, as his good games tally now rises to three in his career.

 

[MarkCatsFan]

Jamie Elliot looks like Alan Didak at his peak against us. He has a Peter Pan face and Chopper Reid arms, you could swear he only got those sleeves to fit in at training camp. Fu ck I hate him. Blair too

 

[rocker_oz33]

Denis the mence Armfield 177 games and not ONE brownlow vote .
I swear he got ONE V us .When he kick 3 against us....that day.

Poor Denis.

 

[Dawn to Dark]

Don't ever show me a Collingwood team photo you could expect some fireworks


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[iameviljez]

Can only shake head at the ease at which we put eligible opposition players into this thread...

just horrendous we are.. and we do it ALL TO EASILY.

Go Catters

Nothing special about Geelong, every club does it.

Surely the Carlton equivalent is called the Jordan Murdoch thread?

 

[iameviljez]

Jamie Elliot looks like Alan Didak at his peak against us. He has a Peter Pan face and Chopper Reid arms, you could swear he only got those sleeves to fit in at training camp. Fu ck I hate him. Blair too

He's no spud, Elliot - it's just that because Collingwood are currently s**t, he's not getting the airtime that Didak did.

 

[calder_daddy]

Shane Edwards

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Get the feeling Caddy will own this thread over the years.

 

[BotsMaster]

Get the feeling Caddy will own this thread over the years.

Nah I'm calling it now: the moon was blue last night.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

So which spud, hack, plodder or list clogger will inexplicably play a blinder against the cats.
Odds on Clangermakers after returning to the side.

 

[calder_daddy]

So which spud, hack, plodder or list clogger will inexplicably play a blinder against the cats.
Odds on Clangermakers after returning to the side.

Tom Mitchell

 

[fpm84]

Alex Fasolo - again.

 

[Hamingja]

Darren Minchington wants his thread title back.

Career

Games 28 Goals 22

V Geelong

Games 3 Goals 9

 

[InnocentBystandr]

Daz, by bumping this thread do you mean Max? Possibly BOG for the Dees, lucky for us he kicks like a ruckman!

 

[dazbroncos]

Daz, by bumping this thread do you mean Max? Possibly BOG for the Dees, lucky for us he kicks like a ruckman!

Nah...Gero started a thread about players that perform well against us and then disappear back to oblivion.

And we already had a thread about it - this one - just had to find it...

took some searching too - so I merged them and here we are.

Can still have the discussion as its completely valid. And as questions are being asked about Buckley's future already, id suggest he's looking at the fixture to when we play them so his band of 6 no namers, Cox included, can look like a bunch of Norm Smith medalists against us again.

Go Catters

 

[Willo_]

Nah...Gero started a thread about players that perform well against us and then disappear back to oblivion.

And we already had a thread about it - this one - just had to find it...

took some searching too - so I merged them and here we are.

Can still have the discussion as its completely valid. And as questions are being asked about Buckley's future already, id suggest he's looking at the fixture to when we play them so his band of 6 no namers, Cox included, can look like a bunch of Norm Smith medalists against us again.

Go Catters

My thread deserves to be the home of all this discussion for thread title alone!!!

 

[geelongempire]

So which spud, hack, plodder or list clogger will inexplicably play a blinder against the cats.
Odds on Clangermakers after returning to the side.

Mason Cox again in Round 8 probably!!

 

[calder_daddy]

L Thomas will probably kick 5 tonight and Motlop will have 30 and kick 3

I actually think Zuthrie would’ve been a perfect match up for L Thomas

 

[calder_daddy]

Shaun Mckernan

Close thread

 

[Matthew Jelley]

Shaun Mckernan

Close thread

Ouch

 

[Spearman]

lol was thinking the same thing, who is this guy?