the list

[rooboy]

I'm not sure what port people would think - I haven't asked, but another way to attack the father son in this state would be:

Port - gets sons of all Port magpies having played 100 games (in line with Vic clubs) with similar cut of dates (i.e played 100 games prior to 97) - no cutoff for when the player has to be drafted.

Adelaide gets all other clubs players with 200 qualification. No cutoff for when they have to be drafted, but must have played the 200 prior to 91.


Reason I was thinking this way, is due to occassion that Ross Gibbs complained and had Glenelg aligned to AFC instead of PAFC. Would father sons from other non-Port Magpie clubs want their father son selections going to Port or Adelaide.... and more precisely what relationship does say WestAdelaide have with Port Adelaide.

Would this work or would the AFL then increase the number of games played to qualify for AFC.

Being a died in the wool Westies man and having an absolute hatred of all things Port, I like your thinking, it kills me to think of sons of Westies playing for the Power.

 

[GoSarge]

1st edit.
Most of what I've got so far has been through the 200 game list on the SANFL site, (it includes state games)
Then referanced through the legends section of footysa.
I have only marked yes to the players who definatly played over 200 club games (one club) between 1970 and 1990.

I really doubt that the club's records are any better than internet searching, If infact anyone is even checking.

Thanks for the help so far.

...

Good work JC67. Are you writing NO next to the players that dont qualify or just leaving them blank ?

 

[jc67]

Only a few players eliminated tonight.
I will be away for the weekend so keep posting any that can be eliminated
I am just deleting those that have been ruled out (either with a reliable source or by a credible poster)
Apparently there are a few books (almanac style from the 80's) one called "The State Of The Game" or something very similar to that circa 1989,
I hope that a few of you might know someone with these books and will ask them for a loan if it.
Plenty of people would keep their scores in their Budget in those days also, so if you know of anybody that might have kept them ask them too.
Also there must be some players on the current list that played in the 1920's or something, so if you know any for sure, post them.


Mr D K Phillis Glenelg
Mr P F Marker Glenelg yes
Mr R H Voigt Glenelg
Mr W Phillis Glenelg
Mr G S Cornes OAM Glenelg yes
Mr P Carey Glenelg yes
Mr J MacFarlane Glenelg yes
Mr S Copping Glenelg
Mr D Marshall Glenelg yes
Mr C McDermott Glenelg yes yes
Mr K H Hodgeman Glenelg yes
Mr J D Seebohm Glenelg
Mr S J Salisbury Glenelg
Mr P J Maynard Glenelg
Mr M Redden North Adelaide yes
Mr D H A Gilbourne North Adelaide
Dr J L Riley North Adelaide yes
Mr T I Clisby North Adelaide yes
Mr P G Arnold North Adelaide
Mr D Hart North Adelaide/Central
Mr P R Bennett North Adelaide
Mr K Klomp North Adelaide/Sturt
Mr D J Sanders North Adelaide
Mr B Phillips North Adelaide
Mr B Winter Norwood yes
Mr M Taylor Norwood
Dr M Gregg Norwood
Mr N Button Norwood
Mr G Nicholson Norwood
Mr P Gallagher Norwood yes
Mr J Wynne Norwood yes
Mr F Stemper Norwood
Mr J L Michalanney Norwood
Mr M C Aish Norwood yes
Mr T P Warhurst Norwood
Mr K Thomas Norwood yes
Mr N Roberts Norwood Doubt it
Mr J A Scanlon Norwood
Mr C Balme Norwood
Mr G McIntosh Norwood
Mr A Jarman Norwood/North
Mr J D’Antiochia Norwood
Mr D Jenkins Norwood
Mr R F Schoff Sturt
Mr R M Rigney Sturt
Mr B C Adcock Sturt
Mr P L Bagshaw OBE Sturt yes
Mr P M Nelson Sturt
Mr A P Burgan Sturt yes
Mr E R Davies Sturt/South yes
Mr M Graham Sturt yes
Mr T Sims Sturt
Mr E Fry Sturt
Mr J C Paynter Sturt yes
Mr R J Klomp Sturt yes
Mr G L Whittlesea Sturt yes
Mr D Smith Sturt
Mr J Richter Sturt
Mr C Thredgold Sturt
Mr B Lennon Sturt
Mr D Woosnam Sturt
C.Casey yes