I think sos was just putting his recruiters hat on. It's been clear that Brayshaw has at times been played at times out of position or not getting enough game time. So of course from a recruiters point of view you would ask about Brayshaw as he fills a need because Higgins is going. They said Brayshaw isn't worth pick 2 or 11 but didn't go into too much detail.
WCE
0 v COL
0 PM
NWD
0 v NA
0 PM
FRA
0 v COB
0 PM
NEW
0 v CRO
0 PM
MEL
0 v SYD
0 PM
PER
0 v ILL
0 PM
NZB
0 v BNE
0 PM
WSW
0 v BRI
0 PM
STK
7.6
48 v RIC
20.14
134 FT
RIC
13.17
95 v SAN
7.13
55 FT
BRI
12 v PEN
20 FT
MEM
113 v DAL
114 FT
LAL
113 v BOS
121 FT
HOU
124 v IND
132 FT
PHX
122 v SAC
114 FT
CHA
90 v CLE
103 FT
CHI
106 v ORL
115 FT
DET
98 v LAC
100 FT
NO
106 v NY
116 FT
TOR
117 v SA
112 FT
ATL
109 v MIL
120 FT
PHI
123 v BRO
117 FT
OKC
109 v GS
147 FT
SAC
111 v WSH
123 FT
SYD
97 v SEM
90 FT
MIN
105 v MIL
130 FT
CLE
101 v GS
119 FT
DEN
123 v MIA
106 FT
-
LIVE: West Coast v Collingwood - Bounce @ 6:10 WST / 8:10 EST
Squiggle sez: Eagles 66% chance to win -- What's your tip?
Oppo Camp The Loony Bin - Now sponsored by the AA Selectors
- Thread starter LeverPuller
- Start date
- Tagged users None
A11dAtP0w3R
Enjoying my teams losses more than I should 😙
- Oct 18, 2013
- 42,435
- 49,030
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers. Zach Wilson.
Melbourne football department for saying we have enough leg speed on the list. What a bunch of nuffies.
Dory_77
Premiership Player
- Apr 2, 2012
- 4,965
- 4,375
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
They saw Salem's GPS numbers and were sold that nothing else was needed.
Toump Ass
Norm Smith Medallist
Apparently three in every four posters on the Carlton Board is "IN THE KNOW" with a "DIRECT LINE" to the board/ coach/ playing group/ captain's wife & side-b*tch too.
"100% STRIKE RATE OVER THE LONGEST TIME! NEVER BEEN WRONG ABOUT TRADING, DRAFT TARGETS, INJURIES OR TEAM SELECTIONS, NEVER BEEN WRONG ABOUT ANYTHING EVER BEFORE!!!"
Paddy McFartin gets an interview, "OH THAT'S A SURPRISE!!!". Luke Dunstan being traded to Carlton? "Who is Luke Dustant, where are theys from?"
Not a single one of them have "inside knowledge" that wasn't on the front page of the Herald-Sun first.
Every club has their nuffies, but Caltron are nothing but.
"Yeah nah, Oliver's not a need, we've got Merrett lined up".
Of course Oliver's a need you turnip, your team is toilet, how many games are you going to win with pensioners like Eddie Betts and Marc Murphy around?
And which ******* idiot is going to pick ZACKARY ******* MERRETT over Clayton Oliver?!?
(LOL "We're trading in Oliver, but we're also trading in Paddy and Dunstan, you know, for our VFL team...")
"CALTRON ARE COMNIG!!! CALTRON ARE COMING!!!"
******* idiots, oh my god. Legitimately the dumbest posters not only on bigfooty but the entire ******* Internet.
"100% STRIKE RATE OVER THE LONGEST TIME! NEVER BEEN WRONG ABOUT TRADING, DRAFT TARGETS, INJURIES OR TEAM SELECTIONS, NEVER BEEN WRONG ABOUT ANYTHING EVER BEFORE!!!"
Paddy McFartin gets an interview, "OH THAT'S A SURPRISE!!!". Luke Dunstan being traded to Carlton? "Who is Luke Dustant, where are theys from?"
Not a single one of them have "inside knowledge" that wasn't on the front page of the Herald-Sun first.
Every club has their nuffies, but Caltron are nothing but.
"Yeah nah, Oliver's not a need, we've got Merrett lined up".
Of course Oliver's a need you turnip, your team is toilet, how many games are you going to win with pensioners like Eddie Betts and Marc Murphy around?
And which ******* idiot is going to pick ZACKARY ******* MERRETT over Clayton Oliver?!?
(LOL "We're trading in Oliver, but we're also trading in Paddy and Dunstan, you know, for our VFL team...")
"CALTRON ARE COMNIG!!! CALTRON ARE COMING!!!"
******* idiots, oh my god. Legitimately the dumbest posters not only on bigfooty but the entire ******* Internet.
A11dAtP0w3R
Enjoying my teams losses more than I should 😙
- Oct 18, 2013
- 42,435
- 49,030
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers. Zach Wilson.
It genuinely make me mad at how many stupid decision we make. This one is so bleeding obvious yet they can't see it themselves.
I honestly can't wait for the this season to go to sh*t so all the campaigners are out on their arses.
Wholesome.
Toump Ass
Norm Smith Medallist
Ok I'm embarrassed I typed that 
The Bluemour thread delivers again.
I dreamt last night that Oliver had genuinely bought into what Carlton was building and was willing to take unders in term of salary.
My footy dreams have come true before. Still waiting on the one where I kick the winning goal in a Carlton premiership, though...
I dreamt last night that Oliver had genuinely bought into what Carlton was building and was willing to take unders in term of salary.
My footy dreams have come true before. Still waiting on the one where I kick the winning goal in a Carlton premiership, though...
He just wants to be a green shoot
Read the early pages here for mental gymnastics about how 'PICK 7 WILL NOT BE INVOLVED'.
As if they have any ******* input into it.
(They just traded pick 7 and a third round upgrade for him)
I heard a nuffy on SEN1116 who said that Preuss wasn't the failure Gawn is and that we haven't lost when Pruess was main ruckman. I'm not sure of the exact record but huddo said our record was 3-7 when Preuss is in the side. He went on to say that gawn has been found out and we should have played Preuss as a ruckman and Gawn as a follower. The thing the got me was when he said luke Jackson is injury prone.
Gysberts2Bate
Brownlow Medallist
It was Austin Bradtke
Gysberts2Bate
Brownlow Medallist
It honestly is a real shame that Preuss isn’t just a few more years younger than Gawn. Max looks like he’ll be able to ruck at AA standard or close to it for another 4-5 years like Sandilands but I reckon Preuss and Jackson would make a decent 1-2 ruck combo if not, and would offer us more than playing injury-prone Jackson as the number 1 ruck when Gawn retires and having to find another similarly mobile forward/utility talent (they don’t exist), even if Jackson turns out to be a better tap ruck than Preuss. Hoping we do bring in another Preuss level player at a better age for us fairly cheap, or Bradtke turns out to be that guy so Jackson can just be more flexible.
Jordie_tackles
Norm Smith Medallist
Injury prone Jackson?
Gysberts2Bate
Brownlow Medallist
Was referencing @mrmonkey’s post
MarcMaverick
Melbourne Buccaneer
- Nov 20, 2008
- 5,919
- 5,122
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- The Super Saiyans, Tampa Bay Buccs
Could we change the title to incorporate Ned Guy or Collingwoods shambles?
TheCount
Moderator
This needs a bump, so I'll kick off.
The weak defence that kept them to a smaller score than when they played in the wet last week, and made their much vaunted small forward brigade absolutely irrelevant. I've only just realised Jack Lonie played last night.
What would you prefer? A mid/forward beast who has turned himself into a top 5 player in the comp? Or a young key forward who hasn't done anything.
TheCount
Moderator
Probably not no, but even what is being suggested there needs to be mentioned. Because if Richo is still there, then they're winning, which is apparently a bad thing?
Gysberts2Bate
Brownlow Medallist
Imagine winning with Richo on your coaching staff
No arguments there, would be like saying we wouldn't want martin because we would have been winning more.
Proper Gander
Owl whisperer and secret agent
I’m glad you pulled this one out for de-construction. I read it on the Saints board yesterday evening and didn’t really understand it in any way
