The MCG should always host the Grand Final post pandemic.

Remove this Banner Ad

Oct 2, 2008
8,897
18,482
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Brothers of Destruction
In the last 15 seasons of AFL Football 12 premierships have been won by Victorian sides whilst a measly two (Sydney 2012, Eagles 2018) were won by Interstate rivals. Here's a recap of the victories since - which includes 3 dynasties.

Hawthorn - 2008, 2013, 2014, 2015
Richmond - 2017, 2019, 2020
Geelong - 2007, 2009, 2011
Collingwood - 2010
Western Bulldogs - 2016

Now the narrative on Big Footy for many years was simple. Supporters of interstate sides continuously moaned about the Grand Final being played at the MCG. Hawthorn's three peat victories against Fremantle, West Coast and Sydney sparked the fury - Richmond's dominate record breaking undefeated streak at the MCG made it constant dialogue.

In the 2020 season - something unpredictable happened, unprecedented- the Grand Final - the entire finals series was played outside Victoria. The Victorian sides played the majority of their season interstate, made the finals and under unbelievable living conditions, these milestone victories occurred in the finals.

- Collingwood knocked out West Coast in Perth, after being locked in quarantine Hubs for a one week and being publicity humiliated in WA newspapers. They defeated the Eagles by 1 point and knocked them out.

- Richmond defeated Port Adelaide in the Preliminary Final - in Adelaide, by 1 goal, in a dour low scoring affair - having slept in a homeless shelter the night before the game according to Dylan Grimes.

- Geelong demolished a pathetic Brisbane at the Gabba - having spent over 100 days living away from their families.

Now in season 2021, after the Bulldogs remarkable victory. Here we are again, the finals series is down to four teams, no Victorian finals, Victorian teams like Melbourne playing their well earned home final in Adelaide - were down to four - three of them?

Melbourne, Footscray and Geelong.

Can we squash the conversation that Interstate teams are disadvantaged with the current system set up? Can we stop hearing pathetic complaints about the Grand Final being moved away from the MCG in the future? The Interstate teams transitioned into the old VFL, not vice versa.

The MCG is the biggest stadium in the country, 40,000 more people can see the game live.

This thread should honestly be placed atop the BF threads board every finals series.

Interstate sides - its not the MCG that stopped your premiership chances, the best team wins no matter where or when. The GF should always be played where it belongs, at the biggest, most historical stadium in the country.
 
Nice troll, however, i think you have a point but before we arrange to clear the covid riddled state and allow the GF back to the G could we just rule out that silly conspiracy theory that suggest a pro Vic bias at the top level.
Im thinking hand over administration and officiating to the WAFL for a season and see how the dust settles on another interstate finals series.

Nah, didnt think so.
 
In the last 15 seasons of AFL Football 12 premierships have been won by Victorian sides whilst a measly two (Sydney 2012, Eagles 2018) were won by Interstate rivals. Here's a recap of the victories since - which includes 3 dynasties.

Hawthorn - 2008, 2013, 2014, 2015
Richmond - 2017, 2019, 2020
Geelong - 2007, 2009, 2011
Collingwood - 2010
Western Bulldogs - 2016

Now the narrative on Big Footy for many years was simple. Supporters of interstate sides continuously moaned about the Grand Final being played at the MCG. Hawthorn's three peat victories against Fremantle, West Coast and Sydney sparked the fury - Richmond's dominate record breaking undefeated streak at the MCG made it constant dialogue.

In the 2020 season - something unpredictable happened, unprecedented- the Grand Final - the entire finals series was played outside Victoria. The Victorian sides played the majority of their season interstate, made the finals and under unbelievable living conditions, these milestone victories occurred in the finals.

- Collingwood knocked out West Coast in Perth, after being locked in quarantine Hubs for a one week and being publicity humiliated in WA newspapers. They defeated the Eagles by 1 point and knocked them out.

- Richmond defeated Port Adelaide in the Preliminary Final - in Adelaide, by 1 goal, in a dour low scoring affair - having slept in a homeless shelter the night before the game according to Dylan Grimes.

- Geelong demolished a pathetic Brisbane at the Gabba - having spent over 100 days living away from their families.

Now in season 2021, after the Bulldogs remarkable victory. Here we are again, the finals series is down to four teams, no Victorian finals, Victorian teams like Melbourne playing their well earned home final in Adelaide - were down to four - three of them?

Melbourne, Footscray and Geelong.

Can we squash the conversation that Interstate teams are disadvantaged with the current system set up? Can we stop hearing pathetic complaints about the Grand Final being moved away from the MCG in the future? The Interstate teams transitioned into the old VFL, not vice versa.

The MCG is the biggest stadium in the country, 40,000 more people can see the game live.

This thread should honestly be placed atop the BF threads board every finals series.

Interstate sides - its not the MCG that stopped your premiership chances, the best team wins no matter where or when. The GF should always be played where it belongs, at the biggest, most historical stadium in the country.
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA

The only response such as a post deserves. I'm sure you'll get similar responses when it gets move to the Bay for trolling.

Kudos though for trying to justify something completely unjustifiable, except to the entitled.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Someone had a great idea the other day. Have it something like this:

MCG, AO, MCG, SCG, MCG, OS, MCG, GABBA and repeat.
Or the Prelim Final weekend rotated around Australia every year, then "coming home" to the MCG for the Grand Final.
 
In the last 15 seasons of AFL Football 12 premierships have been won by Victorian sides whilst a measly two (Sydney 2012, Eagles 2018) were won by Interstate rivals. Here's a recap of the victories since - which includes 3 dynasties.

Hawthorn - 2008, 2013, 2014, 2015
Richmond - 2017, 2019, 2020
Geelong - 2007, 2009, 2011
Collingwood - 2010
Western Bulldogs - 2016

Now the narrative on Big Footy for many years was simple. Supporters of interstate sides continuously moaned about the Grand Final being played at the MCG. Hawthorn's three peat victories against Fremantle, West Coast and Sydney sparked the fury - Richmond's dominate record breaking undefeated streak at the MCG made it constant dialogue.

In the 2020 season - something unpredictable happened, unprecedented- the Grand Final - the entire finals series was played outside Victoria. The Victorian sides played the majority of their season interstate, made the finals and under unbelievable living conditions, these milestone victories occurred in the finals.

- Collingwood knocked out West Coast in Perth, after being locked in quarantine Hubs for a one week and being publicity humiliated in WA newspapers. They defeated the Eagles by 1 point and knocked them out.

- Richmond defeated Port Adelaide in the Preliminary Final - in Adelaide, by 1 goal, in a dour low scoring affair - having slept in a homeless shelter the night before the game according to Dylan Grimes.

- Geelong demolished a pathetic Brisbane at the Gabba - having spent over 100 days living away from their families.

Now in season 2021, after the Bulldogs remarkable victory. Here we are again, the finals series is down to four teams, no Victorian finals, Victorian teams like Melbourne playing their well earned home final in Adelaide - were down to four - three of them?

Melbourne, Footscray and Geelong.

Can we squash the conversation that Interstate teams are disadvantaged with the current system set up? Can we stop hearing pathetic complaints about the Grand Final being moved away from the MCG in the future? The Interstate teams transitioned into the old VFL, not vice versa.

The MCG is the biggest stadium in the country, 40,000 more people can see the game live.

This thread should honestly be placed atop the BF threads board every finals series.

Interstate sides - its not the MCG that stopped your premiership chances, the best team wins no matter where or when. The GF should always be played where it belongs, at the biggest, most historical stadium in the country.
Dude, if it wasn’t for your MCG advantage Richmond wouldn’t of even made the grand final in ‘17.
 
Its a shame we have invisible borders that define us in this country as there are a few of you Vics that are actually decent people.
Invisible lines in the dirt everywhere lead to nothing but division, and such braindead concepts as nationalism, patriotism and parochialism, which all lessen us as a species.
 
Dude, if it wasn’t for your MCG advantage Richmond wouldn’t of even made the grand final in ‘17.
C'mon, don't you love the argument that there's no such thing as home ground advantage so we should have it every year?

I think that if there is no such thing as home ground advantage, then non-Victorian teams should be automatically be given hosting rights to Prelim Finals..... no difference right?
 
In the last 15 seasons of AFL Football 12 premierships have been won by Victorian sides whilst a measly two (Sydney 2012, Eagles 2018) were won by Interstate rivals. Here's a recap of the victories since - which includes 3 dynasties.

Hawthorn - 2008, 2013, 2014, 2015
Richmond - 2017, 2019, 2020
Geelong - 2007, 2009, 2011
Collingwood - 2010
Western Bulldogs - 2016
Only seeing one dynasty there myself.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The Interstate teams transitioned into the old VFL, not vice versa.

Entitlement is always a strong argument by the encumbent AFRAID of a merit based location as is all other finals.

We have ALL the best in the AFL, not some of the best as in the old State League days .....
 
The G is a soulless ground

Optus Oval is the true home of footy

The Melbourne Cricket Club .... dont have 25000 seats, the AFL wont squirrell another 20k.

Be interesting to know how many seats are available to competing clubs/the footy public.

GF for the footy public, not at the G, unless the local scalpers are up to it?
 
Only seeing one dynasty there myself.

:thumbsu:

How some need to dum down achievements: a threepeat requires going back to back twice in a row, thats why its top of the tree, what all fans want.

Geelong certainly have plenty to cheer about, the PFs are remarkable & before the knockers knock, 14 teams are in mothballs that weekend.
My team :thumbsdown:
 
Entitlement is always a strong argument by the encumbent AFRAID of a merit based location as is all other finals.

We have ALL the best in the AFL, not some of the best as in the old State League days .....
All other finals locations based on merit????

2019 Geelong finish 1st and have to play 4th placed Collingwood on their home ground
2017 Geelong finish 2nd and have to play 3rd placed Richmond on their home ground
2016 Swans finish 1st and have to play 4th placed GWS at ANZ stadium
2016 Geelong finish 2nd and have to play 3rd placed Hawks on their home ground
2009 Saints finish 1st and have to play 4th placed Collingwood on their home ground
2008 Saints finish 4th and have to play 8th placed Collingwood on their home ground
2007 North finish 4th and have to play 5th placed Hawks on their home ground
2007 Geelong finish 1st and have to play 6th placed Collingwood on their home ground
 
The Melbourne Cricket Club .... dont have 25000 seats, the AFL wont squirrell another 20k.

Be interesting to know how many seats are available to competing clubs/the footy public.

GF for the footy public, not at the G, unless the local scalpers are up to it?
The footy public.

You dont reckon AFL Members count as part of the "footy public"? Clubs count them as part of their members.

MCC members, plenty also have club membership packages. There was nothing stopping a WC fan putting their name on the MCC waiting list back in 1987 to get access to a GF ticket if the Eagles made it.

Your gripe is that the GF at the G doesn't cater to the Perth footy public....it caters to the majority of the footy public, as the majority of the footy public is outside of Perth.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top