Roast The media....*Shakes Head* Part 6

[LFC2010]

Jake Neade - Above Average
SPP - Below Average.

farken lol.

 

[Steve Dore]

Jake Neade - Above Average
SPP - Below Average.

farken lol.

What's this based on?

 

[LFC2010]

What's this based on?

Looking at the ratings it looks like Jon Ralph has done them.

 

[PatientMental]

Jake Neade - Above Average
SPP - Below Average.

farken lol.

Neade compared to all general forwards in comp. SPP compared to all other mids in comp.

AFL ratings (essentially the same data set as that papers Champion Data):
SPP is the 114th best mid for over the last 2 seasons according to the AFL. Neade is the 51st best best small/med forward over the last 2 season.

Hence the Below Average rating.

 

[Grave Danger]

Jake Neade - Above Average
SPP - Below Average.

farken lol.

 

[LFC2010]

Neade compared to all general forwards in comp. SPP compared to all other mids in comp.

AFL ratings (essentially the same data set as that papers Champion Data):
SPP is the 114th best mid for over the last 2 seasons according to the AFL. Neade is the 51st best best small/med forward over the last 2 season.

Hence the Below Average rating.

and that is where the AFL system is flawed.
at least with champion data they do tend to rate players to the role they play. eg KPF, small forward etc...etc...

 

[PatientMental]

For comparison, here's the rest of our list on 2016/17 AFL Ratings (practically CD) form:

Key Forwards
Westhoff - #4 (Wing not specified in it yet)
Dixon - #9
Howard - #54
Marshall - #65

Small/Medium Forwards
Wingard - #4
Watts - #14 (Yes, really he's seen as a S/M Forward for some reason)
Thomas - #39
Neade - #51
Johnson - #120

Midfielder/Forwards
Gray - #1
Motlop - #9
S.Gray - #14
Amon - #23

Ruck
Ryder - #11

Midfielders
Wines - #23
Rockliff - #29
Boak - #42 (5th for Midfielder/Forwards)
Polec - #49
Ebert - #55
SPP - #114
Toumpas - #134
Trengove - #145
Atley - #148
Snelling - #149

Small/Medium Defenders
Pittard - #15
Broadbent - #24
Hartlett - #36
Jonas - #43
DBJ - #53
Clurey - #70
Houston - #102
McKenzie - #112
Bonner - #132

Key Defenders
Hombsch - #44

 

[tribey]

Jake Neade - Above Average
SPP - Below Average.

farken lol.

Neade getting a huge boost via things like 'pressure acts (yuck)', SPP getting downgraded due to his lack of raw accumulation and presumably kicking efficiency.

 

[PatientMental]

Neade getting a huge boost via things like 'pressure acts (yuck)', SPP getting downgraded due to his lack of raw accumulation and presumably kicking efficiency.

And SPP having only played 23 games hurts. If he plays an identical year to last he will end up around 49th/50th in the Champion Data/AFL Ratings lists.

 

[Moo87]

SPP’s rating is bad, but I’m probably more outraged about them classifying Dougal and Clurey as below average defenders.

 

[Spadge]

For comparison, here's the rest of our list on 2016/17 AFL Ratings (practically CD) form:

Ruck
Ryder - #11

hahaha ummm yeah ok

 

[PatientMental]

hahaha ummm yeah ok

Hahahahaha, yeah, I know, it's almost like he's only played 22 of a possible 45 games over the past two years or something.

If he replicates 2017 he'd be the outright #1 ruck by 190 ranking points and below Patrick Dangerfield and above Dustin Martin in #2 overall.

Removing the season before rankings and only using 2017's Ryder is the #1 ruck and 8th Overall.
Martin
Dangerfield
Fyfe
Sloane
Pendlebury
Zorko
Franklin
Ryder

 

[StrappingTape]

Ignoring the ratings that is a good age profile.

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

What's this based on?

Last 2 years numbers. SPP only has 1 years of numbers/ranking points, ergo ratings in the below average.

 

[Garibaldi Red]

Wallsy at his best again tonight on AFL Tonight.

He says Freo will make the 8. Not an unreasonable call IMO but the reason he gives? Because they have 13 games at home, WTF! No Robert they have 12 games at their home stadium, just like we do.

Get the easy things right before you start to get into the other areas of the game.

 

[Grave Danger]

Wallsy at his best again tonight on AFL Tonight.

He says Freo will make the 8. Not an unreasonable call IMO but the reason he gives? Because they have 13 games at home, WTF! No Robert they have 12 games at their home stadium, just like we do.

Get the easy things right before you start to get into the other areas of the game.

The Suns are playing a home game there due to the Empire Games.

 

[Garibaldi Red]

The Suns are playing a home game there due to the Empire Games.

Ooops.

 

[tribey]

The Suns are playing a home game there due to the Empire Games.

One home game in Perth, another in China.

They don't do things by halves.

 

[Grave Danger]

One home game in Perth, another in China.

They don't do things by halves.

If The City of Churches ever gets the Games this millennium our Shanghai match might just have to be a home game that year, and we could play any others required at Alberton

 

[Doctor Feel]

Backline stocktake: How your defenders are tracking

Kyle Hartigan: Proved himself against the competition's best key forwards. Rested for the first JLT game, but looked solid in the second.

MFW Watts kicked six on him. "Looked solid"

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-19/backline-stocktake-how-your-defenders-are-tracking

 

[tribey]

Backline stocktake: How your defenders are tracking

Kyle Hartigan: Proved himself against the competition's best key forwards. Rested for the first JLT game, but looked solid in the second.

MFW Watts kicked six on him. "Looked solid"

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-19/backline-stocktake-how-your-defenders-are-tracking

View attachment 471923

Well, he did look solid insomuch as he wasn't a gas, nor a liquid.

 

[Amarula]

Backline stocktake: How your defenders are tracking

Kyle Hartigan: Proved himself against the competition's best key forwards. Rested for the first JLT game, but looked solid in the second.

MFW Watts kicked six on him. "Looked solid"

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-19/backline-stocktake-how-your-defenders-are-tracking

View attachment 471923

Maybe this is "solid" as in "as mobile as a small building".

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Chris Judd has a hard on for us to fail for some reason

 

[tribey]

Chris Judd has a hard on for us to fail for some reason

Might have something to do with his and Cousins' last game for West Coast?

 

[TeeKray]

Might have something to do with his and Cousins' last game for West Coast?

His record against us in general was poor by his lofty standards.