Remove this Banner Ad

Certified Legendary Thread The New Carlton Thread: when Carlton looks into the abyss they see Carlton

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Acres is an A Grader, whilst Steele is a washed up hack.

The brain of a Carlton supporter works in fkd up ways...
I don't think they're quite firing on all synapses there.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Bagging the Blose is fun - we don't need to overdo in the next couple of days - despite the egg shortage we could end up with egg on our face...😞 🥚🥚
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Bagging the Blose is fun - we don't need to overdo in the next couple of days - despite the egg shortage we could end up with egg on our face...😞 🥚🥚

Yeah nah.

If the unthinkable happens tomorrow night, just ignore this thread until the world rights itself again - our next win or their next loss.
 
Yeah nah.

If the unthinkable happens tomorrow night, just ignore this thread until the world rights itself again - our next win or their next loss.
Excuse my caution - the scars from 1970 resurface now and then - 1970 "survivors" are wary of trauma resurfacing...
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

With how poor Haynes has been, it got me thinking about our track record with former Giants players compared to them, Carlton have got all the spuds while we’ve got the good ones lmao

Carlton:

Marchbank
Plowman
Jarrod Pickett
Setterfield
Bugg
Williams
Haynes
Phillips
Jaksch
Whiley
Kennedy

The only one they got that was any good they traded and treated like crap, and that was Kennedy

Also a quiet reminder that they paid Williams big bucks over a couple of good finals

Pies:
Hoskin
Treloar
Adams
Perryman
Bobby

Not counting Keeffe and Shaw as they went from Pies to Giants not the other way

All of that Pies list have played in GF’s and two have won flags and one a Norm Smith, Carlton’s list are delisted and haven’t done that outside of Haynes and Williams which I’ll give them credit for

So Giants players that want to leave in the future, come to the Pies
 
With how poor Haynes has been, it got me thinking about our track record with former Giants players compared to them, Carlton have got all the spuds while we’ve got the good ones lmao

Carlton:

Marchbank
Plowman
Jarrod Pickett
Setterfield
Bugg
Williams
Haynes
Phillips
Jaksch
Whiley
Kennedy

The only one they got that was any good they traded and treated like crap, and that was Kennedy

Also a quiet reminder that they paid Williams big bucks over a couple of good finals

Pies:
Hoskin
Treloar
Adams
Perryman
Bobby

Not counting Keeffe and Shaw as they went from Pies to Giants not the other way

All of that Pies list have played in GF’s and two have won flags and one a Norm Smith, Carlton’s list are delisted and haven’t done that outside of Haynes and Williams which I’ll give them credit for

So Giants players that want to leave in the future, come to the Pies
I’ll keep my powder dry but this could be a beautiful copy and paste to share with our Carlton friends at the right moment
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Certified Legendary Thread The New Carlton Thread: when Carlton looks into the abyss they see Carlton

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top