The Next Big Thing - Jake Stringer

[Abomination]

I was responding to a post that made the comparison. Keep up.

Yes, you responded to a poor comparison by making an even poorer declaration. Keep up.

 

[AjsGuns]

What a bizarre comparison. Not only has Stringer got about 30 games experience on Hogan, but this season Hogan is averaging more SC and DT points than Stringer anyway. So while it's debatable that Stringer is the better player (I'd consider him more versatile), it's still a stupid comparison considering the experience gap. If you want a fair comparison between the two, let's compare Stringer's first 10 games with Hogan's and we're getting somewhere.

Or maybe we could just compare Boyd and Hogan? A far better comparison considering their age and no. of games played.

lol at using DT and SC points in a comparison, do you even football? /facepalm

 

[Super Hans]

Do Melbourne supporters have to make every thread about Hogan?

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[The_Ru]

Clint Bizzell loves this thread.

 

[Substance]

Yes, you responded to a poor comparison by making an even poorer declaration. Keep up.

I was speaking truth, you just won't hear it. Bag the comparison all you like, but if you ARE going to compare the 2, then Stringer is the clear winner.

 

[Abomination]

Do Melbourne supporters have to make every thread about Hogan?

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

In case you missed it: it was a Hawks supporter that raised the comparison, a Melbourne supporter calling the comparison idiotic, and a Bulldogs supporter calling Stringer the better player of the two. Nice try though.

 

[Abomination]

lol at using DT and SC points in a comparison, do you even football? /facepalm

LOL at Bulldogs supporters calling Stringer in his 38th game better than Hogan after 10.

 

[AjsGuns]

LOL at Bulldogs supporters calling Stringer in his 38th game better than Hogan after 10.

Stringer > Hogan
Dogs > Melbourne

 

[Igloo]

Can I not come into a thread about the package to bask in his glory without having to read about Hogan again?

 

[Substance]

LOL at Bulldogs supporters calling Stringer in his 38th game better than Hogan after 10.

He is better than Hogan regardless of how many games they have played. Got it yet?

 

[BRADLESTICKS]

he is much more important to the dogs future than bontempelli

 

[go you pups]

If you cant squeeze Wallis in there you are doing it wrong

3 votes tonight, his hands in close were brilliant and he chimed in with 3 snags himself.

 

[King Bont]

What a bizarre comparison. Not only has Stringer got about 30 games experience on Hogan, but this season Hogan is averaging more SC and DT points than Stringer anyway. So while it's debatable that Stringer is the better player (I'd consider him more versatile), it's still a stupid comparison considering the experience gap. If you want a fair comparison between the two, let's compare Stringer's first 10 games with Hogan's and we're getting somewhere.

Or maybe we could just compare Boyd and Hogan? A far better comparison considering their age and no. of games played.

But are you forgetting they got to there respective clubs the same year? Hogan has been in an AFL system just as long

 

[SdKfz 181]

The next big thing - Jake "The Package" Stringer*

 

[Eshay187]

Bulldogs fans are really up and about.

 

[Scary_Foot_9]

Bulldogs fans are really up and about.

Wouldn't you be, if you had Jakey Stringer for the next decade?

 

[Abomination]

Stringer > Hogan
Dogs > Melbourne

Melbourne 15.13.103 to Bulldogs 9.10.64.
http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2015/8/melb-v-wb

He is better than Hogan regardless of how many games they have played. Got it yet?

Jarryd Roughead's better than Stringer, regardless of how many games he's played. Got it yet?

But are you forgetting they got to there respective clubs the same year? Hogan has been in an AFL system just as long

I'll respectfully disagree that # of years in the system is more important than # games played. Drafted in the same year, yes, but Hogan was taken as an underage player in the mini-draft while Stringer was taken at 18. No one's denying Stringer's a gun, but comparing him to Hogan after 10 games doesn't make sense for a whole host of reasons and I'll rightfully point that out.

It's not unlike the way Bulldogs supporters cry foul when Boyd is compared to Hogan.

 

[F_therest]

Stringer is a gun.

Wtf comparisons to Ben Brown and Jesse Hogan ?? Completely different players all 3.

But based on current career output stringer easily tops. But I rate Ben Brown he was good last year particularly and we are seeing Hogan emerge this year

 

[F_therest]

Melbourne 15.13.103 to Bulldogs 9.10.64.
http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2015/8/melb-v-wb


Jarryd Roughead's better than Stringer, regardless of how many games he's played. Got it yet?


I'll respectfully disagree that # of years in the system is more important than # games played. Drafted in the same year, yes, but Hogan was taken as an underage player in the mini-draft while Stringer was taken at 18. No one's denying Stringer's a gun, but comparing him to Hogan after 10 games doesn't make sense for a whole host of reasons and I'll rightfully point that out.

It's not unlike the way Bulldogs supporters cry foul when Boyd is compared to Hogan.

Did you really try to prove that Melbourne are better than the dogs just because they beat them? Wow.

 

[cleveland]

Why is hogan being mentioned in this thread......nick off dee supporters

 

[fargy]

Melbourne 15.13.103 to Bulldogs 9.10.64.
http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2015/8/melb-v-wb

Yep good win by your boys. The last time Melbourne finished higher than the Dogs on the ladder was in 2006....

What the hell have you done with all your draft picks?!

 

[Substance]

Jarryd Roughead's better than Stringer, regardless of how many games he's played. Got it yet?

You say this as if it isn't true, and is supposed to somehow therefore invalidate my post...

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Melbourne 15.13.103 to Bulldogs 9.10.64.
http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2015/8/melb-v-wb

 

[peppy la pew]

Bulldogs fans are really up and about.

Its been a long time between drinks, good on 'em

Bonts, Wallis, Dollhouse, Stringer, Wood, Libba

All potential A graders, who wouldn't get excited about the future

Melbourne have.....................................oh that's right Freo's next gun FF

 

[bigboysdontcry]

You Still think it's a radical call?? You think he won't kick at least 50 goals this year?