The off topic thread

[SM]

Sure, you're inferring again though - which is fine. Honestly, you're probably right, but (and I've been consistent with this all along) I prefer to wait to see what she says her grand plan is before I judge it. Already I disagree with her blanket statement with stopping Muslims coming in.

She's obviously not going to come out and say "I only want to stop the darkies coming in" is she?

 

[Jatz]

She's obviously not going to come out and say "I only want to stop the darkies coming in" is she?

Pauline pretty much did.

 

[jd2010]

Sure, you're inferring again though - which is fine. Honestly, you're probably right, but (and I've been consistent with this all along) I prefer to wait to see what she says her grand plan is before I judge it. Already I disagree with her blanket statement with stopping Muslims coming in.

I'd be 99% sure that any such policy would end up being racist or easily avoided by people wanting to come in.

Now if she hasn't got a policy thought out well enough (racist or not) don't voice it on national TV.

 

[SM]

Pauline pretty much did.

"Pretty much". You wouldn't be making inferences out of Paulines comments would you now?

 

[typeclub]

What an ill-informed and stupid comment.

Its not a race.

 

[Jatz]

I'd be 99% sure that any such policy would end up being racist or easily avoided by people wanting to come in.

Now if she hasn't got a policy thought out well enough (racist or not) don't voice it on national TV.

I suspect that's the more likely one.

 

[Zidane98]

Its not a race.

You're absolutely correct.

 

[Cruyff14]

Yep, i loved it too. How many eps are there?

Two are out.

 

[SM]

Its not a race.

So Judaism isn't hereditary? There are no identifiable physical characteristics? They don't have a unique language? They don't have a homeland?

People can covert, but Judaism does not seek converts, the large majority of Jews are of a racial group.

But I suspect you knew all this but wanted a bite. Congrats.

 

[SM]

You're absolutely correct.

Not sure how this became a discussion, but I'd advise you to do some research.

The Jewish people are considered both a religious and racial group.

 

[jd2010]

So good it posted 3 times

 

[SM]

So good it posted 3 times

No idea what happened there. Can't delete posts on my phone.

 

[Cruyff14]

Be interesting to see if anyone on here is Muslim, or has been subjected to serious racism.

Sonia knew exactly what she was saying, and if people can't see the racism in it they're as big an idiot as she is.

 

[Jatz]

"Pretty much". You wouldn't be making inferences out of Paulines comments would you now?

Looks like you might be right, I can't find a comment where she specifically says she wants to keep the middle eastern muslims out.

This might help with the proving she's a racist though:

Ms Hanson denied she was seeking a return to the White Australia policy, but suggested that multiculturalism "has not worked".

Anyway, don't know why I'm biting. You're clearly looking for it.

 

[Zidane98]

Not sure how this became a discussion, but I'd advise you to do some research.

The Jewish people are considered both a religious and racial group.

How do you consider them a racial group? Do you realise there is a sizeable Jewish population in Ethiopia? It's a religion. Tell us how you distinguish Jewish people as a racial group.

 

[SM]

Looks like you might be right, I can't find a comment where she specifically says she wants to keep the middle eastern muslims out.

This might help with the proving she's a racist though:

View attachment 267708



Anyway, don't know why I'm biting. You're clearly looking for it.

Huh? You're the one making the argumentative statements.

 

[SM]

Be interesting to see if anyone on here is Muslim, or has been subjected to serious racism.

Sonia knew exactly what she was saying, and if people can't see the racism in it they're as big an idiot as she is.

This.

 

[Zidane98]

Looks like you might be right, I can't find a comment where she specifically says she wants to keep the middle eastern muslims out.

This might help with the proving she's a racist though:

View attachment 267708



Anyway, don't know why I'm biting. You're clearly looking for it.

She's a racist bigot that should be ignored.

 

[Jatz]

So Judaism isn't hereditary? There are no identifiable physical characteristics? They don't have a unique language? They don't have a homeland?

People can covert, but Judaism does not seek converts, the large majority of Jews are of a racial group.

But I suspect you knew all this but wanted a bite. Congrats.

Interestingly, the US disagrees. Jewish was not included as a race on the US Census. Neither here nor there, just an interesting fact.

 

[SM]

How do you consider them a racial group? Do you realise there is a sizeable Jewish population in Ethiopia? It's a religion. Tell us how you distinguish Jewish people as a racial group.

Give it a rest. You said "they're more a religion than a race" which shows you think they have racial characteristics. Ice listed several times how I, and most sane people, see their racial characteristics. I've also said they're both a religion and a race.

 

[typeclub]

So Judaism isn't hereditary? There are no identifiable physical characteristics? They don't have a unique language? They don't have a homeland?

People can covert, but Judaism does not seek converts, the large majority of Jews are of a racial group.

But I suspect you knew all this but wanted a bite. Congrats.

So a bunch of different races can't become Jewish? I know how it works, they're not a race.

 

[SM]

So a bunch of different races can't become Jewish? I know how it works, they're not a race.

You're being deliberately argumentative now. I've already said several times they're a religious group as well.

 

[Cruyff14]

Relevant.

 

[typeclub]

You're being deliberately argumentative now. I've already said several times they're a religious group as well.

Ethnicity =/= race.

 

[SM]

Ethnicity =/= race.

OK.