List Mgmt. The Official Playstation Trade Thread

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Betts are off

Premiership Player
Sep 28, 2016
4,867
7,772
AFL Club
Adelaide
We've all asked for it, now let's go at it.

I'm also not sure why I've made this thread considering I won't be doing make believe trades and firmly believe we should hold onto pick 4.

Anyway, go your hardest traders. Every lady loves a tradie!
Can we hand days off to all the particularly judgmental posters who we all know won't be able to resist criticizing playstation trade's for being playstation trades in a playstation trade thread....

You know who you are!
 

GrommoT

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 7, 2015
6,611
10,254
AFL Club
Adelaide



I might collate some trades here...

Bri
16 F1><F1 [Peter Doherty]
16 48 52><23 28 [briztoon]
Bri 16 21 34><4 __ GWS 6><28 34 45 49 __ Adl 4 28 45 49><6 16 21 [Crow_68] DN
Fre
7 10 F1><4 23 F1 [Crow till I die]
7 10 F1><4 23 __ Adl 4 23><10 14 16 __ Gee 14 16><7 [Bring back Bas]
7 10><17 24 F1 F1 __ Adl 4 28 F1><7 10 14 __ Gee 14 17 24 F1><4 28 [Thetrader15]
7 22><4 49 [me]
7 22><4 45 49 [Kristof]
7 F2><23 F1 [Thetrader15]
10 22><4 [dayton]
22 58><37 45 49 [AdelaideFan14] [70lethal]
22 69><37 45 49 [Scorpus]
GC
15 20 F(11)><4+ [Maggsy]
Gee
14 17 F1><4 [Grotto]
14 17 F1><4 45 49 [Kristof]
14 17 24><4 [70lethal]
GWS
6 40 F1><4 45 49 [James_37]
6 F1><4+ [Thetrader15] [lunacy] [Maggsy]
6 F1><37 45 49 F1 [WeedsMullet84]
6 F2 F3 F4><37 45 49 F1 [Rory Walkerfield]
6 F2 F3><37 45 49 F1 F4 [James_37]
6 F2><17 24 35 __ Gee 14 17 24><4 F2 __ Adl 4 35><6 14 [Kristof]
6 40><22 23 28 __ Freo 7 10 22><4 6 __ Adl 4 23 28><7 10 40 [70lethal]
6><28 35 45 53 F1 [dayton] DN
6><17 23 __ Gee 14 17><4 __ Adl 4 23><6 14 [Crow_68]
6><17 23 __ Gee 14 17 24><4 49 __ Adl 4 23 49><6 14 24 [Crow_68]
Syd
5 32><4 45 [me]

[F# means 2020 round # pick, + means balancing extras, DN draft night live trading]

For those who don't venture out much, there's also this thread on the main board


.
 
Last edited:

deaneus

You wouldn’t believe me if I told you
Nov 24, 2007
20,325
39,162
*sigh*
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
All-Blacks
I note the thread says Official.

Has it been endorsed by Sony?

I suspect we will give up #4 for #7 and #10 and #82 and a beer coaster
 

dayton

Premiership Player
Apr 12, 2012
3,933
6,298
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Ricciardo, Red Sox



I might collate some trades here...

Bri #16 20'r1 <>20'r1 [Peter Doherty]
Fre #7 20'r2 <>#23 20'r1 [Thetrader15]
Fre #7 #22 <>#4 #49 [me]
GC #15 #20 20'#11 <>#4+ [Maggsy]
GWS #6 <>#28 #35 #45 #53 20'r1 [dayton]
GWS #6 20'r1 <>#4+ [Maggsy]



[20'r* means 2020 pick, + means balancing extras]
My GWS trade above is only relevant if a bid comes for Green at 3 and GWS are allowed to move points around in trades before matching. I believe they can but I could be wrong.

The other trade I've suggested is similar to Maggsy's.

GWS: 6 + 20'r1 + 20'r3(North Melbourne)
ADL: 4
 

ams4crows

Brownlow Medallist
Apr 22, 2007
10,863
11,101
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
T.Swift Huddersfield Town AUFC
Keep 4 but offer 23,28 and 45 for pick 6 with a gaurentee not to bid at on green at 4 or 6

That is best case scenario, tell them we are bidding on green at 4, 6 is gone for them anyway in that case, may as well give them enough points for green for a pick 5 or later bid and get 6 for ourselves.
 

latinoheat

Club Legend
Sep 8, 2008
2,219
2,288
argentina
AFL Club
Adelaide
Will this work:


Gws trade us 6 for 2020 first on draft night after Melbourne have picked. Maybe some late picks as well, ones we won’t use.

so it’s
Pick 4 crows
Picks 5 Sydney
Pick 6 gws

we pick player x at 4
Sydney bids on Green. GWS match with later picks.
Sydney picks player y
We have pick 6 and trade it back to gws for their first pick in 2020.

so this way we keep pick 4, get gws first next year for Next to Nothing , gws get green with later picks and use pick 6 on someone else
 

latinoheat

Club Legend
Sep 8, 2008
2,219
2,288
argentina
AFL Club
Adelaide
Will this work:


Gws trade us 6 for 2020 first on draft night after Melbourne have picked. Maybe some late picks as well, ones we won’t use.

so it’s
Pick 4 crows
Picks 5 Sydney
Pick 6 gws

we pick player x at 4
Sydney bids on Green. GWS match with later picks.
Sydney picks player y
We have pick 6 and trade it back to gws for their first pick in 2020.

so this way we keep pick 4, get gws first next year for Next to Nothing , gws get green with later picks and use pick 6 on someone else
So to clarify , on draft night it will go something like this

pick 1GCS
Pick 2 GCS
Pick swap. We get pick 6, GWS get some later picks and our 2020 2nd
Pick 3 Melbourne
Pick 4 Crows ( we don’t bid on green )
Pick 5 Sydney - select green . GWS match with later picks
Pick 6 Sydney
Pick swap gws get pick 7 for 2020 first and our 2020 second . They then select who they want at 7
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Elite Crow

Premium Platinum
Mar 21, 2008
54,441
74,124
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
So to clarify , on draft night it will go something like this

pick 1GCS
Pick 2 GCS
Pick swap. We get pick 6, GWS get some later picks and our 2020 2nd
Pick 3 Melbourne
Pick 4 Crows ( we don’t bid on green )
Pick 5 Sydney - select green . GWS match with later picks
Pick 6 Sydney
Pick swap gws get pick 7 for 2020 first and our 2020 second . They then select who they want at 7
I think you should have a lie down
 

Kristof

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 3, 2003
18,343
18,649
Brisbane
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Soft spot for Brisbane
So to clarify , on draft night it will go something like this

pick 1GCS
Pick 2 GCS
Pick swap. We get pick 6, GWS get some later picks and our 2020 2nd
Pick 3 Melbourne
Pick 4 Crows ( we don’t bid on green )
Pick 5 Sydney - select green . GWS match with later picks
Pick 6 Sydney
Pick swap gws get pick 7 for 2020 first and our 2020 second . They then select who they want at 7
I think this is what Sydney and West Coast did last year and they've now banned?
 

Kristof

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 3, 2003
18,343
18,649
Brisbane
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Soft spot for Brisbane
Correct, it’s what they did last year, but I didn’t hear it is now banned.
You might be right. There was discussion of changing the rules following that draft, but I can't find any evidence of that actually happening online.
 

AdelaideFan14

Club Legend
Oct 1, 2011
2,423
1,230
Adelaide Hills
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sturt, Celtics, Team Vodafone
If Melbourne bid on Henry at their 2nd pick, we could trade Picks 23 + 28 to Fremantle for 10. We get a second top 10 pick, Fremantle uses picks 22 and 23 to match the bid and then the leftover points would move Pick 28 into around Pick 16-17. That would give Fremantle a shot at drafting another local in Trent Rivers.
 

Rory Walkerfield

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 6, 2012
8,639
15,112
AFL Club
Adelaide
Ok, the ultimate PlayStation trade period:

Melbourne bid on Green at 3, so Adelaide trade 2020 1st, 28 and 45 (gives GWS the point to match) for GWS Pick 6 and 2020 1st

Adelaide picks 4, 23, 37 and 49 to Freo for 7, 10, 22

Adelaide pick 10 to Brisbane for 16 and 21


Adelaide summary
out: 4, 23, 28, 37, 45, 49, 2020 1st
in: 6, 7, 16, 21, 22, GWS 2020 1st
 

Thetrader15

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 16, 2015
13,874
15,165
AFL Club
Adelaide
You might be right. There was discussion of changing the rules following that draft, but I can't find any evidence of that actually happening online.
There was no need to change the rules.

The AFL have to approve every trade and each trade must be considered in isolation.

The ussue was the AFL didn't enforce their own rules because
a) they were ignorant / stupid
b) knew it would benefit both clubs in the long run, which is not considering trades in isolation

No doubt if they see us benefiting, they will decline one of the trades
 

Thetrader15

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 16, 2015
13,874
15,165
AFL Club
Adelaide
I might collate some trades here...

Bri
16 F1><F1 [Peter Doherty]
16 48 52><23 28 [briztoon]
Bri 16 21 34><4 __ GWS 6><28 34 45 49 __ Adl 4 28 45 49><6 16 21 [Crow_68] DN
Fre
7 10 F1><4 23 F1 [Crow till I die]
7 10 F1><4 23 __ Adl 4 23><10 14 16 __ Gee 14 16><7 [Bring back Bas]
7 10><17 24 F1 F1 __ Adl 4 28 F1><7 10 14 __ Gee 14 17 24 F1><4 28 [Thetrader15]
7 22><4 49 [me]
7 22><4 45 49 [Kristof]
7 F2><23 F1 [Thetrader15]
10 22><4 [dayton]
22 58><37 45 49 [AdelaideFan14] [70lethal]
22 69><37 45 49 [Scorpus]
GC
15 20 F(11)><4+ [Maggsy]
Gee
14 17 F1><4 [Grotto]
14 17 F1><4 45 49 [Kristof]
14 17 24><4 [70lethal]
GWS
6 40 F1><4 45 49 [James_37]
6 F1><4+ [Thetrader15] [lunacy] [Maggsy]
6 F1><37 45 49 F1 [WeedsMullet84]
6 F2 F3 F4><37 45 49 F1 [Rory Walkerfield]
6 F2 F3><37 45 49 F1 F4 [James_37]
6 F2><17 24 35 __ Gee 14 17 24><4 F2 __ Adl 4 35><6 14 [Kristof]
6 40><22 23 28 __ Freo 7 10 22><4 6 __ Adl 4 23 28><7 10 40 [70lethal]
6><28 35 45 53 F1 [dayton] DN
6><17 23 __ Gee 14 17><4 __ Adl 4 23><6 14 [Crow_68]
6><17 23 __ Gee 14 17 24><4 49 __ Adl 4 23 49><6 14 24 [Crow_68]

[F# means 2020 round # pick, + means balancing extras, DN draft night live trading]

For those who don't venture out much, there's also this thread on the main board


.
I think this might just work!
 

Kane McGoodwin

TheBrownDog
May 21, 2001
52,860
43,828
Floating around the Universe
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide Crows
Ok, the ultimate PlayStation trade period:

Melbourne bid on Green at 3, so Adelaide trade 2020 1st, 28 and 45 (gives GWS the point to match) for GWS Pick 6 and 2020 1st

Adelaide picks 4, 23, 37 and 49 to Freo for 7, 10, 22

Adelaide pick 10 to Brisbane for 16 and 21


Adelaide summary
out: 4, 23, 28, 37, 45, 49, 2020 1st
in: 6, 7, 16, 21, 22, GWS 2020 1st
I don't think you can trade with another club once a matching is needed. The trade needs to be done prior to Melbourne bidding on Green. Ie. During pick 1 or 2 process.
 

WeedsMullet84

Team Captain
Oct 31, 2018
369
467
AFL Club
Adelaide
Have you got a copy of the relevant draft documentation as was pretty sure the club whose pick it was couldn't trade out their current pick once their selection was up... but the AFL do change the rules all the time.

Vader?
Yes this has been brought up several times already. From everything i've read on drafting/bidding rules i can't see anywhere that says once a bid comes in you can trade your first round out of the draft, for example.
 

Top Bottom