They weren’t.Here's my issue with what you're saying; you're not providing an alternative pathway to a competitive list by this point in time from the time those trades were made, thereby reducing your posts in this thread to hindsight critique which is so far beyond easy as to make it redundant. You refuse to even confront the issue that an AFL list needs to be 45 players, and that even the 'free hit' players in that list - players that were not the 'point' of the trade, and weren't salary dumps - were better than the players they replaced.
You may have well just kept guys like Holman, Everitt, Gowers, Buckley and S.White if you wanted VFL level list cloggers on your list....and improved list continuity.
Palmer, Smedts, O’Shea, Mullet, Shaw, Lobbe, Garlett, A.Silvagni are just as poor as those blokes you already had...and are already being delisted again!
And they are miles off guys like Judd, Carrazzo, Jamison, Walker, Armitage who retired or guys like Henderson, Thouy, Gibbs who you have traded for even more kids.
Hence why Carlton are now 66 games into a ‘total reset’ and are yet to even start building.