Relief ruckman? Since when did we need one?
How many goals did Leigh Brown kick? What has that got to do with anything?
If we go for Tip it will be to play at full forward. Not throw him around like Collingwood have Dawes.
When did I call him crap? Never. He's not a super star by an stretch and if you're giving up good picks/player and 600,000 + per season you'd wanna get a bloody star.
He would improve us, no question.
Here is a list of clubs with a Ruck and relief ruckman/KPF
Hawthorn...Hale and Roughead (finished top 4)
Adelaide...Jacobs and Tippet (finished top 4)
Collingwodd....Jolly and Leigh Brown (finished top 4)
From the above players can you see a pattern??? We need a forward who is a relief ruckman, Hampson is a ruckman not a forward, Casboult, only played 7 games still learning etc etc, how people cannot see that getting Tippet would be a great get is beyond me.