Teams The Ultimate Bigfooty Vanilla Dream Team (Part 25)

Which rookies would you like to see starting on the field?

  • BACKLINE (SELECT 3)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 4. Campbell Heath

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • MIDFIELD (SELECT 3)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 5. Jack Viney

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    6
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

pillager

Club Legend
Mar 27, 2008
1,583
314
Sunshine Coast
AFL Club
Collingwood
We need to select our starting rookies.

Multiple selections are required.

We need to select:

Three Backline Rookies
Three Midfield Rookies

I hope that I am not jumping the gun here but it looks like Lachie Whitfield will be in our team based on the early votes in the previous thread.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The Bigfooty team scored 2050 in round 1.


bfteamround1.png



Please use this thread to make suggestions for possible trades when we use the polls later in the week.
 
Hmm just thinking out aloud here..how about these as options to consider?

McEvoy > Kreuzer & Macaffer > Leuenberger (if he's named) ..cox to fwds

or

Whitfield > Crouch (if named) ..start Viney on the ground
& Macaffer > Leuenberger (if named) ...Cox to fwds

or

Whitfield > Crouch (if named) ..start Viney on the ground
& Macaffer > JJK (think we might have just enough cash)
 
Hmm how about....

McEvoy > Kreuzer & Macaffer > Leuenberger (if he's named) ..cox to fwds

or

Whitfield > Crouch (if named) ..start Viney on the ground
& Macaffer > Leuenberger (if named) ...Cox to fwds

or

Whitfield > Crouch (if named) ..start Viney on the ground
& Macaffer > JJK (think we might have just enough cash)


Thanks for the suggestions Gingy. Your suggestions will carry a lot of weight if Macaffer and Whitfield were to be dropped.

My counter thoughts...

Surely it's too early to pull the trigger on McEvoy & Macaffer?

While Whitfield was certainly underwhelming, Crouch is yet to play a game.

We could look to bring Crouch in at some point before his price rise. We have plenty of time to make a decision on him.

I think Leuenberger is an interesting selection but why not wait until he has played a couple of games so we can get a sighter? He is coming in a little underdone.


My suggestion:

If all of our players are named this week, the only obvious trade to me at this stage is Naismith ---> Rowe (provided Rowe is named).

Having two trades available every single week does not mean that we have use both of them.

These are just my thoughts and idea's and they carry no more weight than yours. The polls will decide the fate of the team.
 
Your points are all valid. I just like trading for the sake of it LOL

If Rowe is named and we do bring him in, I'd prefer if it were in the forwards so we have a DP link with Cox. R4 is a useless money wasting possie IMHO. I know some others like more than 1 playing ruck benchie, but I'd rather the useful ruck DP link @ F8 myself.

Might want to wait and see if either Macaffer or Dwyer are named. Got a feeling Dwyer will miss out this week...lot of midgits in the Collingwood team this year...whatsup with that?
 
Your points are all valid. I just like trading for the sake of it LOL


Might want to wait and see if either Macaffer or Dwyer are named. Got a feeling Dwyer will miss out this week...lot of midgits in the Collingwood team this year...whatsup with that?


I wish I knew.

Sinclair, Elliott, Blair, Dwyer & Kennedy.

Great things come in small packages I guess.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Varcoe > Leuenberger (Cox to Fwds)
Naismith > Rowe (if named)

And whats this not having to trade each week crap? :p
 
I wish I knew.

Sinclair, Elliott, Blair, Dwyer & Kennedy.

Great things come in small packages I guess.


Moneyball recruiting

teams looking for size means smaller players are drafted below their value.
 
Moneyball recruiting

teams looking for size means smaller players are drafted below their value.

For sure, if Kennedy was 10cm taller he would have been a top 3 pick based on his 2 years @ TAC level.
 
Sorry about not running any polls this week people. I was stuck on the highway all afternoon and got home late and I had no internet access. :(
 
What does the team look like this week?

You'd think we'd want JJK in, he's got a really favourable draw coming up

And yeah, I'm jumping in on this thread late, come at me :)
 
Back
Top