Analysis THE "WE SHOULD HAVE TAKEN SPP" TEARS THREAD

SPP or DV, there can be only one Dustin Martin

  • SPP - Has more campaigner than he knows what to do with

    Votes: 71 32.9%
  • DV - Plays like Luke Shuey mixed with Michael Gardiner.

    Votes: 77 35.6%
  • Jack Watts is the one true king.

    Votes: 68 31.5%

  • Total voters
    216

Remove this Banner Ad

Youngest West Coast premiership player
Shane Bond (1994) - 19 years, 84 days
Mitchell White (1992) - 19 years, 182 days
Glen Jakovich (1992) - 19 years, 186 days
Daniel Venables (2018) - 19 years, 314 days
Ashley McIntosh (1992) - 19 years, 342 days


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Reminds us how special that 1992 team were and how only winning 2 flags in that period may be viewed as underachieving
 
May have been only 4 possessions but his intent on grand final day showed you he’s elite. He attacked contests like a veteran, did the small things right like tackling, chasing and pressuring. Immensely impressive and I think we’ve got something special here - may not be a top 5 AFL midfielder but he’s going to be a star for the eagles if we can retain him.

There was a contest I think were he won the hard ball, drew two players, took the tackle and released someone else for a I50 - got pretty excited by that.
Yup it was brilliant, it showed his strenghts in a very small package.
So clean and smart football thinking. He released it to Yeo. 7 showed a replay and i thought they were going to mention it and say what class it showed from the youngster. Alas no, they simply go on about how thats where maynard hurt his shoulder and miss the quality football.
If Dusty or a media darling did that play they would be jizzing and fawning for days
 

Log in to remove this ad.

DV is developing quite nicely imo, thought he was actually pretty effective on GF day. Not worried about his low disposal count just yet, but confident it'll come good next season, but he's proven that he can still offer pretty good service even with few disposals.
 
How's this looking now one amongst BOG in carving up Eagles other struggling at WAFL level .

For DVs sake I hope he makes a successful career in AFL , maybe as a Premiership player he already has.

Where do people see DV fitting into Eagles going forward , best position ?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
How's this looking now one amongst BOG in carving up Eagles other struggling at WAFL level .

For DVs sake I hope he makes a successful career in AFL , maybe as a Premiership player he already has.

Where do people see DV fitting into Eagles going forward , best position ?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

One played a crucial role in a premiership team and has a medal around his neck, while the other was dropped in a middling
ladder team at the same time. Things change quickly.

Congrats on the win yesterday and I personally love SPP as a player, but to gloat after a one off performance is a bit much.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

How's this looking now one amongst BOG in carving up Eagles other struggling at WAFL level .

For DVs sake I hope he makes a successful career in AFL , maybe as a Premiership player he already has.

Where do people see DV fitting into Eagles going forward , best position ?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Spp wouldnt fit at the eagles (usually) we are about precise kicking - the turnovers hed cause would break our system down
 
How's this looking now one amongst BOG in carving up Eagles other struggling at WAFL level .

For DVs sake I hope he makes a successful career in AFL , maybe as a Premiership player he already has.

Where do people see DV fitting into Eagles going forward , best position ?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I knew this thread would raise its head again. Power-Pepper did it all last night, and had a terrific game . DV has a bit to do here.
 
How's this looking now one amongst BOG in carving up Eagles other struggling at WAFL level .

For DVs sake I hope he makes a successful career in AFL , maybe as a Premiership player he already has.

Where do people see DV fitting into Eagles going forward , best position ?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
An absolutely shithouse kick, that wouldn't improve WC as a side.
 
I am and have been probably the biggest criticizer of Venables all the way through however the game last night was perfectly tailored to show off SPP's strengths and hide his weaknesses. If SPP played in the 80's he would be a superstar. Problem is i just don't see his kicking ever being quality.

(and yes i was an advocate of drafting him. well either him, drew or gallucci as i wasn't big on berry either i just thought he would be a middling at best inside mid so i obviously had s**t for brains that year with my drafting)

I'm pretty sure I actually wanted Drew and Rotham for our first two picks. (Well i really wanted Taranto and he just kept rising and rising and rising) In some ways I can see the venables choice as an easy one by WCE, Taranto and Venables played very similarly when on the park and Taranto jumped up the rankings with great performances while Venables continued to be injured and tease a similar level of ability. To me just doesn't have the game sense. Right attitude, right attributes, right size, doesn't have the game sense and it's very easy to see how that happens missing so much of the most important development years due to injury.
 
Back
Top