Opinion The "What's X/Y Player worth" thread

[Suma Magic]

Jarrod McVeigh? We're pretty charitable to deal with but I'm curious to see who would be interested and what they'd be prepared to trade.

I can't see anyone offering anything of value.

 

[Jeremias]

Jarrod McVeigh? We're pretty charitable to deal with but I'm curious to see who would be interested and what they'd be prepared to trade.

Hasn't there been some talk recently that he may do similar to what Sam Mitchell did at the end of last year?

From memory both Carlton and Essendon have been linked.

I can't see Sydney being too concerned about getting much in return for him. A late pick (or equivalent upgrade) would get it done.

 

[adammania9]

McVeigh is off to GWS from what I've heard, like a Stevie J type deal.

Pretty sure he's UFA though, so no trade required.

 

[JRyan23]

Aaron Hall?

 

[Darkyprotector]

This isn't about him leaving (Contracted till end of next year) but after his surprisingly good form up forward where do people see Tom McDonalds worth? Again I haven't heard anything (And wouldn't want to trade him either) but curious to see how he is rated outside our supporters.

hes now a geniune swing man Priceless
much better value than a intercept marker
at least a low first + player or 2 low firsts or high first high second
i feel his aboute to explode

 

[adammania9]

Aaron Hall?

Pick 20-30

 

[Bokonon_]

McVeigh is off to GWS from what I've heard, like a Stevie J type deal.

Pretty sure he's UFA though, so no trade required.

Cant see it. Stevie J filled a need for an experienced forward leader for the young guys. Anyone else would just be superfuous down back.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Pick 20-30

Aaron Hall an early to mid second? Snowflake's chance.

 

[jakefooty23]

(Out of Interest) Darcy Tucker, Matt Tabener, Luke Ryan

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

jack watts

 

[adammania9]

Aaron Hall an early to mid second? Snowflake's chance.

Have you watched Hall play before? Massive front runner.

 

[Snookers]

Cant see it. Stevie J filled a need for an experienced forward leader for the young guys. Anyone else would just be superfuous down back.

Don't be so surprised when it actually happens mate. Deal done.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Have you watched Hall play before? Massive front runner.

Exactly my point. He'd be lucky to get something inside 40 as a trade.

 

[adammania9]

Exactly my point. He'd be lucky to get something inside 40 as a trade.

Oh, well thank you. I thought I was being generous saying 20-30 but wasn't looking to bait anyone so went with that

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Oh, well thank you. I thought I was being generous saying 20-30 but wasn't looking to bait anyone so went with that

Guys who aren't 6'7" who can't hold down a regular spot in their team's starting 22, irrespective of how good the team is, should be going for anything inside 25 unless their name is Jed Anderson.

 

[schmuttt]

jack watts

15-25 imo. Would be good at the Tigers...

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

15-25 imo. Would be good at the Tigers...

Well we sure as * need someone to help jack

 

[Celli's2Belli's]

Have heard Todd Elton is interested in playing for Gold Coast. Would Elton for Hall be a decent trade?

 

[Drewie11]

Have heard Todd Elton is interested in playing for Gold Coast. Would Elton for Hall be a decent trade?

Elton would be interested in playing for anyone because he would probably be delisted at the end of the year wouldn't he?

 

[schmuttt]

Well we sure as **** need someone to help jack

You'd have to convince Watts to leave but I'd take the GWS 1st rounder you have assuming the Giants make the GF.

 

[Celli's2Belli's]

Elton would be interested in playing for anyone because he would probably be delisted at the end of the year wouldn't he?

Wouldnt have thought so with our lack of depth in KPF posts

 

[eth-dog]

Have heard Todd Elton is interested in playing for Gold Coast. Would Elton for Hall be a decent trade?

Would Cotchin for Keegan Brooksby be a decent trade?

 

[Celli's2Belli's]

Would Cotchin for Keegan Brooksby be a decent trade?

Who is Keegan Brooksby?

 

[Drewie11]

Wouldnt have thought so with our lack of depth in KPF posts

His contract runs out this year so you would have thought that Richmond would have thrown a bone by now.

 

[Celli's2Belli's]

His contract runs out this year so you would have thought that Richmond would have thrown a bone by now.

Potentially although could be waiting to see if Dusty signs and how much we have to pay for him