Opinion The "What's X/Y Player worth" thread

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Obeanie1

Brownlow Medallist
Jul 26, 2007
19,306
12,509
Darwin
AFL Club
West Coast
Hawks and Tigers both apparently interested in Mason Cox.

What's he worth in a trade?
Somewhere in the 2nd round, mid so 25 to 30.

Rucks seem to cost a bit more when it seems they arent worth it but then that's supply and demand. Go look on the fantasy sites at the lust of current AFL rucks. It doesn't take long before it reaches players with little experience.
 

Apex36

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 26, 2014
26,076
46,658
AFL Club
Collingwood
Witts was traded for picks 44 and 62, so you'd think similar. ~Pick 35 - 45 sounds about right.
Maybe, but at the same time Witts was never able to demonstrate an ability to take contested marks and kick goals either.

It's a difficult one, because both Witts and Nankervis went for cheaper last year than what would normally be paid for rucks who are still young and have demonstrated an ability to compete at the top level.
 

Suma Magic

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 22, 2009
21,587
22,372
AFL Club
West Coast
A crack at putting a number next to all the players rumoured to be leaving. I've tried to take into account whether they are contracted and other factors etc.

I've probably gone more for what someone would be willing to pay rather than what what a team would willingly take for them.

No doubt I've got them all wrong... lol

Definitely open to changing my opinion on any of them.

Gibbs - 10
Lever - 10 and 30
Gaff - 7
Balic - 55
Ah Chee (Port) - 60
Crozier - 50
Wilson - 20
Cameron - 20-25
Matera - 50
Goldstein - won't happen as no one wants his salary and North don't want a token pick for him
Impey - 40
Lamb - no value
Masten - 55
Schofield - 55
Watts - 35
Saad - 45
Stringer - 15
Smith - 20
Kennedy - 20
Miles - 50
Ablett - 35
Schache - 15
Taberner - 50
Hartung - 50
Fasolo - 40
 

Mitchell54

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 6, 2013
8,789
5,643
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Sixers, Exers, GWS Womens
A crack at putting a number next to all the players rumoured to be leaving. I've tried to take into account whether they are contracted and other factors etc.

I've probably gone more for what someone would be willing to pay rather than what what a team would willingly take for them.

No doubt I've got them all wrong... lol

Definitely open to changing my opinion on any of them.

Gibbs - 10
Lever - 10 and 30
Gaff - 7
Balic - 55
Ah Chee (Port) - 60
Crozier - 50
Wilson - 20
Cameron - 20-25
Matera - 50
Goldstein - won't happen as no one wants his salary and North don't want a token pick for him
Impey - 40
Lamb - no value
Masten - 55
Schofield - 55
Watts - 35
Saad - 45
Stringer - 15
Smith - 20
Kennedy - 20
Miles - 50
Ablett - 35
Schache - 15
Taberner - 50
Hartung - 50
Fasolo - 40
Think Watts would merit about 20-25. I'd be really comfortable & happy if Hawks got Watts for 32
 

Suma Magic

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 22, 2009
21,587
22,372
AFL Club
West Coast
Surely any pick after about 50 is essentially just getting a player to their chosen club?
Yeah probably. There is some value in the 50s - clubs would prefer to use their third rounder than their 4th as a live pick. I'd say no value in the 60s.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Pykie

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 17, 2006
14,786
26,860
Lord's
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Leeds United
A crack at putting a number next to all the players rumoured to be leaving. I've tried to take into account whether they are contracted and other factors etc.

I've probably gone more for what someone would be willing to pay rather than what what a team would willingly take for them.

No doubt I've got them all wrong... lol

Definitely open to changing my opinion on any of them.

Gibbs - 10
Lever - 10 and 30
Gaff - 7
Balic - 55
Ah Chee (Port) - 60
Crozier - 50
Wilson - 20
Cameron - 20-25
Matera - 50
Goldstein - won't happen as no one wants his salary and North don't want a token pick for him
Impey - 40
Lamb - no value
Masten - 55
Schofield - 55
Watts - 35
Saad - 45
Stringer - 15
Smith - 20
Kennedy - 20
Miles - 50
Ablett - 35
Schache - 15
Taberner - 50
Hartung - 50
Fasolo - 40
Saad is probably worth half of what you've got him for imo.
 

Scotland

Hall of Famer
May 5, 2006
49,586
51,253
AFL Club
West Coast
If we could get Saad for pick 45 I'd do it in a heartbeat. Bloke has genuine pace and isn't afraid to take the game on.

Four players had more than 50 bounces in 2017; Treloar (53), Heath Shaw (59) and Motlop (64) and Saad (93).

There players had more than 5 bounces in 2016; Motlop (51), Saad (55) and Heath Shaw (70). Saad played 10 games.
 

juss

Brownlow Medallist
Feb 23, 2009
16,465
20,160
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
New York Jets
Anthony Miles will request a trade, very good in the VFL and can slot straight into an AFL side as a reliable inside mid, wonder which clubs will be interested.
 

Wojcinski

If your dad has no beard, you've got two mums
Aug 14, 2011
10,811
14,609
AFL Club
Geelong
Anthony Miles will request a trade, very good in the VFL and can slot straight into an AFL side as a reliable inside mid, wonder which clubs will be interested.
I reckon Gold Coast could be his new home, they're screaming for mids
 

Wojcinski

If your dad has no beard, you've got two mums
Aug 14, 2011
10,811
14,609
AFL Club
Geelong
Played half a good season and ended with a bag kicked on him. I think he's worth about what Carlton paid for him in the first place, late second.
Agreed, but he has a lot of the Jason Mooney's about him. High value off the back of a decent half season but has been so flakey in the past I'd be very hesitant to give up much for him.
 

DustinsGuns

Premiership Player
Jun 30, 2012
3,566
6,699
AFL Club
Richmond
What's the consensus in the value of these Richmond players:
- Miles
- Bachelor
- Lloyd
- Lennon

Lloyd is the only one contracted. Would love to hold onto all 4 given we were kissed on the D with injuries all year and that's unlikely to happen next year.

3rd rounders for all? Miles and Lloyd would be very handy pickups for bottom 8 side and Batchelor is just far too good and VFL level.
 

philthy05

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 9, 2008
17,017
18,124
adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
adelaide 36ers
A crack at putting a number next to all the players rumoured to be leaving. I've tried to take into account whether they are contracted and other factors etc.

I've probably gone more for what someone would be willing to pay rather than what what a team would willingly take for them.

No doubt I've got them all wrong... lol

Definitely open to changing my opinion on any of them.

Gibbs - 10
Lever - 10 and 30
Gaff - 7
Balic - 55
Ah Chee (Port) - 60
Crozier - 50
Wilson - 20
Cameron - 20-25
Matera - 50
Goldstein - won't happen as no one wants his salary and North don't want a token pick for him
Impey - 40
Lamb - no value
Masten - 55
Schofield - 55
Watts - 35
Saad - 45
Stringer - 15
Smith - 20
Kennedy - 20
Miles - 50
Ablett - 35
Schache - 15
Taberner - 50
Hartung - 50
Fasolo - 40

Port would ask for west coasts pick 48 for ah chee. If west coast had that pick tied up elsewhere and honestly could not do anything about that and ah chee asked to go we would likely just send him off for a nothing pick but our ask would be that pick 48 and I think west Coast would do it straight off the bat.

Impey is contracted and teams are circling him as opposed to port looking to offload him. Pick 40 would be the extreme extreme low end of his value. I think hawthorns pick 32, Geelong pick 33 or dogs picks 26 (or 28 if they get that in from dons) are going to be what's on the table for impey from day one. Don't see Port even returning phone calls for any less.
 
Top Bottom