Opinion The "What's X/Y Player worth" thread

[pantskyle]

Andrew Gaff?

A lot.

 

[King_Steele]

What do you think Sam Mayes is worth? Coming OOC this year and not always in the seniors

Pick 20-30 at this stage.

I rate Mayes as more of a 15-20 pick.

 

[Drewie11]

What do you think Sam Mayes is worth? Coming OOC this year and not always in the seniors

I was thinking the same. He might only be worth a late second round pick or early third??

 

[eth-dog]

What is Jake Stringer worth? I heard someone on the main board saying he is worth draft picks 1, 2 and 3. Combined. LOL.

Incorrect. Said I'd be willing to give up 1/2/3 for him, not all three you *.

 

[TheHairyGamer]

Pick 20-30 at this stage.

I rate Mayes as more of a 15-20 pick.

I would almost take that at this point if he can't get a regular spot

 

[Dogsman16]

Daniel McStay (20 - 25)??

 

[chaelsonnen]

Incorrect. Said I'd be willing to give up 1/2/3 for him, not all three you ******.

Oh it was you. Awkward.

 

[eth-dog]

Oh it was you. Awkward.

By the fact that you fail a comprehension test?

 

[chaelsonnen]

By the fact that you fail a comprehension test?

You should have added in 'either', before you listed the numbers.

 

[eth-dog]

You should have added in 'either', before you listed the numbers.

The "/" have always meant "or", not "and".

 

[chaelsonnen]

The "/" have always meant "or", not "and".

Still having an 'either' before the numbers would have made sense.
...And no, it does not 'always' mean 'or'. A Grade 5 'and' 6 class in school is written like this: 5/6.

 

[TheHairyGamer]

Daniel McStay (20 - 25)??

Not sure about that one... young tall who can play at either end... maybe a 15 - 20 but don't see us giving him up any time soon

 

[JasRulz63]

Daniel McStay (20 - 25)??

Given he's contracted, I don't see us giving him up for a second rounder. Another case of being worth more to his current club than he would be to others.

 

[Dogsman16]

Given he's contracted, I don't see us giving him up for a second rounder. Another case of being worth more to his current club than he would be to others.

I'd be willing to overpay for him, really do think he will be a good player. I'd probably add a player to that.

As you said though his worth is probably more to the lions than what teams would offer.

 

[dewah07]

tom hickey
eli templeton

 

[Dr Whoooooooo]

Jack Watts?
Tom McDonald ?

 

[eth-dog]

Jack Watts?
Tom McDonald ?

Watts around the pick 20 mark. McDonald a top 5 pick.

 

[Dr Whoooooooo]

What about

Jack Grimes
Jack Trengrove

 

[blueiris]

Jack Watts?
Tom McDonald ?

Watts is a free agent so it will depend on what a team is willing to pay 2nd round pick for Melbourne would be my guess can't see anyone offering anymore than $500'000
Tom MacDonald would get Melbourne a pick between 15-25

 

[Dr Whoooooooo]

Watts is a free agent so it will depend on what a team is willing to pay 2nd round pick for Melbourne would be my guess can't see anyone offering anymore than $500'000
Tom MacDonald would get Melbourne a pick between 15-25

Yeah but he is a restricted free agent ala Dangerfield, dont think Dees would let him walk for a second rounder. Roos has a very high opinion of him.

 

[blueiris]

Yeah but he is a restricted free agent ala Dangerfield, dont think Dees would let him walk for a second rounder. Roos has a very high opinion of him.

Roos won't be at the club next year though yeah they may match the bid can't see anyone give more than a second round pick for Watts though meaning he'll stay at Melbourne

 

[Dr Whoooooooo]

Roos won't be at the club next year though yeah they may match the bid can't see anyone give more than a second round pick for Watts though meaning he'll stay at Melbourne

I appreciate he wont be there in an official capacity, but Roos and Choco Williams wrote the book on wheeling and dealing at trade time, I have a feeling he loves that side of the business and he may stay distantly involved as an "advisor - mentor" ... think he will try to help try and finish what he started.

On Watts - awesome club person, loved by the players .... but has been much maligned by many fans at the Demons who have even aired their grievances at games. I also think Jack will look past that & stay a Demon. But its interesting to get a general opinion on what he is worth.

Cheers

 

[Pykie]

Our biggest need is a KPF. Wood is that. I wouldn't want to trade it straight up but if we can get a downgrade on it we can get the player we need whilst not giving up a top 40 pick.

He wont be traded, I wouldn't be surprised to see him play the next 10-15 games.

He's a jet, he's capable of 15-20p/2 goals a game imo.

 

[eth-dog]

He wont be traded, I wouldn't be surprised to see him play the next 10-15 games.

He's a jet, he's capable of 15-20p/2 goals a game imo.

You might not have a say in the matter. He's out of contract, plays AFL every second week and could get a better deal elsewhere.

 

[eth-dog]

Tom Campbell's worth Dogs fans?