The 'Who to play' Thread

[Judd_Magic]

hmm got one Grimes vs Richmond or Broughton vs the mighty doggies?

I'd go Broughton purely cause he hasn't put a foot wrong even against the good teams and isn't injury prone either.



I have one myself -

Backs - Goddard, Fisher, Newman, Gilbee, Cornes, Grimes, Broughton

(Grima, Rance)


Who do I start out of Grima and Cornes? Seriously thinking of putting the Chad on the bench.

 

[Bloods]

Go with Chad, Judd_Magic.

Need to bench two of Mackie, Broughton, Grimes and Grima??

 

[munk3ymark]

The backline seems to be causing a few folks trouble, me included.
I've got all 9 of my guys playing. As it stands from last week:
Goddard, Newman, Lake, Fisher, Broughton, Suban, Ellis (Grimes, Pratt)

I'm leaning towards benching Suban & Ellis, but Suban has had a couple of good weeks- can he keep it up? You'd think he'll have a fair bit to do against the Doggies, as will Broughton. Ellis has been pretty up and down, and Port over there can be tricky. Grimes is becoming a walk-up start, but Pratt has also been somewhat mercurial of late (but it is going to be a big game for the Roos farewelling Simpson). Carlton will want to avenge last week's loss though. Argh!

Help! Please!

 

[PowerOfThePussy]

Backline dilemna for me also.

Grima or Houlihan for the 7th spot. At the moment I have Grima in there as Houlihan doesn't exact fill me with confidence, but am still a bit undecided.

 

[RevDog]

I'd almost be picking Grima myself. I am down to Cornes vs. Grimes, ideas?

 

[PowerOfThePussy]

I'd almost be picking Grima myself. I am down to Cornes vs. Grimes, ideas?

Tough one also. I usually always take the more established player in these type of scenarios, but form must be considered as well. Grimes has been excellent, whereas Cornes has been only so so. I would probably lean towards Cornes, but Grimes formwise has definitely been better.

Good luck.

P.S. I've gone with Grima. Will know if I made the right choice in a couple of hours. Goes against my rules, but I am hoping that Grima fires up after his week off.

And Houlihan is a girl in a male body.

 

[Dirtywhirl]

Grima or Cheney

 

[Pedsy]

I have a tricky decision to make in my midfield which could shape my finals campaign.

I need to play 2 out of Rich, Hasleby and Anthony.

Rich I'm a bit worried about as his numbers at the MCG aren't great. Playing Essendon, not sure if they have anyone that will run with him.

Hasleby is playing Port and I'm assuming will get a Chornes tag which could mean another low scoring game from him. He got 52 against them earlier in the year.

Anthony seems to be going along great. Playing Melbourne so should do well.

So I'm leaning towards Rich and Anthony atm. Any advice?

 

[alternatevista]

Definitely Anothony, close between Rich / Hasleby. Both equally capable of scoring 50-odd but Rich is more likely to score 100+

 

[reddahaydn1]

same old rich v anthony debarcle...i'm leaning towards anthony, think he'll kill it agaisnt melb.....
rich is only playing bombers tho...could go either way...my opposition has them both on the field so at least i'm one up, but picking the wrong one could hurt!

 

[Spudwick]

Ok midfield dilemma.
my mid consists of
GAJ, Goodes, Judd, Cooney, Sewell, Pendlebury, Shane tuck, muston.

Trying to decide who to bench with Muston.
Any help? I'm actually thinking of benching Judd v cats

 

[Headless]

Uhh.. Shane Tuck, buddy.

 

[Derogue]

With cross out injured, i have muston and robinson as my bench players.

So which one should i play? (thats if robinsonn gets in the final 22).

 

[30RYDER]

Who can help with this one?...
Should I play
Mitchell Brown (playing North at home)
or
Houlihan (playing port away)

 

[Dalzielling]

Rosa vs Anthony - both teams playing each other! Thoughts?

 

[M_I_G]

houla is interesting, we havnt been using him as a fwd really so not sure if he is scoring well, used to have him but traded him out
anthony always seems to rack up at least a 70, no idea bout rosa tho.
debating who to start on - dawson or grima ?

 

[Judd_Magic]

h
debating who to start on - dawson or grima ?

Grima easily.

 

[Judd_Magic]

With cross out injured, i have muston and robinson as my bench players.

So which one should i play? (thats if robinsonn gets in the final 22).

Muston as he has more upside and is named on the half back line where as Robinson has to kick goals to score well at half forward.

 

[RevDog]

Muston vs. Anthony vs. Hasleby, which one?

 

[Cool Cat]

Muston vs. Anthony vs. Hasleby, which one?

tough, but haselby if you wanna go safe or otherwise anthony.

mine is krakoeur vs mitchell brown. leaning towards the former but would appreciate any opinions

 

[Hawkmad]

From last weeks mess where I had 3 dounuts & no bench players playing in my team and now this week I have that many to pick from I don't know who to play and who to bench.

Backline who do i bench -

Goddard , Hurn , Lockyer , Hodge , Broughton , Drummond , Cheeney , Gilbert & Greenwood.

I'm thinking Cheney & Greenwood but interested in your opinion.

 

[sebsport3]

Who can help with this one?...
Should I play
Mitchell Brown (playing North at home)
or
Houlihan (playing port away)

Tough call. Id say Brown based on the past couple of weeks.

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

From last weeks mess where I had 3 dounuts & no bench players playing in my team and now this week I have that many to pick from I don't know who to play and who to bench.

Backline who do i bench -

Goddard , Hurn , Lockyer , Hodge , Broughton , Drummond , Cheeney , Gilbert & Greenwood.

I'm thinking Cheney & Greenwood but interested in your opinion.

Yep, I'd go with Cheney and Greenwood.

 

[Cool Cat]

I'm thinking Cheney & Greenwood but interested in your opinion.[/quote]


Yeah, that's what I'd do. Any thoughts on my krakouer vs brown dilemma?

 

[roodav]

Muston vs Swfit for cover for Cross? Through to prelim's in all my leagues so no fixtures this week but would like a decent score