Thompson or Waters

[Eggzoi]

I'd much rather the Crows did those as 2 seperate deals. I think the Crows would be better off making seperate trades than a straight Stinger for Thompson deal.

 

[Stiffy_18]

I think that deal is just a speculation. Adelaide have said a number of times that we are keeping the 2 deals separate. I highly doubt that Stenglein trade will involve Thompson.

 

[mymansyd]

I think that deal is just a speculation. Adelaide have said a number of times that we are keeping the 2 deals separate. I highly doubt that Stenglein trade will involve Thompson.

I hope you're right. I'd love to know where SEN got their story from, if in fact that was a story.

 

[Carn the Coasters]

How about this:

WEST COAST
Gain: Stenglein
Lose: pick 12 and Chambers

ADELAIDE
Gain: Thompson and pick 29
Lose: Stenglein

MELBOURNE
Gain: pick 12 and Chambers
Lose: Thompson and pick 29

 

[Stiffy_18]

How about this:

WEST COAST
Gain: Stenglein
Lose: pick 12 and Chambers

ADELAIDE
Gain: Thompson and pick 29
Lose: Stenglein

MELBOURNE
Gain: pick 12 and Chambers
Lose: Thompson and pick 29

For the hundredth time Adelaide wants to keep the Stenglein and Thompson trade separate and is highly unlikely that they will entertain the idea of getting the 2 deals mixed up.

 

[Mong]

WEST COAST
Gain: Stenglein
Lose: pick 12 and Chambers

Interesting.

When Stenglein first announced he was heading West the general consensus from Eagles fans was that Stenglein was worth a second round pick.

Funny how things have changed.


****

 

[Portia]

I reckon its pretty astounding how much you guys have talked them up to. Unless this draft is really weak, I'd say its definitely over the odds.

We can't even get Freo to think about putting together a proposal.

 

[Jars458]

I reckon its pretty astounding how much you guys have talked them up to. Unless this draft is really weak, I'd say its definitely over the odds.

We can't even get Freo to think about putting together a proposal.

Its very early days yet. I can see no deals being done until Friday afternoon again.

Freo must see taht they will have to give something decent to get Carr. Surely??

 

[Stiffy_18]

Its very early days yet. I can see no deals being done until Friday afternoon again.

Freo must see taht they will have to give something decent to get Carr. Surely??

One has already been done.

Nathan Thompson to Kangaroos
Picks 10 and 26 to Hawks.

Official. Announced by Dermie on SEN just then

 

[Mong]

Nathan Thompson to Kangaroos
Picks 10 and 26 to Hawks.

Official.

Good news for us because the Eagles were keen on Nathan Thompson.

To quote Worsfold re Nathan Thompson:

"We'd like to get him, but it's hard to say whether we will or not," Worsfold said.

"(We'll do) whatever it takes, but obviously with our first-round draft pick, which is up for offer, we're keen to deal with Adelaide, with Tyson Stenglein.

"A first-round pick is not enough for Adelaide, so we've got to come up with a fair bit better than that, (so it will be) another player or another pick. We don't want to miss out on both."

****

 

[snakebite01]

Good news for us because the Eagles were keen on Nathan Thompson.

To quote Worsfold re Nathan Thompson:



****

That's what I was thinkning ****.

Stenglein's value for WC has just risen thanks to the Kangas.

 

[theorangeapple]

That's what I was thinkning ****.

Stenglein's value for WC has just risen thanks to the Kangas.

we have chosen to get stenglein ahead of thompson. ironically for the same price as the roos paid. the stenglein deal is done in principle. that is why the hawks did the deed with the roos.

 

[snakebite01]

we have chosen to get stenglein ahead of thompson. ironically for the same price as the roos paid. the stenglein deal is done in principle. that is why the hawks did the deed with the roos.

You may be right, but I'll believe it when I see it. No confirmation yet, so AFAIAC no deal has been finalised yet. Therefore, it is open for more negotiation.