List Mgmt. Tim Kelly remains a Cat for 2019

How long will Tim Kelly last at Geelong?

  • He will return to WA in the 2018 trade period

  • He will play at Geelong in 2019 but return to WA at end 2019

  • He will sign a long term deal at Geelong


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
An all time classic to ruin a young mans career ? A young man who has 3 little children and no support base on the other side of the country ? Can not believe that your board can not see how bad the geelong club looks in the eyes of the rest of the comp. Very classy stuff.
One of the funniest parts of the failed WCE trade period has been all the WCE supporters who all of a sudden give a s**t about some random bloke's well-being who is playing for the Geelong Football Club. Spare us the crap about 'ruining a young man's career', if your team didn't stand to gain any benefit in this scenario you wouldn't give it a second thought.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

An all time classic to ruin a young mans career ? A young man who has 3 little children and no support base on the other side of the country ? Can not believe that your board can not see how bad the geelong club looks in the eyes of the rest of the comp. Very classy stuff.

You are all kinds of dumb.

He could have gone to Freo, but didn't. So the family thing really wasn't ringing true.

I guess, looking at it another way, given both WA clubs have overlooked him in 5 previous drafts, even again in the sixth draft when WCE had two picks before the Cats draft pick, but you went with Brander and Allan. So all up, over the 6 drafts that you could have saved this poor family, which totalled 30 odd picks in both the ND and rookie drafts; but you chose not to.

Double those picks to include Freo. So that's 60-65 picks that both WA clubs have 'ruined' this man's career and family life by not picking him up.

See how stupid your view is knowing the above?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
One of the funniest parts of the failed WCE trade period has been all the WCE supporters who all of a sudden give a s**t about some random bloke's well-being who is playing for the Geelong Football Club. Spare us the crap about 'ruining a young man's career', if your team didn't stand to gain any benefit in this scenario you wouldn't give it a second thought.

Funny about us ruining his career LMAO.

These clowns had 5 years to give him a career and 5 times in a row they refused to.

Then when he gets one, they want it to be with them so they build him up all year that he's important to them and they'll take care of him, only to leave him and his family in the lurch bereft of the commitment to follow through to get him home LOL.

SO he has a career with us. Plays the best footy he can with us and makes more in 1 year than he did in the last 5.

And we're not classy. o_O:rolleyes:

Go Catters
 
An all time classic to ruin a young mans career ? A young man who has 3 little children and no support base on the other side of the country ? Can not believe that your board can not see how bad the geelong club looks in the eyes of the rest of the comp. Very classy stuff.
Nah. Everyone else bar most WC fans are proud of Geelong.
If he was willing to go to Freo and we said No, different story.
People aren't stupid. (Except for you).
 
Funny about us ruining his career LMAO.

These clowns had 5 years to give him a career and 5 times in a row they refused to.

Then when he gets one, they want it to be with them so they build him up all year that he's important to them and they'll take care of him, only to leave him and his family in the lurch bereft of the commitment to follow through to get him home LOL.

SO he has a career with us. Plays the best footy he can with us and makes more in 1 year than he did in the last 5.

And we're not classy. o_O:rolleyes:

Go Catters
The generous West Coast are willing to 'save' young Tim's career only now once they realise he is actually a gun footballer. The five years prior they couldn't give a care in the world about him or his family's well-being. Yet even now they are only willing to 'save' him by offering up a bunch of second round draft picks. :D:D
 
Funny about us ruining his career LMAO.

These clowns had 5 years to give him a career and 5 times in a row they refused to.

Then when he gets one, they want it to be with them so they build him up all year that he's important to them and they'll take care of him, only to leave him and his family in the lurch bereft of the commitment to follow through to get him home LOL.

SO he has a career with us. Plays the best footy he can with us and makes more in 1 year than he did in the last 5.

And we're not classy. o_O:rolleyes:

Go Catters
Yep, their previously invisible compassion is now boundless isn’t it? Good on em.
 
An all time classic to ruin a young mans career ? A young man who has 3 little children and no support base on the other side of the country ? Can not believe that your board can not see how bad the geelong club looks in the eyes of the rest of the comp. Very classy stuff.

Funny how numerous posters from other clubs have applauded the way be held firm on getting a fair value, and that we were right to do it cause of tim refusing to go to freo, who had better offers.

But go ahead, live in your little fantasy world.

WC screwed tim over again.
 
You are all kinds of dumb.

He could have gone to Freo, but didn't. So the family thing really wasn't ringing true.

I guess, looking at it another way, given both WA clubs have overlooked him in 5 previous drafts, even again in the sixth draft when WCE had two picks before the Cats draft pick, but you went with Brander and Allan. So all up, over the 6 drafts that you could have saved this poor family, which totalled 30 odd picks in both the ND and rookie drafts; but you chose not to.

Double those picks to include Freo. So that's 60-65 picks that both WA clubs have 'ruined' this man's career and family life by not picking him up.

See how stupid your view is knowing the above?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Pathetic and incorrect. Not going to bother discussing with any of you. You all see it one way and make up arguments to convince yourselves of your righteousness. After reading your board, the threats to the Kelly's etc, can only conclude you are the worst supporters in the country.
 
I see that mods on the Eagles board have even resorted to editing posts from Geelong posters in their Tim Kelly salt farms over on their board. Jeff76 can attest to that.

Are there notifications or alerts if a mod edits a post you have made?
 
Pathetic and incorrect. Not going to bother discussing with any of you. You all see it one way and make up arguments to convince yourselves of your righteousness. After reading your board, the threats to the Kelly's etc, can only conclude you are the worst supporters in the country.

ok then.. dont let the door leave an untimely imprint on your posterior as you exit stage left. And there's a box of tissues right by it to wipe them salty tears off as you leave as im sure you can't see thru them to well.

GO Catters
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Nah. Everyone else bar most WC fans are proud of Geelong.
If he was willing to go to Freo and we said No, different story.
People aren't stupid. (Except for you).
Just about everyone who was traded got to the club of their choice. The only one who didn't was Kelly. What's that about stupid ?
 
Pathetic and incorrect. Not going to bother discussing with any of you. You all see it one way and make up arguments to convince yourselves of your righteousness. After reading your board, the threats to the Kelly's etc, can only conclude you are the worst supporters in the country.
BOOOOOOOOOO
 
Are there notifications or alerts if a mod edits a post you have made?
yes... you should receive an alert that suggests exactly that...

Go Catters
 
ok then.. dont let the door leave an untimely imprint on your posterior as you exit stage left. And there's a box of tissues right by it to wipe them salty tears off as you leave as im sure you can't see thru them to well.

GO Catters
Cheers, cya next year. sniff sniff :'(
 
Just about everyone who was traded got to the club of their choice. The only one who didn't was Kelly. What's that about stupid ?
You didnt meet the contracted clubs fair valuation. Of course it didnt happen. You can't be that thick.

Go Catters
 
Unless you're a relative or have an autistic kid within your own family you wouldn't know the first thing about how they cope. My brother and sister in law have two autistic and 2 young kids and they cope just fine even without family input they'd have no problems coping so don't give us this sh!t that the Kelly's struggle because if that was the real case and they were desperate to get home then they wouldn't have ruled out Freo, but of course you cretins can't see that.

This is a really important post. It's a child with autism, not the end of the world by any means. I wonder how many are "pitying" the Kelly family situation through their own ableism and prejudges against people with autism?

That would be Kelly sacking him wouldn't it? The client walking away. You can hardly call Wells professional; sitting at the trade table pretending to do a deal when there was never any intention of doing said deal. I don't see WCE operating like that at trade time. When a player wants to go home, that trade generally gets done.

You really don't know the first thing about Wells, do you?

It has to be a very good contract. west coast gain 1.5 mil in cap space in 2020 with kennedy and nic nat technically veterans under the salary cap. Ithink we were always gonna wait as why pay two round first draft pick for someone we can get for free next year. Geelong wouldnt get compo either as he wouldnt be technically a free agent, just has to go through the draft

Just for anyone curious this is not true, the veterans allowance has been gone for a few years now. West Coast supporters seem to have a really misinformed grasp of the rules...
 
This is a really important post. It's a child with autism, not the end of the world by any means. I wonder how many are "pitying" the Kelly family situation through their own ableism and prejudges against people with autism?



You really don't know the first thing about Wells, do you?



Just for anyone curious this is not true, the veterans allowance has been gone for a few years now. West Coast supporters seem to have a really misinformed grasp of the rules...

Running theme.. their supporters dont know s**t and TK's manager... also a WC supporter, clearly does not know s**t. There is a pattern here.

GO Catters
 
You didnt meet the contracted clubs fair valuation. Of course it didnt happen. You can't be that thick.

Go Catters
Fair Valuation ? you wanted 3 first round draft picks . Anyway it doesn't matter, he is a geelong player for 2019 and I hope he has another good year . Moving on.
 
Fair Valuation ? you wanted 3 first round draft picks . Anyway it doesn't matter, he is a geelong player for 2019 and I hope he has another good year . Moving on.

Mmmmmmmmm salt.
I like these super salty, ignorant eagles posters.
You say moving on, but here you are, on an opposition board, continuing to post salty, ignorant and downright stupid garbage.
I think you need to move on, champ.
 
Pathetic and incorrect. Not going to bother discussing with any of you. You all see it one way and make up arguments to convince yourselves of your righteousness. After reading your board, the threats to the Kelly's etc, can only conclude you are the worst supporters in the country.
The threats to the Kelly’s Lol you’re pathetic. Go cry elsewhere
 
Fair Valuation ? you wanted 3 first round draft picks . Anyway it doesn't matter, he is a geelong player for 2019 and I hope he has another good year . Moving on.
Top 10 pick. How many times does it need to be repeated?

The fact that Wells at the last minute was willing to accept unders at 20+22+2018 1st was ridiculously generous on his part.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top