Maybe. im just factoring in the current circumstances and that its likely to be a last minute deal. I think with what we were staring at last Thursday, Polec and second rounder will look pretty good.
There just wont be the time to haggle and wait out another party.
What good would a 2nd rounder be to us? If we receive Polec in the trade, then we'll only have 1 list vacancy remaining.
Tippett + 20 <--> Polec + 8
elevates our position in the draft (for our only "live" pick) from 20 to 8 - a good outcome. This trade is inherently biased in Brisbane's favour, but we can live with it as with pick #8 in our pocket #20 becomes surplus to requirements.
Tippet + 20 <--> Polec + 28 (?)
drops us several positions in the draft and effectively rates Polec > Tippett, which is blatantly untrue. Seriously bad trade - albeit still better than what Sydney are apparently offering.