Tippett's Gone - READ RULES BEFORE POSTING

[Onetonylockett]

d

How about white + syd 2nd round to bris

Polec + sydney 1st round to crows

Tippett to Sydney

dunno if the lions would be happy with that

 

[TheLeftFist8]

what about this? bent I know but....
Tippett, 20 to Sydney
White, Parker, 23 to Adelaide

Why should we swap 20 & 23?

 

[Tex Support]

How about white + syd 2nd round to bris

Polec + sydney 1st round to crows

Tippett to Sydney

More like...
Tippett to Sydney
Pick 23, White to Brisbane
Polec to Adelaide.

Would Brisbane do that? Maybe slide them an Adelaide pick as well?

 

[latinoheat]

So what your saying is Brisbane is going to give up Polec who was drafted at number 5 two years ago for the spud White and pick 40 something. Not gonna happen

If they have a need for white then yes why not? Polec may be out of favour .... Don't think he got much of a run last year.

 

[crow4life]

Would need Crazy Vossy to be at his Crazy best for that one. Brisbane absolutley reamed!
Better chance of
Adelaide - Polec
Sydney - Tippett
Brisbane - White, 23, 45

Better deal for Brisbane

 

[Vader]

I can guess what the CEO intervention was.. "Noble.. either you or White will be employed by the AFC on Monday, but not both. Your choice!"

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Haven't we learnt not to take Rucci as Gospel

Didn't Noble say that this could go to Friday and we were exploring to bring in third parties

Let's all hold fire for now

 

[nightchook]

Why should we swap 20 & 23?

Because it's a useless baseless gesture.... Seems Sydney are used to those so it made sense ;-)

 

[crow4life]

If they have a need for white then yes why not? Polec may be out of favour .... Don't think he got much of a run last year.

Polec is class. You dont give away class for a pick in the forties and a hack

 

[Danoz]

So what your saying is Brisbane is going to give up Polec who was drafted at number 5 two years ago for the spud White and pick 40 something. Not gonna happen

We can BF this trade up a bit though.

Bris gain: White, 20 (Adel), 23 (Syd) lose: Polec, 8 (Bris)
Adel gain: Polec, 8 (Bris) lose: Tippett, 20 (Adel)
Syd gain: Tippett lose: White, 23 (Syd)

 

[JasRulz63]

If they have a need for white then yes why not? Polec may be out of favour .... Don't think he got much of a run last year.

Mainly due to injury.

We're not trading away a contracted pick 5 for pick 40-ish plus White.

 

[AndrewJo]

​

I still cannot understand why we would have ANY interest in White

Am I missing something? At the moment we have 2 picks that we use in the ND. 19 and 54. If we take 23 plus a player we effectively rule out pick 54 but then have only one pick even though we have picks 19 and 23. This means we have to negotiate with a club and trade all our picks for ONE lower pick. Smells of further delistings......I would have hoped that the white 23 deal has stalled because the Adelaide FC would be going backwards in that deal.better to reject that deal, send Kurt to the Psd and at least get 2 picks in the ND in the hope that we unearth a good player.

 

[TheRoo32]

Better deal for Brisbane

Exactly. Brisbane could be tempted into taking it. They get White (who they apparently want) A first rounder and a second rounder.

 

[TheRoo32]

Mainly due to injury.

We're not trading away a contracted pick 5 for pick 40-ish plus White.

What about White, 23 and 45?

 

[Vader]

what about this? bent I know but....
Tippett, 20 to Sydney
White, Parker, 23 to Adelaide

A - the deal is infinitely better without White
B - Sydney have repeatedly said that they won't be trading Parker
C - the deal leaves us with no list vacancies at all; we need one "live" selection to satisfy the AFL's mandatory minimum of 3 selections; so we'd have to delist another player.

So.. no, no and no.

 

[crow4life]

More like...
Tippett to Sydney
Pick 23, White to Brisbane
Polec to Adelaide.

Would Brisbane do that? Maybe slide them an Adelaide pick as well?

This would be a good outcome from this mess

 

[jenny61_99]

"We haven't killed it" does not = "We still absolutely want him and are just waiting for some extra supplies in lube to get the job done". Have we learned NOTHING from the last two weeks? It may well have been a quote from Trigg, but it may have referred to any number of questions from Rooch. He doesn't seem to think its a problem for taking quotes often out of context.

 

[JasRulz63]

What about White, 23 and 45?

Would you rather White, 23 and 45 or Polec in return for Tippett?

 

[TheRoo32]

We can BF this trade up a bit though.

Bris gain: White, 20 (Adel), 23 (Syd) lose: Polec, 8 (Bris)
Adel gain: Polec, 8 (Bris) lose: Tippett, 20 (Adel)
Syd gain: Tippett lose: White, 23 (Syd)

Absolutley no chance mate.
As I said earlier best chance really is

Adel: Polec
Syd: Tippett
Bris: White, 23, 45

Even that is very unlikely. 0 chance of Polec and 8!

 

[TheRoo32]

Would you rather White, 23 and 45 or Polec in return for Tippett?

Polec. Its just apparently you guys are interested in White. Also if he is showing signs of homesickness it may work.

 

[Hodgy]

Polec is class. You dont give away class for a pick in the forties and a hack

That's true but it does make some sense. Brisbane were so desparate for a forward this year that they played Merrett up forward with Brown and they know that Brown is close to the end and has injury problems. If you couple this with Polec telling them that he would like to return home and he coming out of contract next year and White wanting to leave Sydney now Tippett is there... Some guess work I know but a definate possibility.

 

[Iva Bigun]

Looking in to the near future from the Crows Boardroom

 

[johnnypanther]

are the steak knives still on the table as a legitimate sweetner?

No - Rucci and most of the scribes seem to be treating the steak knives (White) as the integral part of the deal

 

[Danoz]

Absolutley no chance mate.
As I said earlier best chance really is

Adel: Polec
Syd: Tippett
Bris: White, 23, 45

Even that is very unlikely. 0 chance of Polec and 8!

WHY WON'T YOU JUST LET ME DREAM!!!!! jokes

 

[Danoz]

No - Rucci and most of the scribes seem to be treating the steak knives (White) as the integral part of the deal

Without steak knives, there would be no deal