TJ1996's 2012 Mock Draft

[TJ1996]

TJ1996's 2012 Mock Draft​

​

 

[saintsrfreak]

Simpson and Shaw at 46 and 48?

 

[TJ1996]

Simpson and Shaw at 46 and 48?

I'm not Simpson's biggest fan. There is a lot of upside, but there is also a lot of downside. Shaw is another one who just doesn't do it for me. I could (and probably will) be proven wrong.

 

[recon]

I would cry if Menzel is available and we take Liam Mc Bean.

 

[TJ1996]

I would cry if Menzel is available and we take Liam Mc Bean.

All suggestions being taken into account. I can't remember putting Menzel that low

 

[dajesmac]

A good draft there for WCE, would've preferred Nelson @ 62 but still I'd be happy with that.​

 

[dajesmac]

FWIW Marschall isn't nominating for the draft.

Unless things have changed...

 

[TJ1996]

FWIW Marschall isn't nominating for the draft.

Unless things have changed...

Cheers for that, I'll have to take him out

 

[Zach Package]

colquoun at 7 seems alot high (i personally see him going in the late 20's onwards, but otherwise I like it from an essendon perspective.

A big bodied, plug and play midfielder, and a classy outside ball user.
Replace Bailey with Nic Graham and you'd have me doing cartwheels to be honest

 

[TJ1996]

colquoun at 7 seems alot high (i personally see him going in the late 20's onwards, but otherwise I like it from an essendon perspective.

A big bodied, plug and play midfielder, and a classy outside ball user.
Replace Bailey with Nic Graham and you'd have me doing cartwheels to be honest

I dunno, I just really like Sam Colquhoun as a player and as a name tbh

 

[Sin City]

I dunno, I just really like Sam Colquhoun as a player and as a name tbh

I thought it was alright, I have him at ten on my list

 

[HARKER]

I thought it was alright, I have him at ten on my list

Out: Daniher
In: Culquhoun

Tippett looks about right at #14.........even then.

 

[Sin City]

Out: Daniher
In: Culquhoun

Just my personal list, not phantom draft.

 

[HARKER]

Just my personal list, not phantom draft.

I KNOW...............................

Irrespective of which name falls to Carlton at #11, it just seems to look good.................except Jaksch for me.

 

[TJ1996]

Irrespective of which name falls to Carlton at #11, it just seems to look good.................except Jaksch for me.

So you think that Jaksch is too high?

 

[Silvagnis]

Why would Carlton take another ruckman at 36?

We will need to get a hard mid if we go tall with pick 11.

 

[year of the roo]

Dean Towers?

 

[the distributer]

McBean looks like a player from his highlights package, looks to have a lot of upside.

 

[Sin City]

McBean looks like a player from his highlights package, looks to have a lot of upside.

He's got some nice moves for big guy but he'll take time. Needs to get more involved in the game and get his hands dirty a bit more.

 

[muttonchops]

FWIW Geelong are only using 3 picks and one is already designated for Jesse Stringer, so live picks are 16 and 79.

 

[TJ1996]

Alright thanks muttonchops I'll get the order finalised when I can, this is just to get some names out there.

Robinson Kreuzer Changed. Dean Towers in for Symonds who has moved down the order to Carlton's last pick

year of the roo Towers in @ Pick 36

 

[missionpossible]

Brad Symes to Port at 85, you do have a wicked sense of humour

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

god i hope your draft comes true for WCE would be amazing.

 

[theGav56]

Moller for Freo is being taken as a Rookie not in the draft.

Would be disappointed if our draft did not have a strong focus on KPPs.

 

[CallumBartlett]

G'day, just some personal opinions. First mock draft and going on best available for now, positional needs etc., will come in when I have some spare time but this is just to get some names out there. Description + player info to come. I am in no way an expert on these players, this list is just from what I have seen and heard + seen on bigfooty.

1. GWS - Lachie Whitfield
2. GWS - Jimmy Toumpas
3. GWS - Brodie Grundy
4. Melb - Oliver Wines
5. WB - Jake Stringer
6. WB - Jonathon O'Rourke
7. Port - Sam Colquhoun
8. Bris - Dayle Garlett
9. Rich - Jackson Macrae
10. Ess - Joe Daniher (F/S)
11. Carl - Lachie Plowman
12. GWS - Sam Mayes
13. GC - Tim Membrey
14. GWS - Kurt Tippett
15. NM - Kristian Jaksch
16. Geel - Ben Kennedy
17. Frem - Nick Vlastuin
18. Coll - Taylor Garner
19. Coll - Troy Menzel
20. Adel - Adam Carter
21. Coll - Max Duffy
22. WB - Tanner Smith
23. Syd - Matthew Haynes

24. Bris - Tom Clurey

25. StK - Tim McBean
26. StK - Nathan Wright
27. Melb - Jack Viney
28. GWS - Nathan Hrovat
29. Haw - Jackson Thurlow
30. Port - Matthew McDonough
31. Port - Brodie Murdoch
32. Rich - Kyle Martin
33. Bris - Mason Shaw
34. Rich - Tom Temay
35. Ess - Jesse Lonergan
36. Carl - Dean Towers
37. Frem - Brant Colledge
38. NM - Ben Jacobs
39. Coll - Jason Pongracic
40. Frem - Dean Kent
41. StK - Nicholas Rodda
42. NM - Rory Atkins
43. Rich - Cameron Banfield
44. StK - Tom Tyquin
45. Syd - Harrison Marsh

46. WCE - Josh Simpson
47. Syd - Marco Paparone
48. NM - Anthony Bonaddio
49. Melb - Harley Montgomery
50. WB - Lachie Hunter (F/S)
51. WB - Alex Howson
52. Ess - Nic Amato
53. Melb - Todd McKay
54. Adel - Darcy Bailey
55. Ess - Nicholas Graham
56. Carl - Jacob Ballard
57. GC - Andrew Boston
58. NM - Sean Lynch
59. GC - Jordon Bourke
60. GC - Ben Duscher
61. WCE - Samual Lowrie
62. WCE - Shane Nelson
63. NM - Nathan Stark
64. Rich - Oliver Johnson
65. GWS - Tim O'Brien
66. Syd - Chase Bower
67. Syd - James Stewart

68. Haw - Marvin Warrell
69. GWS - Laine Wilkins
70. Melb - Corey Chalmers
71. Carl - Aidan Corr
72. Haw - Harrison Gill
73. Melb - Michael Close
74. Melb - Spencer White
75. Ess - Sam Heavyside
76. Carl - Matthew Dick
77. StK - Josh Saunders
78. NM - Kyle Hartigan
79. Geel - Chris Yarran (not the one from Carlton)
80. Frem - Shannon Taylor
81. WCE - Brendan Verrier
82. Coll - Kamdyn McIntosh
83. Adel - Ryan Morrison
84. Haw - Brendan Lee
85. Port - Brad Symes

86. GWS - Aliir Aliir
87. GC - Jake McKenzie
88. Melb - Paul Bower
89. WB - Sam Iles
90. Port - Matt Wallis
91. Bris - Steven Salopek
92. Rich - Mason Wood
93. Ess - Kane Mitchell
94. Carl - Sean Henson
95. StK - Emmanuel Irra
96. NM - Ben Kearns
97. Geel - Khan Haretuku
98. Frem - Jacob Surjan
99. WCE - Mack Byron-Pendergast
100. Coll - Leigh Osborne
101. Adel - Tim Sumner
102. Haw - Jack Hannath
103. Syd - Matt Rennie

104. GWS - Jarred Moore
105. GC - Anthony Tipungwuti
106. Melb - Tim Broomhead
107. WB - Jarrad Lienert
108. Port - Liam Jurrah
109. Bris - Josh Scott
110. Rich - Josh Porter
111. Ess - Justin Sherman
112. Carl - Brendon Lim
113. StK - Braedon McLean
114. NM - Daniel Robinson
115. Geel - Ashlin Brown
116. Frem - Craig Moller
117. WCE - Andrew Stokes
118. Coll - Darcy Fort
119. Adel - Byron Sumner
120. Haw - Toby Nankervis
121. Syd - Tom Hargreaves

122. GWS - Freddie Clutterbuck
123. GC - Clay Cameron
124. Melb - Kenny Ong
125. WB - Mark Seaby
126. Port - Andrew Stephen
127. Bris - Tasman Fitzgerald
128. Rich - Gideon Simon
129. Ess - Michael Mascoulis
130. Carl - Cameron Symonds
131. StK - Jarrod Hibberd
132. NM - Shaquille McKenzie
133. Geel - Louis Egger
134. Frem - Jacob Green
135. WCE - Matthew Jupp
136. Coll - Ben Richmond
137. Adel - Brian Coleman-Broome
138. Haw - Ciaran Kilkenny
139. Syd - Zac Williams

Good effort young fella, I'd be very surprised to see this many mature agers go and you just might want to look at needs a bit more for each club. E.G Salopek to Brisbane we'd have not much use for him but all in all decent effort