- Jun 19, 2006
- 12,896
- 27,759
- AFL Club
- Geelong
So if tom Atkins is dominating, smith is a brownlow fancy and Holmes is a star then why do we get destroyed in the middle all the time?
We don't???
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
So if tom Atkins is dominating, smith is a brownlow fancy and Holmes is a star then why do we get destroyed in the middle all the time?
∵ they all need to be firing at the same time and generally they ain't. Smith and Max have dropped off a bit, though Max was good on the weekend.So if tom Atkins is dominating, smith is a brownlow fancy and Holmes is a star then why do we get destroyed in the middle all the time?
The simple answer is we don't. We're ranked 2nd in the league for scores from stoppage differential. Bulldogs are 1st, Gold Coast are 3rd.So if tom Atkins is dominating, smith is a brownlow fancy and Holmes is a star then why do we get destroyed in the middle all the time?
They’re decent stats considering we are supposedly carrying the cheapest ruck in the league tooThe simple answer is we don't. We're ranked 2nd in the league for scores from stoppage differential. Bulldogs are 1st, Gold Coast are 3rd.
The extended answer for why we sometimes get beaten in midfield, is that we lack 4th/5th quality rotations, so when Smith + Holmes have a less effective game there isn't much to cover for them.

.Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Tom is not super-talented, nor is he overly athletic. A lesser character in Tom's body would be no more than a solid local footballer.They’re decent stats considering we are supposedly carrying the cheapest ruck in the league too.
On Atkins, I always thought Cameron Ling got as much out of what he had as any player I’ve seen at Geelong, it’s now Atkins. Unbelievable what he has turned his career into.

Toms response there might be a bit targeted there. Gotta keep the missus happy and reassuredTom is not super-talented, nor is he overly athletic. A lesser character in Tom's body would be no more than a solid local footballer.
Tom's career panning out the way it has is testament to the work ethic and hunger of the man, to do everything in his power to succeed.
You just know that the guy is a head down, bum up, no bullshit kind of guy. He gets on with the job, avoids the media and has laser focus on his craft.
I loved his dry response the other day when asked about Bailey Smith's Instagram Tinder collaboration. "I know nothing about it and could not care less."![]()
Harsh. Not sure what he has done to be seen as just this ‘honest toiler come good’ He is no Chris Judd but definitely has vision and skills to go along with his terrier work ethic.Tom is not super-talented, nor is he overly athletic. A lesser character in Tom's body would be no more than a solid local footballer.
Plus contested ability and defensive know how is still under the talent umbrella. Skills and vision wise I agree, he's absolutely decent too. Makes a lot of smart decisions in tricky congested situations.Harsh. Not sure what he has done to be seen as just this ‘honest toiler come good’ He is no Chris Judd but definitely has vision and skills to go along with his terrier work ethic.
If Tom started off as an honest toiler (we can agree to disagree there), he's certainly come beyond just good in my estimations.Harsh. Not sure what he has done to be seen as just this ‘honest toiler come good’ He is no Chris Judd but definitely has vision and skills to go along with his terrier work ethic.