Tom Hawkins v John Butcher

[Peck]

IMO Butcher will kick more goals, but I could be biased.

I just don't think Hawkins is that big of a goal kicker unless he goes through a huge transformation after that Grand Final - which was magnificent, but definitely an anomaly for him.

 

[Partridge]

IMO Butcher will kick more goals, but I could be biased.

I just don't think Hawkins is that big of a goal kicker unless he goes through a huge transformation after that Grand Final - which was magnificent, but definitely an anomaly for him.

To an extent, his whole finals series was actually pretty good.

 

[morell]

Next year? Hawkins of course, he has the mature body, the team around him and the structure.

Hopefully with time Butcher will be a great player but its a bit harsh to compare him to someone like Hawkins who has been in the system, and a very good one at that, for considerable time.

 

[Powerade 08]

Nick Reiwoldt kicked 21.18 in his second year playing

Franklin 31.9

So if Butcher is the next big thing you'd think somewhere between 20-30 goals max which Tom Hawkins has managed the last 3 years without pulling his finger out yet.