Traded Tom Mitchell - Traded to Collingwood as part of 3-way trade (details tbc)

[Strapping Young Lad]

IF, SYL.

There's always IFs.

I can't see a reality where Collingwood don't offer 27 for Tom, if they do he's gone.

If not and they refuse to go inside the 30, Tom stays.

Win win.

Jaeger leaving, to either GWS or Freo (GWS preferably for us), would be also the look out.

No Dom, he's going. The haggling is about the price, that's all.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Hawks supporters would be happy with a pick in the 20's for Mitchell. The 25 from Geelong or the 27 Collingwood already have. 41 is a Collingwood pipedream that just isn't worth it, if that's the best they can do we'd just keep him.

I can see that logic. I think its a little bit overs (ie i reckon mitchell is worth a 30s pick) but i think its ballpark and if pies are really keen they may do 25 or 27. Pies will probably be looking to offload a late 3rd as will geelong so im sure later picks could be shuffled around between the 3 sides as needed.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

They're both going.

What do you think they will go for?

 

[Dominic03]

No Dom, he's going. The haggling is about the price, that's all.

I'm certain he's going, but that's again IFs.

IF they fail to offer what we would take at a minimum, aka 27.

We won't trade him to Collingwood, it'll be another team or he's staying.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

What do you think they will go for?

Mitchell is likely to go for 27.
JOM, I really don't know because Freo have nothing to offer at the moment.

 

[pieman123]

Why are Collingwood chasing another 30 year old to start in their midfield.

He is 29, why did Melb chase a 28 year old ruckman?

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Mitchell is likely to go for 27.
JOM, I really don't know because Freo have nothing to offer at the moment.

I assume if it is freo that they are going to offer their 30 that they get for lobb?

 

[5minutes_of_Dew]

Mitchell is likely to go for 27.
JOM, I really don't know because Freo have nothing to offer at the moment.

I could easily see Freo sending out Lobb for 21 and forwarding it to Hawthorn for O'meara.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I could easily see Freo sending out Lobb for 21 and forwarding it to Hawthorn for O'meara.

Dogs don't even have 21 yet.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I assume if it is freo that they are going to offer their 30 that they get for lobb?

Giants had apparently tabled 18 or 19 in order to get them to ask JOM if he was open to a trade, so I doubt Hawks would accept 30.

 

[catman2006]

I could easily see Freo sending out Lobb for 21 and forwarding it to Hawthorn for O'meara.

Jom is not worth 21

 

[halfback dasher]

Jom is not worth 21

Agree , although I didn’t think Bowes and 7 were only worth a third rd pick either so what would I know .
Strange would we live in atm .

 

[TylerDurden]

Jom is not worth 21

He's worth 19 to GWS.

 

[catman2006]

He's worth 19 to GWS.

Salary dump yes but Freo not worth handing pick 21 over

 

[spudmaster]

Jom is not worth 21

A player whose salary is being paid for by another club, ie no impact on the salary cap for new side, could be worth quite a bit to clubs that are stretched already but would like to add another quality player to their list.

 

[catman2006]

Agree , although I didn’t think Bowes and 7 were only worth a third rd pick either so what would I know .
Strange would we live in atm .

wasnt worth a pick that high for a salary dump

 

[halfback dasher]

wasnt worth a pick that high for a salary dump

Sure .

 

[PieLebo87]

He is 29, why did Melb chase a 28 year old ruckman?

Don’t bother. He’s got NFI.

 

[Ash1337]

Pick around 30 is about right for a aging Mitchell imo. I think Pies dont want to give up 27 but their current offer is not enough. I doubt this gets done.

 

[Dominic03]

Pick around 30 is about right for a aging Mitchell imo. I think Pies dont want to give up 27 but their current offer is not enough. I doubt this gets done.

27 is literally a steal for Collingwood, it'll get done.

 

[ChristianBoy]

He is 29, why did Melb chase a 28 year old ruckman?

We have a younger group overall.

 

[TradeDraft]

Question would be are Collingwood willing to depart with 27 if they get nothing for Henry

I would think so as I doubt we be as Keen as we are

 

[TradeDraft]

Pick around 30 is about right for a aging Mitchell imo. I think Pies dont want to give up 27 but their current offer is not enough. I doubt this gets done.

Might be the Opposite and might be swap or Picks as well

 

[HeHateMe]

Might be the Opposite and might be swap or Picks as well

Was thinking maybe we are getting involved in the Henry trade to help it get done with some pick swapping and thats the hold up.

Geelong need to move on players for stuff Collingwood want so I'm sure between all the clubs having more picks to move around will help get them there.

 

[HeHateMe]

Just need to get melb on board haha

Melb: 33 for F2nd
Port: Ratugolea for 33
Coll: Mitchell, F1st (Geel) for Henry, 41, F4th
Haw: 25, 41 for Mitchell, F3rd
Geel: Henry, F2nd (Melb), F3rd (Haw), F4th (Coll) for Ratugolea, 25, F1st

Who's unhappy?