Tommy Walsh - HATE thread

[VDS66]

If only they would allow some genes from outside their family it might happen.

Not gonna happen, so my bet is to give them all free condoms.

Can't sure the diease, but you can at least stem the flow.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Are you suggesting something because Ferris the collingwood grub keeps asking me if I'm the Fireman.
Is that what you're asking Guide?
Because I'm not. I may be many things but I'm not the f**king Fireman.

You are an idiot for one.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

You are an idiot for one.

You can't come on a StKilda board and ... and.... oh alright, go ahead then.

 

[saber_32au]

yeah where were they when he wasn't getting a a gig? monday's experts.

The "Monday" experts were here, asking for his inclusion:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=855231&highlight=Walsh

SF25, several people (myself included) were asking for his inclusion for many many weeks. As somebody else has already stated, Lyon didn't play him for god knows what reason. He was pulling BOG performances in the VFL, but continually overlooked, and replaced by players who's performances in the VFL didn't warrant a recall to the seniors.

The fact that you pot him and call him a dog after he leaves the club for:

* Better opportunity
* More pay

is a disgrace. What he has done is no different to thousands of workers out there who change job for more opportunity and a greater pay packet. It's also no different to other AFL players out there who move clubs for greater opportunity...

This thread should be shut and idiots like you banned from this forum. Stick to SS if you want to post these rants. BF is a far better place without you.

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

This shit doesn't belong on this forum.

C'mon guys, up your acts!

 

[Cardio Carl]

One of the worst threads ever set up on Saints board and surprised Mods have allowed it to exist.

Why hate a guy who never played a game for us FFS.

Give it a rest Fish

 

[just a line monkey]

This thread started shows complete ignorance, the fact that TW was over looked afetr having about 10 BOG's in a row not to be given a crack in the seniors was purely a decision made by Ross and the way for which you are sooking is below par. This decision of TW can only be blamed on the legacy left by Ross and the selection panel, also whats being reported in the media about financial pressure, they could only offer TW what was market value for a player who had not proven him self in the seniors yet (although most of us know the quality which will come through from TW). Also other questions should be asked about a club CEO whos salary is apparently the highest in the AFL, whilest the club who he represents is recording low if any profits what so ever.

 

[Beesto]

Isn't the point being missed here by SF25. Sydney gave picks 35 and 68 for Walsh. Probably a close to fair trade for a guy who hasn't played first grade. If Walsh had stayed at the saints and been paid what he deserves the the saints would have an even bigger problem right now with the salary cap and you would be complaining about who they were going to delist. I have a sneaky suspicion that the list managers would be quite happy with picks 35 and 68 and not having a bigger salary problem.

History shows that there have been some great pickups over the years in the 30's. instead of hating someone for doing what they want you should be starting a thread on what the saints need to use the picks on. Although by some of the posts so far I am not sure that the ability to put that much thinking in is entirely evident.

 

[stkildathunda]

This thread started shows complete ignorance, the fact that TW was over looked afetr having about 10 BOG's in a row not to be given a crack in the seniors was purely a decision made by Ross and the way for which you are sooking is below par. This decision of TW can only be blamed on the legacy left by Ross and the selection panel, also whats being reported in the media about financial pressure, they could only offer TW what was market value for a player who had not proven him self in the seniors yet (although most of us know the quality which will come through from TW). Also other questions should be asked about a club CEO whos salary is apparently the highest in the AFL, whilest the club who he represents is recording low if any profits what so ever.

What a load of crap. Walsh was nowhere near BOG for 10 games for entire year, let alone 10 in a row. If he was BOG 10 weeks in row how come he didnt win the B&F or come anywhere near the winner? He finished 5th, polling less then half what the winner did, less then Mcqualter, Simpkin, Lynch who all played less games then him.

Walsh should have maybe played against Gold Coast & Adelaide but thats it. The hysteria around him by the Saints fans was plain ridiculous. He had 1 standout game in VFL and the rest were about average. If this bloke wasnt Irish he wouldnt get anywhere near the attention he did.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Worst. Thread. Ever.

 

[stkildathunda]

Worst. Thread. Ever.

But im guessing its alright to have a "roast thread" about players that should be delisted. Players that actually want to play for the Saints. Sure thats alright to bag the absolute crap out of Zac & Raph in that one...... Fact is this bloke didnt want to play for us. At least all players left on our list do want to play for RW&B.


(Not saying you yourself Freaky, just saying whole concept of bagging a hate thread on player when same thing is happening to actual Saints players is bit ridiculous)

 

[SamFisher25]

This thread should be shut and idiots like you banned from this forum. Stick to SS if you want to post these rants. BF is a far better place without you.

meh, what are you going to do?

Isn't the point being missed here by SF25. Sydney gave picks 35 and 68 for Walsh.

instead of just gobbing off.. fact is that there are a lot of saints that know a hell of a lot more about the guy than you currently do.. so i suggest you do some research, play him as a forward and watch him turn into being another steak and kidney GOP.

 

[saintsrfreak]

But im guessing its alright to have a "roast thread" about players that should be delisted. Players that actually want to play for the Saints. Sure thats alright to bag the absolute crap out of Zac & Raph in that one...... Fact is this bloke didnt want to play for us. At least all players left on our list do want to play for RW&B.


(Not saying you yourself Freaky, just saying whole concept of bagging a hate thread on player when same thing is happening to actual Saints players is bit ridiculous)

I wouldn't call listing the players that are due for delisting a hate thread. IMO Raph's been lucky to last this long and only has because he was a high pick, not bagging him, just being realistic. We can't afford to lose Zac though because as much as people love to bag him, he's our best one on one defender.

 

[SamFisher25]

I hate Hate Threads but I felt the need on balance to start one because the Ross Lyon Hate Thread was unreasonable.

Ross Lyon did wonderful things at St Kilda. His message became lost somewhere amongst the madness.

I'm not going to fall over myself tracking the progression on Walsh just because he was selfish enough to believe that he will be a star in Sydney.

 

[disgruntled goat]

Let's do a real role reversal...

What if syndey had recruited him as an Int Rookie, and then we traded for him after he spent 2 years learning the craft at Sydney?

He came to us because of more money and an opportunity to play.

What would Tommy then be?

A St Kilda player.

Did I get it right?

 

[Beesto]

instead of just gobbing off.. fact is that there are a lot of saints that know a hell of a lot more about the guy than you currently do.. so i suggest you do some research, play him as a forward and watch him turn into being another steak and kidney GOP.

maybe what should happen now is someone start a " I hate SS25 thread" and a "I hate racist supporters" and a "I hate moron know it all posters".

No wait they are all the same thread

 

[saintsrfreak]

maybe what should happen now is someone start a " I hate SS25 thread" and a "I hate racist supporters" and a "I hate moron know it all posters".

No wait they are all the same thread

For the record, the views and opinions of SamFisher25 are in no way affiliated with the views and opinions of other St Kilda Bigfooty posters

 

[saber_32au]

meh, what are you going to do?

Nothing, just expressing my opinion like you have without racist undertones...

For the record, the views and opinions of SamFisher25 are in no way affiliated with the views and opinions of other St Kilda Bigfooty posters

Agreed!!!

 

[sainter]

This thread has run its course.