Tony Shaw on WLF

[eddiesmith]

Did anyone see this idiot on White Line Fever? They had a thing on all teams so far with who is the best, worst, who to keep and who to dump of fringe players

Best: Clement. Obviously
Worst. Davis. Is he ********ing stupid?
Keep: Cole. WTF? He said he adds speed to the team? Has he seen him lately?
Get rid of: Walker. Obvious again, but is unfortunately safe due to a new contract

I would have had Woey as worst

 

[FIGJAM]

Why would you have Leon as being better performed than Woewodin?

Woey's only played one Willi game and was BOG. Leon's played heaps and has had the same amount.

Sure, Leon had a more serious injury midway through the season, but his return from said injury has been poor.

Eitherway it's all semantics. Our worst player is clearly Andrew Williams, although Donuts King may have slipped past him in recent times in the useless stakes. Lokan should have gone last year too.

We shouldn't have re-signed Walker. He's not up to it.

 

[hotpie]

Andrew Williams is not our worst player.

He's so bad he doesnt even qualify to be called a "player".

 

[MarkT]

Can't argue with Shaw re Leon. 5 years is a lot of time for little improvement. If he gets a price take it. He like's Cole and so do others. If he gets a price I'd trade but if not there are plenty to dump so we can keep him. Nothing in what you wrote that means jack as far as I can see. We are a bit paranoid re Shaw. Sad on both parts what has happened if you ask me. I hope Brayden does something over the rest of the year because it could get uglier.

 

[1980GFVideo]

not trolling just wondering what your beef is with Shawry.

He speaks it straight and doesnt try and be a comedien like that idiot Dipper.

Cant expect him to be PR for the club just because he was an ex player.

He is not charisma but doesnt try to be just speaks it down the line.

Ive never heard him say anything that the club should take offense to.

In response to MarkT, what has happened?.

 

[Perty4]

Actually didn't have too much of a problem with what he said. I would keep Cole and play him on the wing. For a draft pick 11 in the best draft ever we are not just going to delist him as hes lost confidence. Im not saying hes a gun Eddie so dont wet your pants but I am saying on a list ofw ahtever number, he is worth retaining.

If Walker has any value at all he should be offloaded, perhaps the Bullies would have traded for him with Rohdea t the helm, but not with Eade.

Williams obviously worst but with only a couple of games and we already know how ********e he is, I guess Davis gets it.

 

[Jabso]

I'd still rather Richie than Sam Power who was taken in the same draft pick 10.

 

[magpies42]

All i can say is that this cant be good for the club that an x-captain and father of a currently player is saying who shoudl be axed and who should stay! I mean if i was playing for teh pies and one of my team mates fathers came out and said i suck and i need to be axed i SHAW as hell woudl not be happy!

 

[Jabso]

I think some people do go overboard with some of Shaw's Collingwood criticism as many other teams have club greats who shoot straight or are crticial of their club. However I do beleive Shaw does try to knock Collingwood to make headlines (as a former champion and all) and is too concious on not being harsh on Collingwood, if you know what I mean.
Then again Shaw is a pretty honest man. He was talking about his son when he was in bad form for Willy and said this is a do or die year for him and it would be worrying if he can't impress this year.

 

[Magpies2005]

well thats just basic about his son, his yet to play a senior game and usually if they havent played a game in 2 years there out of there.

i personally think we might need a clean out coz the players like williams walker arnt even fringe players we would be better off getting kids and playing them at willy instead.

davis is a top player when his playing well but his bad is really bad.