Prediction Top 10 B&F at the Bye

Elite Crow

Cancelled
30k Posts 10k Posts TheBrownDog
Mar 21, 2008
56,538
77,659
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Interesting to see what the thoughts are on our B&F at the bye, which will tell us a bit about our season.

Would be fair if you haven’t put up yours don’t pot.

The closest to gets nothing.

1) Brad
2) Sloane
3) Lynch
4) Matt
5) Keath
6) Laird
7) ROB
8) Smith
9) Tex
10) Kelly

Hard to do given games missed by some, Matt, Lynch, ROB, Milera, CEY.

Brad has been the clear consistent player and coaches votes support that.

Sloane generally been consistent, the odd real quality game but not usual level.

Matt another one not at his best but still consistent enough to poll, missed games will hurt.

Lynch had a couple of quiet games early then starred before getting injured.

Keath maybe should be higher since he hasn’t missed a game and had a real good year.

Hard to read Lairds year, hasn’t had a great one but hasn’t missed a game and had some good ones.

ROB has had some stand out games and been consistent after a quiet couple of games.

Smith a solid year.

Tex a couple of shockers but reckon the coaches will give him votes even for his ok games as they know the role they want him to play plus had some good ones.

Kelly has been very consistent.

Of the misses, I could see CEY, Talia, Atkins in.

Milera missed too many games and hasn’t settled in a role.

What it tells me is we have a number of players who can improve which augurs well for the rest of the year if we can get it together.
 
Interesting to see what the thoughts are on our B&F at the bye, which will tell us a bit about our season.

Would be fair if you haven’t put up yours don’t pot.

The closest to gets nothing.

1) Brad
2) Sloane
3) Lynch
4) Matt
5) Keath
6) Laird
7) ROB
8) Smith
9) Tex
10) Kelly

Hard to do given games missed by some, Matt, Lynch, ROB, Milera, CEY.

Brad has been the clear consistent player and coaches votes support that.

Sloane generally been consistent, the odd real quality game but not usual level.

Matt another one not at his best but still consistent enough to poll, missed games will hurt.

Lynch had a couple of quiet games early then starred before getting injured.

Keath maybe should be higher since he hasn’t missed a game and had a real good year.

Hard to read Lairds year, hasn’t had a great one but hasn’t missed a game and had some good ones.

ROB has had some stand out games and been consistent after a quiet couple of games.

Smith a solid year.

Tex a couple of shockers but reckon the coaches will give him votes even for his ok games as they know the role they want him to play plus had some good ones.

Kelly has been very consistent.

Of the misses, I could see CEY, Talia, Atkins in.

Milera missed too many games and hasn’t settled in a role.

What it tells me is we have a number of players who can improve which augurs well for the rest of the year if we can get it together.
Pretty accurate I think. I'd put in CEY, and Murphy should get votes for playing his role. Probably Cam over Kelly.
 

Elite Crow

Cancelled
30k Posts 10k Posts TheBrownDog
Mar 21, 2008
56,538
77,659
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Pretty accurate I think. I'd put in CEY, and Murphy should get votes for playing his role. Probably Cam over Kelly.
I should have checked first, how many games Cam missed, 2? Don’t reckon Murphy has done enough
 

hey shorty

Cancelled
30k Posts 10k Posts TheBrownDog
Jun 15, 2005
69,233
60,483
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
AUFC, Everton, Sturt
Reckon you've got it right EC, with CEY and maybe Lynch sneaking in due to how they've played when they've played.
 
May 26, 2013
22,058
31,324
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Liverpool FC
Interesting to see what the thoughts are on our B&F at the bye, which will tell us a bit about our season.

Would be fair if you haven’t put up yours don’t pot.

The closest to gets nothing.

1) Brad
2) Sloane
3) Lynch
4) Matt
5) Keath
6) Laird
7) ROB
8) Smith
9) Tex
10) Kelly

Hard to do given games missed by some, Matt, Lynch, ROB, Milera, CEY.

Brad has been the clear consistent player and coaches votes support that.

Sloane generally been consistent, the odd real quality game but not usual level.

Matt another one not at his best but still consistent enough to poll, missed games will hurt.

Lynch had a couple of quiet games early then starred before getting injured.

Keath maybe should be higher since he hasn’t missed a game and had a real good year.

Hard to read Lairds year, hasn’t had a great one but hasn’t missed a game and had some good ones.

ROB has had some stand out games and been consistent after a quiet couple of games.

Smith a solid year.

Tex a couple of shockers but reckon the coaches will give him votes even for his ok games as they know the role they want him to play plus had some good ones.

Kelly has been very consistent.

Of the misses, I could see CEY, Talia, Atkins in.

Milera missed too many games and hasn’t settled in a role.

What it tells me is we have a number of players who can improve which augurs well for the rest of the year if we can get it together.
Would swap Keath and Matt due to games missed by Matt
 

hey shorty

Cancelled
30k Posts 10k Posts TheBrownDog
Jun 15, 2005
69,233
60,483
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
AUFC, Everton, Sturt
I’ve got Lynch 3rd
Sneaking into the 10 i mean.

I reckon he had some stinkers early days when we were travelling poorly, but his good games would have him inside the 10
 
Interesting to see what the thoughts are on our B&F at the bye, which will tell us a bit about our season.

Would be fair if you haven’t put up yours don’t pot.

The closest to gets nothing.

1) Brad
2) Sloane
3) Lynch
4) Matt
5) Keath
6) Laird
7) ROB
8) Smith
9) Tex
10) Kelly
1. Brouch
2. Sloane
3. Keath
4. Smith
5. Lynch
6. Laird
7. Mrouch
8. Talia
9. Betts
10. CEY

ROB hasn't played enough games, but expect he will be top-10 by season's end.
 

Elite Crow

Cancelled
30k Posts 10k Posts TheBrownDog
Mar 21, 2008
56,538
77,659
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
1. Brouch
2. Sloane
3. Keath
4. Smith
5. Lynch
6. Laird
7. Mrouch
8. Talia
9. Betts
10. CEY

ROB hasn't played enough games, but expect he will be top-10 by season's end.
Didn’t ROB only miss the first 2?

I think I had Keath to low and he may well be 3rd.

I’d be surprised if Smith is that high.
 
Didn’t ROB only miss the first 2?

I think I had Keath to low and he may well be 3rd.

I’d be surprised if Smith is that high.
You are correct, as I thought he had missed more.

Mrouch has missed 4 too.

So bump ROB up to #7 & CEY drops out.

Smith was consistently amongst our best early in the season.
 

Morning_Fog

Premiership Player
Jun 24, 2018
4,296
4,302
AFL Club
Adelaide
I think Talia would be inside the top 10 as well.

Since the North Melbourne debacle, our defensive unit has been rock solid. Keath and Talia have been doing their job every week. This will accumulate coaches votes.
 
Back