Top 10 Clubs In AFL History

[Always Ballin]

1. Hawthorn
5 Premierships
6 Grand Finals

2. West Coast
3 Premierships
5 Grand Finals

3. Geelong
3 Premierships
7 Grand Finals

4. Brisbane
3 Premierships
4 Grand Finals

5. Sydney
2 Premierships
6 Grand Finals

6. Collingwood
2 Premierships
5 Grand Finals

7. Essendon
2 Premierships
4 Grand Finals

8. Adelaide
2 Premierships
3 Grand Finals

9. North Melbourne
2 Premierships
3 Grand Finals

10. Port Adelaide
1 Premiership
2 Grand Finals

 

[HaroLad]

Teams or clubs?

And West Coast?

 

[Always Ballin]

Teams or clubs?

And West Coast?

Top 10 Clubs of the AFL Era (1990-)

I put WCE over Geelong because they beat them twice in GF's (92, 94)

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Ah the annual AFL is/isn't the VFL thread raises its head again.

 

[HaroLad]

Top 10 Clubs of the AFL Era (1990-)

I put WCE over Geelong because they beat them twice in GF's (92, 94)

Being first in the ladder since 2000 is irrelevant then.

As is producing the greatest player of that era, and winning a flag after losing him and our coach.

 

[Always Ballin]

Ah the annual AFL is/isn't the VFL thread raises its head again.

Don't get upset. Your VFL history still exists.

Just don't try and use it when comparing to non Victorian teams. It's stupid and foolish.

 

[ronpingwins]

#1: BRIS - LDU
#2: FREM - Dow
#3: CARL - Rayner
#4: NTH - Cerra
#5: FREM - Fogarty
#6: COLL - Coffield
#7: STK - Stephenson
#8: STK - Brayshaw
#9: WB - Bonar
#10: CARL - Brander
#11: GWS - Higgins
#12: ADEL - Naughton
#13: WCE - Clark
#14: SYD - Constable
#15: BRIS - O'Brien
#16: WB - Murphy
#17: RICH - Allen

 

[Always Ballin]

Being first in the ladder since 2000 is irrelevant then.

As is producing the greatest player of that era, and winning a flag after losing him and our coach.

Yes you would have regular season win percentage over just about anyone since 1990... But Premierships are what count the most.

Geelong might have the Win-loss % over WCE, but we have the H2H edge in Grand Finals. Hawthorn has a similar edge over us, but it doesn't really matter because they have 5 and we have 3.

 

[conrad_437]

#1: BRIS - LDU
#2: FREM - Dow
#3: CARL - Rayner
#4: NTH - Cerra
#5: FREM - Fogarty
#6: COLL - Coffield
#7: STK - Stephenson
#8: STK - Brayshaw
#9: WB - Bonar
#10: CARL - Brander
#11: GWS - Higgins
#12: ADEL - Naughton
#13: WCE - Clark
#14: SYD - Constable
#15: BRIS - O'Brien
#16: WB - Murphy
#17: RICH - Allen

Almost there.

 

[ronpingwins]

Yes you would have regular season win percentage over just about anyone since 1990... But Premierships are what count the most.

Geelong might have the Win-loss % over WCE, but we have the H2H edge in Grand Finals. Hawthorn has a similar edge over us, but it doesn't really matter because they have 5 and we have 3.

Being first in the ladder since 2000 is irrelevant then.

As is producing the greatest player of that era, and winning a flag after losing him and our coach.

 

[Ron The Bear]

Club|W|L|D|Win %
\Ge|415|241|6|62.69
\WC|375|281|6|56.65
\Ha|367|280|4|56.37
\NM|350|296|3|53.93
\Ad|338|287|2|53.91
\Co|341|298|7|52.79
\Es|338|299|9|52.32
\Sy|342|307|8|52.05
\PA|248|232|5|51.13
\WB|317|318|8|49.30
\St|307|323|9|48.04
\Ca|290|344|5|45.38
\Fr|232|288|1|44.53
\Ri|270|350|6|43.13
\Br|272|359|8|42.57
\Me|255|374|4|40.28
\GWS|52|83|2|37.96
\GC|40|113|1|25.97
\Fi|38|114|0|25.00

 

[Always Ballin]

Club|W|L|D|Win %
\Ge|415|241|6|62.69
\WC|375|281|6|56.65
\Ha|367|280|4|56.37
\NM|350|296|3|53.93
\Ad|338|287|2|53.91
\Co|341|298|7|52.79
\Es|338|299|9|52.32
\Sy|342|307|8|52.05
\PA|248|232|5|51.13
\WB|317|318|8|49.30
\St|307|323|9|48.04
\Ca|290|344|5|45.38
\Fr|232|288|1|44.53
\Ri|270|350|6|43.13
\Br|272|359|8|42.57
\Me|255|374|4|40.28
\GWS|52|83|2|37.96
\GC|40|113|1|25.97
\Fi|38|114|0|25.00

Is that W/L since 1990?

 

[Deep]

I will just list in order the 10 teams I hate the least

Geelong
Port
Essendon
Fremantle
Carlton
GWS
St Kilda
WCE
WB
Melbourne

 

[The Swert]

Move the GF thread - tick
State of Origin thread - tick
VFL/AFL thread - tick

All we need is a Buckley vs Voss vs Hird thread and we've got the off-season covered and it's only 1 November!

 

[basashi]

subtract major scandals

 

[DapperDon]

Don't get upset. Your VFL history still exists.

Just don't try and use it when comparing to non Victorian teams. It's stupid and foolish.

I get the theory, but if you're going to base it off when it began then it should start from when GWS came in. Equal footings for all

Hawks
Sydney
Bulldogs
Richmond

Everyone else is s**t

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Don't get upset. Your VFL history still exists.

Just don't try and use it when comparing to non Victorian teams. It's stupid and foolish.

I called it. Every year a non-Victorian club supporter starts one of these.

So ... how about you explain to a Hawks fan why their 1989 flag is not as good as Collingwood's 1990 flag?

 

[Always Ballin]

I called it. Every year a non-Victorian club supporter starts one of these.

So ... how about you explain to a Hawks fan why their 1989 flag is not as good as Collingwood's 1990 flag?

"The league was officially renamed the Australian Football League in 1990 to reflect the new national perspective;[14] the VFA later took over the Victorian Football League name in 1996. Functionally, the AFL gave up control over its Victorian-based minor grades at the end of 1991 – clubs continued to field reserves teams in the independent Victorian State Football League."

 

[The Swert]

I called it. Every year a West Coast supporter starts one of these.

EFA.

Yet they always pick 1990 not 1987, so that West Coast looks better.

 

[exxcessivve]

Geelong poos on WCE

 

[Power Raid]

The Hawk's achievements speak for themselves

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

"The league was officially renamed the Australian Football League in 1990 to reflect the new national perspective;[14] the VFA later took over the Victorian Football League name in 1996. Functionally, the AFL gave up control over its Victorian-based minor grades at the end of 1991 – clubs continued to field reserves teams in the independent Victorian State Football League."

Right ... so the competition changed its name.

 

[Always Ballin]

EFA.

Yet they always pick 1990 not 1987, so that West Coast looks better.

1990 was the first year of the AFL.

Besides, we had to PAY to join the league in the 80's. It cost us MILLIONS to join.

We had 17 less players than Victorian teams in the 80's.

We had to PAY for Victorian teams to come over and play us in the 80's.

 

[Ron The Bear]

Besides, we had to PAY to join the league in the 80's. It cost us MILLIONS to join.

We had to PAY for Victorian teams to come over and play us in the 80's.

Well you lot have got all the gold over there.

 

[Always Ballin]

Well you lot have got all the gold over there.

It was VFL bias. We didn't get fair and equal rights until the competition went national in 1990.