Top 10 Rookies

[collingwill]

Wait, you rate Maxwell higher than Rooke?

i dont rate maxwell that highly as a player, definantly not one of the top 10 rookies of all time but he shits on rooke. IMO

i thought you didnt want to get into that again?

 

[Tap Tap Tapperoo]

Wait, you rate Maxwell higher than Rooke?

The rookie monster is a decent player in a great side..definitely not worthy of a spot amongst those names.

Maxwell > Rooke

 

[collingwill]

The rookie monster is a decent player in a great side..definitely not worthy of a spot amongst those names.

Maxwell > Rooke

i reckon he's shit.

disposals ave, 11
goal ave, 0.4

defensive fwd or not thats shit, ling averages more goals than rooke and lings a midfield tagger.

 

[Bartel]

Greg Broughton was pretty amazing for someone that was a rookie and got picked from the WAFL, pretty gunny.

 

[CarnTheTiges]

Greg Broughton was pretty amazing for someone that was a rookie and got picked from the WAFL, pretty gunny.

He's good, but only the start of his career, give him time.

 

[Tulip]

Maxwell (>) Rooke

 

[melbournemartin]

Playing for Collingwood obviously has it's advantages.


Nick Maxwell - 118 games, 12.9 possessions, 4.5 marks, 0.2 goals, 2.6 tackles.

Michael Firrito - 127 games, 13.4 possessions, 3.7 marks, 0.2 goals, 2.6 tackles.



I'll take comfort in the knowledge that Leigh Adams, Matt Campbell, Nathan Grima and Marcus White will all make their way in to that list in 5 or 6 years.

You honestly think that all of those 4 players will be in the top 10 rookies of all time list?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Nick Maxwell is well and truly behind Tarkyn Lockyer and Harry O'Brien in vying for a spot on this list in my eyes.

How Lockyer's missed is beyond me.

 

[danger_to_walker]

Jason Porplyzia was on the rookie list, was then axed and re-drafted the following year. He has turned out to be a fairly handy player thus far, though probably not top 10 as of yet.

 

[strengthwithin]

as an out and out FB id have him against the highlighted names, maybe glass as well on this year at least, presty is a very very good FB, believe me, i cant remember the last time someones got hold of him TBH, at FB at least, riewoldt got him at CHB during the finals, but tippet had no idea, kicked 4 goals from free kicks but presty only gave him one.

Glass was the eagles B+F this year above LeCras and Hurn. Don't disregard his input just because you don't see him play every week.

Very very consistent.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

ah Coxy you Ledg

 

[Tarkyn_24]

i reckon he's shit.

disposals ave, 11
goal ave, 0.4

defensive fwd or not thats shit, ling averages more goals than rooke and lings a midfield tagger.

Lockyer plays the same role better and got snubbed. Rooke isn't anywhere near it.