Opinion Top 15 midfielders 2009

[Foley is a Gun #]

in my opinion the top 20 is:
1 Gary Ablett
2 Chris Judd
3 Dane Swan
4 Leigh Montagna
5 Sam Mitchell
6 Lenny Hayes
7 Nick Dal Santo
8 Matthew Boyd
9 Joel Selwood
10 Marc Murphy
11 Adam Goodes
12 Shane Tuck
13 Brendan Goddard
14 Scott Pendelbury
15 Brad Sewell
16 Joel Corey
17 Jimmy Bartel

I did my Top 17, but i wanna hear some top 15's
Unlucky: Simon Black, Luke Power, Bryce Gibbs, Kane Cornes, Brett Kirk, Adam Cooney, Matthew Priddis

 

[AG]

You say you are doing a top 20, you do a top 17 but you want a top 15? You need Watson in your list.

1. Gary Ablett
2. Lenny Hayes
3. Leigh Montagna
4. Chris Judd
5. Dane Swan
6. Nick Dal Santo
7. Joel Selwood
8. Matthew Boyd
9. Brad Sewell
10. Scott Pendlebury
11. Jobe Watson
12. Marc Murphy
13. Simon Black
14. Sam Mitchell
15. Scott Thompson

Unlucky: O'Keefe, Power, Edwards, Jackson, Tuck, Winderlich, Hasleby, Bartel, Corey, K.Cornes, Kirk, J.Bolton, A.Selwood, Cross, Cooney

I haven't included Davis, Goodes, Goddard, Davey and Didak because I have them as HB or HF flankers.

 

[smiddaz123]

This is the top 20.

But I really did 17.

Now give me your top 15 guys.

I love it haha.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

This is the top 20.

But I really did 17.

Now give me your top 15 guys.

I love it haha.

stop being a ****ing smartass wanka

 

[DG-Man]

1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Swan
4. Hayes
5. Montagna
6. Dal Santo
7. Selwood
8. Boyd
9. Murphy
10. Pendlebury
11. Watson
12. Sewell
13. Black
14. Mitchell
15. Jackson

 

[hamush]

1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Swan
4. Hayes
5. Montagna
6. Dal Santo
7. Selwood
8. Boyd
9. Murphy
10. Pendlebury
11. Watson
12. Sewell
13. Black
14. Mitchell
15. Jackson

same except out jackson in power and swap ablett with judd

 

[Pessimistic]

Rate them head to head (in actual games) and watch Sewell rocket to near the top of that list.

PS how did Bartel and Selwood go when the heat was on them as the main midfielders v brisbane ?

 

[AG]

PS how did Bartel and Selwood go when the heat was on them as the main midfielders v brisbane ?

Selwood has been the number 2 midfielder all year and Bartel played one of the best individual games so far this year in the biggest match of the season against St Kilda.

 

[LoveLeon]

in my opinion the top 20 is:
1 Gary Ablett
2 Chris Judd
3 Dane Swan
4 Leigh Montagna
5 Sam Mitchell
6 Lenny Hayes
7 Nick Dal Santo
8 Matthew Boyd
9 Joel Selwood
10 Marc Murphy
11 Adam Goodes
12 Shane Tuck
13 Brendan Goddard
14 Scott Pendelbury
15 Brad Sewell
16 Joel Corey
17 Jimmy Bartel

I did my Top 17, but i wanna hear some top 15's
Unlucky: Simon Black, Luke Power, Bryce Gibbs, Kane Cornes, Brett Kirk, Adam Cooney, Matthew Priddis

Sewell, Bartel, Pendlebury, K.Cornes, Black all above Tuck.

 

[Hawka08]

Sewell, Bartel, Pendlebury, K.Cornes, Black all above Tuck.

EASY and how is shane tuck even in there ?? Goddard is way better aswell your a joke Sewell would smash him

 

[alinghi]

No Cooney or Deledio? Or they don't count as mids?

 

[RPetterd15]

1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Swan
4. Hayes
5. Montagna
6. Selwood
7. Boyd
8. Sewell
9. Dal Santo
10. Murphy
11. Pendlebury
12. Watson
13. Black
14. Mitchell
15. K.Cornes

 

[Coooooooneyyyyyyyy]

hmmmm dunno about cornes.

 

[Hutto]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Chris Judd
3. Dane Swan
4. Leigh Montagna
5. Nick Dal Santo
6. Lenny Hayes
7. Joel Selwwod
8. Matthew Boyd
9. Sam Mitchell
10. Jimmy Bartel
11. Marc murphy
12. Adam Goodes
13. Bernie Vince
14. Scott Pendlebury
15. Simon Black

 

[Seb78]

1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Swan
4. Hayes
5. Selwood
6. Dal Santo
7. Montagna
8. Boyd
9. Watson
10. Pendlebury
11. Cross
12. Sewell
13. Black
14. Vince
15. Jackson

 

[Biggy_Boy]

1. Ablett
2. Bartel
3. Selwood
4. Corey
5. Chapman
6. Ling
7. Kelly
8. Varcoe
9. Byrnes
10. Hogan
11. Ablett w/hair
12. Enright
13. Mackie
14. Wojak
15. Stokes

 

[Big Nasty]

1) Gary Ablett
2) Lenny Hayes
3) Dane Swan
4) Chris Judd
5) Joel Selwood
6) Matthew Boyd
7) Bernie Vince
8) Leigh Montagna
9) Nick Dal Santo
10) Jobe Watson
11) Marc Murphy
12) Brad Sewell
13) Simon Black
14) Scott Pendlebury
15) Sam Mitchell

 

[tim_saints]

You say you are doing a top 20, you do a top 17 but you want a top 15? You need Watson in your list.

1. Gary Ablett
2. Lenny Hayes
3. Leigh Montagna
4. Chris Judd
5. Dane Swan
6. Nick Dal Santo
7. Joel Selwood
8. Matthew Boyd
9. Brad Sewell
10. Scott Pendlebury
11. Jobe Watson
12. Marc Murphy
13. Simon Black
14. Sam Mitchell
15. Scott Thompson

Unlucky: O'Keefe, Power, Edwards, Jackson, Tuck, Winderlich, Hasleby, Bartel, Corey, K.Cornes, Kirk, J.Bolton, A.Selwood, Cross, Cooney

I haven't included Davis, Goodes, Goddard, Davey and Didak because I have them as HB or HF flankers.

This one's great I agree totally with it well done mate . Great to see Lenny Hayes is being recognized as one of the most elite midfielders in the game.

 

[Rough_Edges]

this thread lacks Vince.

 

[AG]

this thread lacks Vince.

Yeah I'd swap Vince in for Thompson in my list.

There is no doubt that Ablett and Hayes are no.1 and no.2 at the moment.

 

[deliciouss]

Tyson Edwards has had 1 of his best seasons.

 

[TheBigT]

no particular order
Ablett
Hayes
Boyd
Swan
Judd
Black
Vince
Selwood
Dal Santo
Montagna
Watson
Sewell
Pendlebury
Jackson
Murphy

 

[Juddbemetron]

In no order
Judd
Swan
Ablett
VInce
Murphy
Dal Santo
Boyd
Selwood
Montagan
Hayes
Gibbs
Pendelbury
Black
Watson
Sewell

thats 15

 

[Tom27]

in my opinion the top 20 is:
1 Gary Ablett
2 Chris Judd
3 Dane Swan
4 Leigh Montagna
5 Sam Mitchell
6 Lenny Hayes
7 Nick Dal Santo
8 Matthew Boyd
9 Joel Selwood
10 Marc Murphy
11 Adam Goodes
12 Shane Tuck
13 Brendan Goddard
14 Scott Pendelbury
15 Brad Sewell
16 Joel Corey
17 Jimmy Bartel

I did my Top 17, but i wanna hear some top 15's
Unlucky: Simon Black, Luke Power, Bryce Gibbs, Kane Cornes, Brett Kirk, Adam Cooney, Matthew Priddis

Why is shane tuck above jimmy Bartel? Tuck has never won a Brownlow

 

[Zahasouvlakis]

Why is shane tuck above jimmy Bartel? Tuck has never won a Brownlow

Because he plays for richmond, derrr.