Top 15 players 07 - 09 Drafts

Bailey01

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 25, 2013
6,286
2,450
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Norwood Redlegs, Tennis
Breust, Gunston, Stratton, Shiels, Rioli, Duryea, Suckling.

Not a bad crop. Question marks surrounding Whitecross (can he get over his knees?) and Schoey.
No we originally picked Gunston!!!
 

94_Eagles

Brownlow Medallist
Suspended
Jul 22, 2004
14,519
4,776
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Wildcats Warriors Glory Pelicans
You pretty much calling our midfield rubbish as an excuse for Cotchin voting highly in 2012. Bender 571 nailed it...why haven't more poor teams players won Brownlows?

429944891-1a2141c.jpg
 

MAAAATTDAAAAMON

Club Legend
Jun 6, 2010
1,785
795
NSW
AFL Club
Essendon
Bump. My original effort was bloody horrible. Revised. Not easy.

1. P. Dangerfield
2. N. Fyfe
3. A. Rance
4. C. Rioli
5. D. Hannebery
6. D. Martin
7. H. Taylor
8. J. Gunston
9. M. Gawn
10. D. Beams
11. N. Natanui
12. T. Walker
13. M. Hurley
14. C. Hooker
15. J. Carlisle
16. C. Ward
17. R. Sloane
18. S. Sidebottom
19. S. Mumford
20. L. Shuey

Unlucky:
T. Cotchin
M. Barlow
J. Ziebell
P. Davis
S. Hill
T. Scully
P. Hanley
 
May 28, 2013
25,313
27,132
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Seattle Seahawks
Bump. My original effort was bloody horrible. Revised. Not easy.

1. P. Dangerfield
2. N. Fyfe
3. A. Rance
4. C. Rioli
5. D. Hannebery
6. D. Martin
7. H. Taylor
8. J. Gunston
9. M. Gawn
10. D. Beams
11. N. Natanui
12. T. Walker
13. M. Hurley
14. C. Hooker
15. J. Carlisle
16. C. Ward
17. R. Sloane
18. S. Sidebottom
19. S. Mumford
20. L. Shuey

Unlucky:
T. Cotchin
M. Barlow
J. Ziebell
P. Davis
S. Hill
T. Scully
P. Hanley
What has Carlisle done to make the list? He has done very little in a team that has been below average.
 
1.P.Dangerfield
2.J.Grimes
3.M.Hurley
4.C.Rioli
5.S.Hill
6.J.Trengove
7.D.Martin
8.D.Rich
9.T.Cochin
10.M.Kruzer
11.H.Taylor
12.S.Sidebottom
13.T.Scully
14.D.Hannerbury
15.D.Beams
Dangerfield must've had a good game on the weekend.
Can you elaborate why you rate Danger at one? Thought it was going to be a Crows fan for sure.
To me personally Dangerfield reminds me of a young Riccouto (who I personally rate as the best midfielder of the late 90's early 00's).
He is big, strong can play midfield and then go forward and take a mark and kick goals. I realise most people wont agree with me, but if I had my choice I would take him over any of the players in the 07-09 drafts long term.
Not too bad for a prediction from 6 years ago. Probably hurt by the Melbourne bias a little bit (Grimes & Trengove).
Fair to say picking Danger as the clear number 1 wasn't a popular call back then, but a pretty bloody good one none the less
 
May 28, 2013
25,313
27,132
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Seattle Seahawks
Career to date each draft:

2007:
1) Danger
2) Rance
3) Taylor
4) Rioli
5) Walker
6) Cotchin
7) Hooker
8) Ward
9) Steven
10) Wood

2008:
1) Nic Nat
2) Hannebury
3) Hurley
4) Beams
5) Sloane
6) Sidebottom
7) Bruest
8) Shuey
9) Ziebell
10) Hill

20090
1) Fyfe
2) Talia
3) Martin
4) Gunston
5) Gawn
6) Scully
7) Cunnington
8) Barlow
9) Duncan
10) Stratton
 
Back