Competitions TOP 20 DRAFT - 2014

[gandaal]

1. Saints........ Petracca
2. Melb .......... Brayshaw
3. Melb .......... McCartin
4. GWS .......... Laverde
5. C’wood ...... De Goey
6. GWS .......... Ahern
7. GWS .......... Goddard
8. G.C. ............ Pickett

9. C’wood ....... Moore
10. G’long ...... Lever
11. W.C. ........ Cockatoo
12. R’mond .... Langford
13. Freo ......... Wright
14. Adel ......... Marchbank
15. G.C. ......... Durdin
16. North ....... Weller
17. E’don ....... Duggan
18. Syd .......... Heeney
19.C’ton ........ Mckenzie
20. E’don ....... Garlett


#19................ McKenzie

#28................ Boekhorst

#61................Pittonet

#65................ Saad

Making a change.

I've got a feeling...

 

[Matty411]

Making a change.

I've got a feeling...

Which McKenzie?!

 

[gandaal]

Which McKenzie?!

Fair point. Reece.

 

[Matty411]

Thought you meant the big guy. Just think we're going to get a slider/real value at our picks, and I'd be happy with Reece at 28, but not at 19 necessarily. Depends what Rogers wants - Reece won't be there at 28 imo.

 

[gillo94]

Thought long and hard 1.0 edition of top21 picks

1 Petracca - Saints
2 Brayshaw - Demons
3 McCartin - Demons
4 Lever - GWS
5 Laverde - Pies
6 Pickett - GWS
7 Goddard - GWS
8 Weller - Suns
9 Moore f/s - Pies
10 Marchbank - Cats
11 Duggan - Eagles
12 Wright - Tigers
13 Cookatoo - Freo
14 Durdin - Crows
15 Suns - Duggan
16 De Goey - North
17 Essendon - Ahern
18 - Heeney - Swans
19 - Ellis - BLUES!!!
20 - Lamb - Bombers
21 - McKenzie - Saints

 

[gandaal]

Thought you meant the big guy. Just think we're going to get a slider/real value at our picks, and I'd be happy with Reece at 28, but not at 19 necessarily. Depends what Rogers wants - Reece won't be there at 28 imo.

What makes Reece different to Tom Hawkins as a 18 year old prospect?

Exactly the same queries over Tom at the time, and they were claiming that Tom would be number 1 with a bullet at the time in an open draft.

Can we really by pass a guy who could be our Tom Boyd for the next 10 years (without the multi-million dollar contract)?

 

[etsal1]

1. Saints........Petracca
2. Melb ..........Brayshaw
3. Melb ..........McCartin
4. GWS ..........Pickett
5. C’wood ......Laverde
6. GWS ..........Ahern
7. GWS ..........Goddard
8. G.C. ............Duggan
9. C’wood .......Moore
10. G’long ......De Goey
11. W.C. ........Cockatoo
12. R’mond ....Ellis
13. Freo .........Wright
14. Adel .........Durdin
15. G.C. .........Langford
16. North .......Lever
17. E’don .......Garlett
18. Syd ..........Heeney
19.C’ton ........Weller
20. E’don .......Blakely


#19................Weller

#28................Menadue

#61................Boekhurst

#65................Anderson

 

[gillo94]

1. Saints........Petracca
2. Melb ..........Brayshaw
3. Melb ..........McCartin
4. GWS ..........Pickett
5. C’wood ......Laverde
6. GWS ..........Lever
7. GWS ..........Goddard
8. G.C. ............De Goey
9. C’wood .......Moore
10. G’long ......Wright
11. W.C. ........Cockatoo
12. R’mond ....Duggan
13. Freo .........Durdin
14. Adel .........Maynard
15. G.C. .........Langford
16. North .......Ahern
17. E’don .......Garlett
18. Syd ..........Heeney
19.C’ton ........Weller
20. E’don .......Blakely


#19................Weller

#28................Menadue

#61................Boekhurst

#65................Anderson

Just can't see Weller getting past North or Bombers at this stage

 

[etsal1]

Just can't see Weller getting past North or Bombers at this stage

Who knows but it could happen. IF it doesn't, just means someone else falls to us

 

[gillo94]

Who knows but it could happen. IF it doesn't, just means someone else falls to us

Agree someone always usually does drop but just rate him ahead of guys like Ahern, Cookatoo, Langford & Garlett. I wouldn't mind if Langford drop but expect Suns to pounce on him from what I've been reading

I like your phantom draft except for Weller and no Marchbank, early prediction top10 to Cats

 

[bmaurizio]

1. Saints........Petracca
2. Melb ..........Brayshaw
3. Melb ..........Lever
4. GWS ..........McCartin
5. C’wood ......Laverde
6. GWS ..........Ahern
7. GWS ..........Pickett
8. G.C. ............Weller
9. C’wood .......Moore
10. G’long ......Wright
11. W.C. ........Durdin
12. R’mond ....Duggan
13. Freo .........Goddard
14. Adel .........McKenzie
15. G.C. .........Garlett
16. North .......Cockatoo
17. E’don .......De Goey
18. Syd ..........Heeney
19.C’ton ........Langford
20. E’don .......Blakely

#19...............Langford

#28................Lamb

#61.................Hamilton

#65.................Butler

 

[gillo94]

1. Saints........Petracca
2. Melb ..........Brayshaw
3. Melb ..........Lever
4. GWS ..........McCartin
5. C’wood ......Laverde
6. GWS ..........Ahern
7. GWS ..........Pickett
8. G.C. ............Weller
9. C’wood .......Moore
10. G’long ......Wright
11. W.C. ........Durdin
12. R’mond ....Duggan
13. Freo .........Goddard
14. Adel .........McKenzie
15. G.C. .........Garlett
16. North .......Cockatoo
17. E’don .......De Goey
18. Syd ..........Heeney
19.C’ton ........Langford
20. E’don .......Blakely

#19...............Langford

#28................Lamb

#61.................Hamilton

#65.................Butler

I like its ok. I think top 3 won't change with Petracca, Brayshaw and McCartin. Demons don't need Lever with Frost pickup so can draft McCartin and build a forward line around Hogan.

I just don't see this phantom draft happening just yet. But I do like it!

 

[Doc2Drej]

1. Saints........Petracca
2. Melb ..........Brayshaw
3. Melb ..........McCartin
4. GWS ..........Laverde
5. C’wood ......De Goey
6. GWS ..........Goddard
7. GWS ..........Pickett
8. G.C. ............Langford
9. C’wood .......Moore
10. G’long ......Lever
11. W.C. ........Ahern
12. R’mond ....Duggan
13. Freo .........Durdin
14. Adel .........Wright
15. G.C. .........Marchbank
16. North .......Cockatoo
17. E’don .......Lamb
18. Syd ..........Heeney
19.C’ton ........Weller
20. E’don .......Ellis


#19................Weller

#28................Menadue

#61................Lonie

#65................Boekhorst

 

[gandaal]

Doc2Drej have you got heeney and Wellar the wrong way around?

 

[etsal1]

Rumours of Mckenzie to Adelaide would be very helpful for us.

 

[Doc2Drej]

Doc2Drej have you got heeney and Wellar the wrong way around?

Yep, sorry, ill change that. Must have been wishful thinking

 

[Doc2Drej]

Im pretty happy with my phantom so far, but I was just wondering which two out of Lonie, Daniel, Boekhorst and Pittonet we would be most likely to draft, and who if any would be most likely gone by then.

 

[HARKER]

#19................Weller
#28................Menadue
#61................Lonie
#65................Boekhorst

Would be very happy should this come about

 

[Blue By Blood]

11 days folks... just happens to coincide with getting my final year uni exam marks back. Dream scenario would be:
19: Lachie Weller (class)
28: Connor Menadue (speed)
61: Toby McLean (x-factor fwd)
65: Hammelmann (young tall)

Rookie Draft
Boekhorst (outside runner)
Baulderstone (23yr old ruck)
Best available

 

[HARKER]

Come on guys and girls.

Get your top 20's in

 

[Hussey14]

1. Saints........Petracca
2. Melb ..........Brayshaw
3. Melb ..........McCartin
4. GWS ..........Laverde
5. C’wood ......Pickett
6. GWS ..........De Goey
7. GWS ..........Goddard
8. G.C. ............Weller
9. C’wood .......Moore
10. G’long ......Lever
11. W.C. ........Ahern
12. R’mond ....Duggan
13. Freo .........Durdin
14. Adel .........Wright
15. G.C. .........Langford
16. North .......Ellis
17. E’don .......Blakely
18. Syd ..........Heeney
19.C’ton ........Harchbank
20. E’don .......Lamb


#19................Ellis

#28................Menadue

#61................Drummond

#65................Boekhorst

 

[TGR]

What makes Reece different to Tom Hawkins as a 18 year old prospect?

Exactly the same queries over Tom at the time, and they were claiming that Tom would be number 1 with a bullet at the time in an open draft.

Can we really by pass a guy who could be our Tom Boyd for the next 10 years (without the multi-million dollar contract)?

The difference being that Hawkins destroyed all of the best defenders his year had to offer. Eric Mackenzie would still be having nightmares from their matchup.

Reece hasn't got a hold of the better key position defenders of this year.

He needs a bit more refining than Tom did and will take a while.

 

[Matty411]

Alright, have re-jigged my top 20... here goes.

1. Petracca
2. McCartin
3. Brayshaw
4. Pickett
5. De Goey
6. Goddard
7. Laverde
8. Duggan
9. Moore
10. Wright
11. Garlett
12. Ellis
13. Durdin
14. Lever
15. Langford
16. Cockatoo
17. Ahern
18. Heeney
19. Weller
20. Lamb

19. Weller
28. D McKenzie
61. Boekhorst
65. Wilkinson

 

[Cringle]

Alright, have re-jigged my top 20... here goes.

1. Petracca
2. McCartin
3. Brayshaw
4. Pickett
5. De Goey
6. Goddard
7. Laverde
8. Duggan
9. Moore
10. Wright
11. Garlett
12. Ellis
13. Durdin
14. Lever
15. Langford
16. Cockatoo
17. Ahern
18. Heeney
19. Weller
20. Lamb

19. Weller
28. D McKenzie
61. Boekhorst
65. Wilkinson

No wishful thinking at all there Matty..

 

[Matty411]

No wishful thinking at all there Matty..

Honestly trying to work out where to fit the top rated guys, where I could see them play and what's been said about types of players etc - I can't help but feel strongly that one of the highly rated guys (Duggan/Weller/Ahern/Ellis) will drop. In this scenario, its Weller.