Opinion Top 50 2012

[Dwight Schrute]

No votes for Ablett?

Pretty sure hes only doing Pies players(He isnt the Maker of the top 50)

I would give Ablett an 8-9, hardly any impact on the game for that many possies.

 

[Heater39]

No votes for Ablett?

Just voting on the pies players in contention for the top 50. It's hard enough for me to rate the players from my team let alone the opposition

 

[jabbers]

My Votes vs GCS

9- Thomas
8- Beams
7- Cloke
6- Pendles (very good before he went off imo)
5- Sidey

Pendlebury deserved a 9. He set the game up in the first half. Cant be blamed for not playing in the second half.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Here's round 10.
As always, let me know what you think:

 

[Igloo]

You've got Lake in the 50 as well as unlucky.

 

[eaglespremiers]

You've got Lake in the 50 as well as unlucky.

Darn it, one always slips through.

 

[jabbers]

Can't understand how Watson would be rated over Pendlebury. Pendlebury was best on ground at half time before he was injured.

 

[Slattery_20]

Can't understand how Watson would be rated over Pendlebury. Pendlebury was best on ground at half time before he was injured.

Watson was best on ground. At full time.

 

[Slattery_20]

Ess-Dees match

Watson great. Had him best on, ahead of Jones even in a losing side. Zaharakis solid. Bad night for most other Essendon players.
Other dees - Moloney pretty good, Grimes good, Howe very good and Colin ****ing Garland good as well.

 

[00Stinger]

Rankings from Melb v Ess:
9 - Jobe Watson
8 - Nathan Jones
7 - David Zaharakis
6 - Brent Stanton, Ben Howlett
5 - Courtney Dempsey, Paddy Ryder
4 - Stewart Crameri

1 out of 8 of the best players despite winning the game?

 

[Surkin]

1 out of 8 of the best players despite winning the game?

He was only rating players in contention for the top 50.

Jones was the only Dees player he rates near there ATM. With apologies to Mitch Clark that is fair enough.

 

[Surkin]

Lenny Hayes too high. I love him as much as the next bloke but there is no way he has been better than Griffen or Dangerfield so far this year.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Lenny Hayes too high. I love him as much as the next bloke but there is no way he has been better than Griffen or Dangerfield so far this year.

Thanks, will rectify.

 

[eaglespremiers]

1 out of 8 of the best players despite winning the game?

Scores of 5 & 4 place these players no where near the best on the ground.

 

[robertg22]

On a side note the list displays in full with the new BF design, looks much better

 

[AG]

Yeah, I hated it when they reduced the picture size on the old site.

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Geel v Carl:
9 - Simpson
8 - Selwood
7 - Judd, Chapman
6 -Taylor, Robinson
5 - Johnson
3 - Hawkins, Henderson

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Rich v Frem:
8 - Cotchin, Tuck
5 - Maric
4 - Deledio, Martin
3 - Riewoldt, Rance

 

[LordJimmy]

Lenny Hayes too high. I love him as much as the next bloke but there is no way he has been better than Griffen or Dangerfield so far this year.

Pfft... wait, who is Griffen?

Ryan Griffen is nowhere near Hayes this year.

Anyway, Nick Riewoldt and Jason Blake are making big cases for coming in, now. Riewoldt should be. Blake is a line/ball call.

 

[eaglespremiers]

From St Kilda v Suns:
10 - Riewoldt
8 - Armitage
7 - Dal Santo
6 - Hayes, Goddard
4 - Ablett

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Ess v Syd:
10 - Watson
9 - Howlett, Richards
8 - Jetta
7 - Kennedy, Jack
6 - Stanton, Hooker, Ryder
2 - Crameri

 

[AG]

Watson goes 1st if Pendles has a quiet one imo. Cotchin into the top 4.

1. Kennedy (I'd have him 4th or 5th, with the above three ahead of him (pending Thompson's game whether it's 4th or 5th))
2. Richards (teens, surely AA FB at this stage, was brilliant)
3. Jetta (well in then 50 now)
4. Jack (likewise)
-------------------------------
That's still it from the Swans. A clear top 4 and the next in line are too even.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Watson is number one already and Pendlebury is out injured...

 

[AG]

Ha, good point.

1. Watson
2. Pendlebury
3. Cotchin
4/5. Thompson/Kennedy

That would be my top 5.

 

[StringyDog]

From Ess v Syd:
10 - Watson
9 - Howlett, Richards
8 - Jetta
7 - Kennedy, Jack
6 - Stanton, Hooker, Ryder
2 - Crameri

Seems harsh on Jetta, he was highly influential and the game breaker and pretty generous to Stanton, he was pathetic.