Opinion Top 50 2012

[eaglespremiers]

From Syd v Bris:
8 - Kennedy, Richards
7 - Jack
6 - Jetta
5 - Rockliff
4 - Redden

 

[AG]

Looks fine. Kennedy was the best of the lot.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Looks fine. Kennedy was the best of the lot.

You'd be happy to see Goodes back in fine form?
Also Reid finally delivered big time. Was he struggling with an injury previously?

 

[AG]

Apparently he was injured early in the year but that might have just been fluff to cover up his poor form. Definitely jumping at the ball with more confidence the past few weeks.

 

[DerpWerls]

From Melb v Rich:
9 - Tuck, Grigg
8 - Jones, Cotchin
7 - Deledio
6 - Maric, Riewoldt

Didn't catch the game, what are people's thoughts?

About right. Jones is indeed a gun IMO

 

[juss]

h

From Melb v Rich:
9 - Tuck, Grigg
8 - Jones, Cotchin
7 - Deledio
6 - Maric, Riewoldt

Didn't catch the game, what are people's thoughts?

Rance while not outstanding did a good job, wasn't scored heavily on and though it was a fairly easy day at the office he still got the job done when required. I'd give him a 6. Apart from that, pretty good.

 

[eaglespremiers]

From StK v Ess:
9 - McEvoy
8 - Dal Santo, Riewoldt
7 - Dempsey, Hayes
6 - Watson, Howlett
5 - Ryder, Stanton
4 - Hooker

 

[eaglespremiers]

From PA v Adel:
10 - Jacobs
9 - Thompson
8 - Chaplin
7 - Sloane, Surjan
6 - Dangerfield
5 - Ebert
3 - Carlisle

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Good effort on the bombers/saints game

From a bombers perspective I'd have it

8. Dempsey
7. Howlett
5. Watson, Ryder
4. Stanton
2. Hooker

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Haw v GWS:
10 - Rioli
9 - Lewis
8 - Mitchell, Roughead
7 - Franklin, Ward

 

[lamaros]

Good effort on the bombers/saints game

From a bombers perspective I'd have it

8. Dempsey
7. Howlett
5. Watson, Ryder
4. Stanton
2. Hooker

Aye, Hooker was awful. Just awful. I don't think he was a three last week, but he was a two in that one. Stanton was better than a 5 though. Looks about equal with Watson for me.

 

[raskolnikov]

I'd give watson a 7 and Stanton a 6.

 

[Ravenous Crow]

From PA v Adel:
10 - Jacobs
9 - Thompson
8 - Chaplin
7 - Sloane, Surjan
6 - Dangerfield
5 - Ebert
3 - Carlisle

Way, way, way too high. The stats look good but his turnovers and lack of defensive influence killed Port.

Is Dan Talia on your radar? Having a very good year but only just starting to catch the Vic media's attention.

 

[hawkman]

From Haw v GWS:
10 - Rioli
9 - Lewis
8 - Mitchell, Roughead
7 - Franklin, Ward

From your top 50, would give Birchall an 8 as well

 

[Pie in the Sky]

Great effort. Not convinced Sidebottom is the sixth best player in the league, has had a great year but has dropped off a little of late. Would rank Beams, Pendlebury and maybe Swan above him. Good work though.

 

[LordJimmy]

Wondering how Deledio has dropped from about 5/6th to 13th in the space of 3 weeks based off 1 poor game and good 2 games?

lulz try Hayes.

Best player in the comp and every week he doesn't get "573782 touches 5673% contested" they knock him down five or six places.

 

[The Prosecutor]

lulz try Hayes.

Best player in the comp and every week he doesn't get "573782 touches 5673% contested" they knock him down five or six places.

Hayes is no where near being the best player in the competition.

 

[LordJimmy]

Hayes is no where near being the best player in the competition.

You are objectively wrong.

 

[The Prosecutor]

You are objectively wrong.

You really are a deluded fool.

 

[robertg22]

You are objectively wrong.

He's not in the top 20 players in the comp.

 

[policegetthatman]

lulz try Hayes.

Best player in the comp and every week he doesn't get "573782 touches 5673% contested" they knock him down five or six places.

lel

 

[00Stinger]

Quick Question: Robinson v Judd?
I am considering bringing one of these guys into the 50 on the back of their good games last night.
If you had to chose either Carlton player, who deserves to come in?
Or do neither?

Robinson has had the better year

 

[eaglespremiers]

Couple of players I am probably going to be bringing in this week:
Dean Cox
Matt Priddis
Sam Jacobs
Nick Riewoldt
Mitch Robinson
Does anyone have any objections?

Anyone else I should consider?
Adcock? Greene? Pavlich? Kelly? Bennell?

 

[Roobs321]

Andrew Gaff not even in the unluckies? absurd. Other than that, a good 50.

Just regarding Priddis, it is worth noting that he has missed 3 games this year, plus was concussed early in the essendon game. So despite his consistent excellence, he has missed a few.

 

[Seldom Seen Kid]

Big fan of the effort that's going into this, well done eaglespremiers and others.

Pearce Hanley should be worth a look, pretty solid form most of the year and been Brisbane's best player the last few weeks. Would be arguably ahead of Adcock on form